Return-Path: Received: (majordomo@vger.kernel.org) by vger.kernel.org via listexpand id ; Fri, 14 Feb 2003 17:04:52 -0500 Received: (majordomo@vger.kernel.org) by vger.kernel.org id ; Fri, 14 Feb 2003 17:04:52 -0500 Received: from ns0.cobite.com ([208.222.80.10]:49414 "EHLO ns0.cobite.com") by vger.kernel.org with ESMTP id ; Fri, 14 Feb 2003 17:04:45 -0500 Date: Fri, 14 Feb 2003 17:14:37 -0500 (EST) From: lkml@dm.cobite.com X-X-Sender: david@admin To: Andrew Morton cc: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org Subject: [BENCHMARK] 2.5.60-mm2+anticipatory results with Oracle db load In-Reply-To: <20030131142213.37020b31.akpm@digeo.com> Message-ID: MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: MULTIPART/MIXED; BOUNDARY="-556791216-321133549-1045260877=:24530" Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org X-Mailing-List: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org Content-Length: 21069 Lines: 378 This message is in MIME format. The first part should be readable text, while the remaining parts are likely unreadable without MIME-aware tools. Send mail to mime@docserver.cac.washington.edu for more info. ---556791216-321133549-1045260877=:24530 Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII Andrew and list, I've been tracking various kernels with my 'production load'. The load and the platform are described below. As stated in the subject line, this is 2.5.60 + mm2 + all three anticipatory IO scheduler patches from experimental/ In case anyone is comparing these to prior results, be warned, I've changed CPUs, changed Oracle tuning, and of course, changed kernels. Only the relevant kernels for comparison are included below (i.e. these runs are on the same HW platform with same Oracle config). If you would like to see other tests, let me know. As per a prior request, I've attached 'vmstat 10' output during the run (and a bit after). It's compressed. If this vmstat is useless, let me know, I feel a bit bad spamming the list with it. If you'd like other profiling, let me know along with some hints on how to use it. I tend to think this is really an I/O scheduler + user space CPU utilization issue (not a kernel system time issue). kernel minutes ----------------------------- ----------- 2.5.59 102 2.5.59-mm8 105 2.5.60-mm2-with-anticipatory 107 <- attached vmstat.log.gz for this Platform and configuration: HP LH3000 U3. Dual 1Ghz Intel Pentium III, 2GB ram. megaraid controller with two channels, each channel raid 5 (hardware raid) PV on 6 15k scsi disks, one megaraid LV per PV. Two plain disks w/pairs of partitions in raid 1 for OS (redhat 7.3), a second pair of partitions (regular partitions with ext2) for Oracle redo-log (in a log 'group'). Oracle version 8.1.7.4 (no aio support in this release) is accessing datafiles on the two megaraid devices via /dev/raw stacked on top of device-mapper (lvm2). Workload: The workload consists of a few different phases. 