Takashi Iwai wrote:
>
> Do you really get Oops with 2.6.17-final, too?
> AFAIK, there was a bug in the early 2.6.17-rc regarding OSS emulation,
> but it got fixed in the later rc.
I confirm that the only oops I got was with 2.6.17-rc1
> The behavior of invalid O_* flag seems incompatible with the older
> version. Although I don't think it's totally wrong behavior, surely
> better to keep the compatibility. The patch below should fix it.
I don't care: I have changed my player.
I also tend to agree that opening /dev/dsp read write was not a good
idea, so I would not criticise the new behaviour.
Each version of Linux 2.6 tend to break some softwares due to subtil
changes. What is bad is that these changes tend to be not announced,
but on the other hand the kernel mailing list is very responsive,
so all in all it might be a reasonable way to go.
At Wed, 02 Aug 2006 18:35:26 GMT,
Hubert Tonneau wrote:
>
> Takashi Iwai wrote:
> >
> > Do you really get Oops with 2.6.17-final, too?
> > AFAIK, there was a bug in the early 2.6.17-rc regarding OSS emulation,
> > but it got fixed in the later rc.
>
> I confirm that the only oops I got was with 2.6.17-rc1
>
> > The behavior of invalid O_* flag seems incompatible with the older
> > version. Although I don't think it's totally wrong behavior, surely
> > better to keep the compatibility. The patch below should fix it.
>
> I don't care: I have changed my player.
> I also tend to agree that opening /dev/dsp read write was not a good
> idea, so I would not criticise the new behaviour.
Well, incompatibility is worse in most cases than rationality.
Could you test the patch really fixes your case, so that I can push it
to 2.6.17-stable tree?
> Each version of Linux 2.6 tend to break some softwares due to subtil
> changes. What is bad is that these changes tend to be not announced,
> but on the other hand the kernel mailing list is very responsive,
> so all in all it might be a reasonable way to go.
It was an unintentioal change, so it's not somthing to be announced ;)
It's a thing just to be fixed.
Takashi