2006-08-20 01:36:58

by Xin Zhao

Subject: Where does NFS client associate the file handle received from server with inode?

I ran into a problem:

I extend several fields to file handle, and change compose_fh() to
initialize some value into the file handle. I think the client side
should be able to associate the file handle with inode and used them
properly afterwards. However, I found a problem:

Say I have a program 'postmark" in /tmp, and my current directory is /

If I do '/tmp/postmark', getattr() funciton will not use the right
file handle with extension. Instead, it seems to use a file handle
excluding my extension

but if I change to '/tmp', do 'ls -al' first, then I do 'postmark',
getattr() will use the right file handle.

So I think maybe I need to change NFS client to associate the extened
file handle with inode . But I don't know where NFS client does this.
Can someone give me a help?

Many thanks!

-x

2006-08-21 13:53:44

by Trond Myklebust

Subject: Re: Where does NFS client associate the file handle received from server with inode?

On Sat, 2006-08-19 at 21:36 -0400, Xin Zhao wrote:
> I ran into a problem:
>
> I extend several fields to file handle, and change compose_fh() to
> initialize some value into the file handle. I think the client side
> should be able to associate the file handle with inode and used them
> properly afterwards. However, I found a problem:
>
> Say I have a program 'postmark" in /tmp, and my current directory is /
>
> If I do '/tmp/postmark', getattr() funciton will not use the right
> file handle with extension. Instead, it seems to use a file handle
> excluding my extension
>
> but if I change to '/tmp', do 'ls -al' first, then I do 'postmark',
> getattr() will use the right file handle.
>
> So I think maybe I need to change NFS client to associate the extened
> file handle with inode . But I don't know where NFS client does this.
> Can someone give me a help?

Why are you changing the file handle? We should already be caching the
correct one (i.e. the one that was sent to us by the server in the
LOOKUP call) in the 'struct nfs_inode'.

Cheers,
Trond

2006-08-23 13:57:42

by Xin Zhao

Subject: Re: Where does NFS client associate the file handle received from server with inode?

Because I have to carry some additional information of the file
identified by the file handle. :) But never mind, the problem has been
fixed.

Thanks anyway,
xin

On 8/21/06, Trond Myklebust <[email protected]> wrote:
> On Sat, 2006-08-19 at 21:36 -0400, Xin Zhao wrote:
> > I ran into a problem:
> >
> > I extend several fields to file handle, and change compose_fh() to
> > initialize some value into the file handle. I think the client side
> > should be able to associate the file handle with inode and used them
> > properly afterwards. However, I found a problem:
> >
> > Say I have a program 'postmark" in /tmp, and my current directory is /
> >
> > If I do '/tmp/postmark', getattr() funciton will not use the right
> > file handle with extension. Instead, it seems to use a file handle
> > excluding my extension
> >
> > but if I change to '/tmp', do 'ls -al' first, then I do 'postmark',
> > getattr() will use the right file handle.
> >
> > So I think maybe I need to change NFS client to associate the extened
> > file handle with inode . But I don't know where NFS client does this.
> > Can someone give me a help?
>
> Why are you changing the file handle? We should already be caching the
> correct one (i.e. the one that was sent to us by the server in the
> LOOKUP call) in the 'struct nfs_inode'.
>
> Cheers,
> Trond
>
>