1) Indexing: multiple indexes built against a 9 million row table. This is mostly about sequential scans of a single table, with bursts of write activity. 50 minutes or so. 2) Analyzing: The database scans tables and builds statistics. Most of the time is spent analyzing the 9 million row table. This is a completely cpu bound step on our underpowered system. 30 minutes. 3) Summarization: the large table is aggregated in about 100 different ways. Records are generated for each different summarization. This is mixed read-write load. 50 minutes or so. -- /==============================\ | David Mansfield | | lkml@dm.cobite.com | \==============================/ ---556791216-321133549-1045260877=:24530 Content-Type: APPLICATION/x-gzip; name="vmstat.log.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: BASE64 Content-Description: Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="vmstat.log.gz" H4sICCFpTT4AA3Ztc3RhdC5sb2cA3X1Zki25jeW/VnGXwHlYTkklWetDLZnU srLafRMHIJ3uDtL9ZmWbvej8iIwXwwmAADGT/Hw+//jn3//0r4/639/+/Le/ //O/+fN//dd//OP4zl//zl/873/9nz//jb/0p3/8+w+ff34+f/x8/gs//4// bP/7yz///Of2vz/++y9/aT/yH3/6X/Svf/2VPgDij3/FR/r8r/8bMP/6/Ptf Dfjz1//8w8d+PubzcfwHzMcGX4qnf9YQyifm9q/E3+ofUqCPNn4+MeL3SsV3 zKfWO551Nhb6jRrbL5YaTQgTnrfJWaC6j/UxE3KKH9d+pn5S/gP9nJ3wSqkh EkE1tT/e0FM40edtMIU+zYbwEii1H9eoLZ9UbvQ1PF/Bbg5Gw3OF+fW54SUL vEZf+xtxhUff/NTS/qfj4d/tqw3PAC9NeO7Cb3DF0E/VhtvwfIlxxnPVRFoi 11bV8l+2pf0ZA7wA+k54zpdAv2BIDtaGWHm9unydz/TtYGv7GZLsx7n8icAI Cr+2VBKvNRbrF01yJzwSLYmD1s9AsZpmAc98wl1fCM/SGhiH9bviuWQhLqyf A330h71vX/kkr+EVWrD2t21S8LzzrI+J9AWitk1AjWWRx1X/bMkEYE0wQcVz edDnm6a0H812kq+50pdzBL+hknyjjaf90f5AhRJb+msZ8nVNEqAp5ju/jYcA +pJlvMT0TPJo/3bJB/qb+FNt14VE34xBw/PMbyrg1xabNDzjaI1p/zY1aZIF ntHwLOPlCHnYGlX6IvCwtNF0PKvhGQN95v0WHa/XHS8MvAa2oS/mAH2uDvrs bJ7x2tdtITxHqwt78GmCCw7ySHd98TEU4hfKT3j+tN/aRqO1t74e8jV+ku8d z9EustYKv/5MX1NL2vIeuxvfalt9S59NoM/x/nDhZF+sbxaV+M303cJ4W/2L Ta0Iz/P+cDGYE30pgd9M1BcHvDTh/ShvWXxga2U9716Xymn3NjZpMbwnXcoe 3Ibd6oXsSEJt2/Pq5XRaPZ8qpJEgDXhLazba4rLJoK/tEsIr+Uxf0+4G4kI6 pFvtx1eypvFu/TJ5N9CXoQ81+rM1cCZQXFDImztyQp/cfoDMQrP59Y4XQzLQ vlLJnrsWdJgTHnZHpJDAOtKr5tPqhzZAs/bxDwJ24DkTE9yho93bdulZHg2P /lxsuwd/jfBS7t4j3Ohrv80CbF6T8GrOF/qaIW14tAfbz5A1SGX2Rle8JtbC 7pr0hfZWKBd+iT6TiT7jO78WeLx7/YxnW3hB8nWw9s3253Kmz5BQo6G97Qzo a67twLvoXyzRgD5v2jo1pY7ibQ88Mt6hAA9L0Via1u+K17wX9oeHtWqxTDlb e2c96Kvgl1QpNRu95JdsFay9d4HwUlvzC31kQkOthfBAn+VoyCOavNAXSvtR 0If9G6o/e9+GB93NlaRvoC+NSof9oUQHof16wobPtH+bcfZnfWFvFxKiF2yd RPtjSZ/LFd7SF0d4jcCzvlgi5+NLhS8g+kixiGbXkDU89m6exKLg0VZsP59p fxgmnbwlkaB534ZXWF9oGVU8iTbK4X0jOfTD+0LWV7wWxKv8flgfyKg0+mB6 Qj7jXemjVaZwdkdfJm2C40T0ssPjaI2icg2vRNJnl2r8wEG3/5pCYsnbZtDw EqKDliQUBa+Zh1pBfiabS/JticVP8pbuzK1hadAmIW7zybq0eJm8G2xij108 +SHkHpo0ErZrS2IoWoxk5k6r11IdLG6q5GGM4GXQ5O7Wj/A86EuQxh2vQro5 El4F3s6bNzwkozYg1tXwqjmkGyHdusXzzG+h6I7wTrF906KGRG6gHLFk+zVg KN684Tnebcgt73i+BW/EL+XSHG2c6bvgNTME80ZJEa0fpapnaxoolowRvp69 eZPHMncjY4xctQXhjb5EzufizTPhNWdK1hTeMvpzdHDCc46jgwjvm2LTtKu1 N2QAKDdyDnh+4z1a7m2gYBHRcSreXbxlo5joY2sP79Ec+zLaaMEKe7dIXtxm 05zSmT5HJj46eDdrnvh1LZehXdQcA0V/mVK5C7+NnMZvQSwH+tzM75U+07w3 nA68b26hhLl4N8q9msnC+rE3D02MFP2RN1LwkCskKoQoeC0ioDycYrZGH+E1 Tib6woXf5jQgD6TAOl4gfinasGR3W0ZUuze/R6cND8mVhVlgvMv6VY7WKPav 5D3aggPPabWhhmd5/WAPgHf25rRypH+x6zOVzpbRRhMfRy+pWhWv/QDWz5YR TbYYUKIrRZ9NTli/pnmCd46u2vJHsgeo5SB3o5iSIn6r1Q4oGMP+zZCggofa kEM01KMDu87NJ7yq08fRQaLso0cHc7Txy3tLnVuXVqtH3MaS9MrLXVvYGmQf tdWz0JOmg8hVxbvlyXsstSWo9LXQlJx9s/O+W3sqYi29UcNDJbbhkXVW8Hjz eNodbA2s2XjLAy9S7Kzwi91suS5YeyXCY/cqueqEF3S8iEpsycNaveSXNrnG b4U3r8g8LSrP7Qtb+hC9ZKpIMt6pktOSRLIkppRurSijOXKFO56Ft8xp6Msl 16fgoTHtCY92byL63JS7nfFSZn6RGxGeO1tnS9FG9Ie+JBcn72bO0SThsT6X bq1u3o2ssyN+nWM8v859HVU4wW/Jon/nSrZDwhYpIh/0uXOueqUPtYOWPAYV z9Jejd7WsX4m7qz9wCsiX3+yB7aSyQsl2p6rwhsVwsuaNRW8Yro++4t8fYD3 cD03jyVP9N3xUDq0xRqj49HvhorolBxdo2/r3RLvj2K9yONaeyEXHmB9Dn69 WXrfFDPT16ONc/TXknaPVDuiuvpBvLXO3Rpeclg/2+VxxvtQy4lywXzklnWd WxIecsFiu/274SGXpuile8tN7jvjpTVeMFTJNlyWiXaqtP8wb4kgsnHrFtJF wOIy+goRq5e4D2W1PhRpM68eVXDueC11iPAeqJwi19rmRgdesJo0qA+A1A51 2jJyt2c8CsmXeFT/7db+XGdX+GVtTkbT5k6fT7nn5lMlQt29rmK3JVX7On0J lSvpK/gtfahHWVSwVbyKQhm6Npzr7/oUzsTK1qAMeZxz81S50gT6EL2ccv0b vwFt84bX9e/UR/lkpDrBkDVgfn1TRQ/rnLRoLSAcaIFYxzv38ZrFi8jdRqU9 tYzhlKuevVFIyC2r7fqcz9YZCWWktMMibf1QSXmTCwbWv+q6d7viRVTaQxyV XRu3ePDRDS8J3qWS7al83UK54d1ocODqff2Ex5Xs6rv+XSvZyH1rzBQdsPct O+/W8ULU8RAsNe9mujePpU654J1froXVaMXan/uWzmbgcXQaJryFtwzorje8 wvItl9yXgsemLzn2aBe5Zem5741fj9aT5TkGBY9zadTCuJIda9nl0p5z/VqF 33LJpS0Nf4SKWg7+FCWbG31hvPajptN3yX2poNE2UT6iDbeTr4c+N7yxfhc8 RFfZYP2oVke1pEO+v7a3vK+ecGsl9rtw+/FkmZpcPXlLWL+mBjIlcK/UkTRg zk2PNa542Jo+W0wdIFeNft3VP/Dcgj7Jff2U+9YtXuBk1DtVuoJH5S9LCSvR F3axlUcfr/0/aXg0VoNKLKY23nijTl8Yu+OEhyyG8OLo+5I3N8vcfOCp8mh4 DvR5WBfuS8c3eNHqeBWVIdqybfdyXzr0XFXFI+9HRmSBZxMZs+aU0Rt+5tfB +7Y/bVR5tEgdsX08ahGOow2vTUUQHss3F826NB9KtRIwIZVYTCGtc3OuPDej JLlquebSpGstFzToXX8oON1WYh0q4zTsIvRdcukGeOSq8L4unb3lBY/l0bRA 6Lvk0jB5DQ+5Frylq7tc2qGz4NAk1vBgTSNmTnj9aMNs+OXGaYtOcqfvkktT wSpSQkYDh1g/u+4jE57Dr4VO3zmX7rUDRPdc2a2zt1ToE7xO3yX3tRxduSO6 auEM7UHOzc01WrOYWnNUytbwpI9cE/CirN+OPsHLnd/rnAU6Fd6N/dvC7V20 YRH+OFv6frt2UgrNRVjMaEo0NNcOfm1vedNmi8qBo2RL4/bj2JlSLMSZNKxL WXojS0kRlFZdvQ9rw6myG3febeB1bXmDd3i3u3QZz43YSsPzJg9+HyobLY5w wAsqXkRbs21ui/k6+moLLjEXp0cbHc+q60e5peveqHvLbW5JnWLgdet3wcsY kUMlwJYxxYUdGzXrN/Cqpi82wNhKdCC5dD7TZ0+5TMdzTpPvyKVRiRVvOSrP O35d1vnt9E19ZLurZHc87zT5NtdIfcsWbYRj5q+8wiu6fFEKaIniMQVnwi46 MBjibqvXo7Xz1Ib3mGZHdMV9stgM/7pPSzkCnGwa/F77bmRNSVV6H3nvLQ1K ww7TasCLF++BXBqxK1t7GvvZeHOD1oZDBRZ4pylC2ojAK+XIpf2ucj/wejR5 6euzdwuoDVXO9fOmL02z58SvN90bnfGax6C+JerS7M1bfLnlF/Va563UIkq6 yCOiL53j8Jal5ZZhMXcw4UknoFxrLzxllo/c/Kg8a9FLx+u1khse95GL7523 WOZazq/tLe/cojTgvO/W6lzJsRhpC5krQ1W43WTmPGXR8Lq1KhdtoVwhSN8N qxfTVIm44NlacWLB+ZA6fecufCFtDpFiIRRhaOwQ1sBp2tzwOFfwUccTGWNv 99wyUemevKVT6UvgN5kVHvoApo4J/vZx2TWf8Lr3veEh96W92KOD/AqvW2ed Pp756134LR6si886v4VGdIk+N2bqij33ZWZvOeF163fCG5VsTPDL1NWmkk1D LYidfVHpo04AJtpBX+FKu1tHBxNe3tDXvVvpeKvo5cDrUyALfkvulWzwu/KW E15U8Xwt9egEMN6mDz/wglmsH7Xxid9ztLaKDhoeR+PB6OvXvAqiP5YHog27 iTaoIgl9DiP6u1Z2I866Ycabc9/mik596SsevHkY9q9ec31UxpEL4vAbvO+w 9vf1Q2W34Qm/9VKJxXBAROwluVvjd5lLH3hB+qpXPBuAR7UXmaE2aYdXkEy6 EKVWUq9TUg65JWa8ubbRfmA5hUTOH94y9M7R9YQaZSXNnnDtinPL+GO85Z3b wLsjS2WyqjNhFdYKuyOmvF29jifWuZ6nhpq3xJRAMX13EN7S+x54VWLdai+V CDkRkEcfoNlAkYa22wq6+g1Pdlu9VsKYvsmbN/d+qmy4Cx52W+x9snqdKiHP HarBlAXWr7h1n4L6HYjtY586uM5gIiGKNIw9ThjYdR+FxncwcBx7Llgv5yPR JvVUDrKGTwg1xcYkkdaXJn7h3aLr8ridt6Sfz+zNeUrAYUbPaFMME55EL3c8 Wj9YKxORm9N5vNEJUOTLeN363fFoOTBzanA+ksCO2oYiD1iX6JPGr6Wx249M 8FO74oPzpRvv1vGCUfFiwAkr1LU4F8QJq7X3yBxNxqCuX6/chzD19cs6Nz/w +szpFQ/NY1ec696I6Dsqz2u8bg9ueBb82q7PRN8WD5XO2Cv3V7zCnYWcu3W2 1Pfd4CF5bnidvlMltvlkA32x44TQ1FnQ8BLXhmKfE6jn3DxYnuLCjDfP2NIU 19qbJwf7F3sf9ILnHGbQoX8yZda+sMPjSnvstcTL+dcWhpD3zQn2FN48pZ19 Hnhd/y65Ps/I06nzhsfRS/wxlVhFGii1xuGNLpUIh74CZrgccg+akF/WxSe8 0FfvIt3gRl+GYytHZ0dQt9esFZ+oILyi4tHh8g/2nEzcU9AkeE7Dsyzd2qV7 qRxY9I0s2Vrxbs3NnPoKKl7qM3/1MrWBSk6oGVMRzG/e8tvxujZf8SiBbqm0 GecPqe/xAq9788sUCI4VsK+SiXa7xzOQbzJSyanXEySI7dvO6PKlovGBd99t gtdzhXqbKuFahB0nPozfRQcRl2M0PLZ+PlwrVxQSeIfT4cgtI1lnMkhNMhpe EPo42vCXKQtrPQ9iU24Ob0Qxm0QH9wl+woM1TTJV58vl/LBDiPahXCEXOgjQ 7O7HoVaSNesXMWXmkvdOw/Oe8ei7hYICm5toHKLJrOUeEVN/fNBKwQuZhw1a DGirx3wbjv7QiZRy77tRWw2djyTe/IYn/FJto5K+WBzWgL4UTf94iosOqsn6 nU+8BVSeEbJYHvcmb0j8hk++VzobHudaLaMuKh68B69fJe+GVbQ4gVM0fe54 4s1veEluPyE8choWicOG34634BcneugyGEy2fTCv+bGwV0WzVwMv6Xg8qMv6 Unkady+PjldUPG8sF9QIDydvEyUiEXjux3nLwJUXDAIr3LbNBe2juzGwUVo0 mCdul3hSWbvgfXw0fbTHYridNvp6amjCy07Ds5mtoXfj7pij0qlqs+AVo/FL N7uwNlMug5nJ6bzRFi+EHR5Vroz38umyDzrhqbtXpc/tKqd82pzODW7x+O4T Xr+0pU/w6sP6OYU+df06ntuu33w3ywXP6niqNTjkYQ5+N1NmhIdcPxur61/n F/K1Z/3T10/wFvoSOTbH3Tuyfns8ZHh8icdu/fxB36YPf+BJ33xJH+HhdoxH +lDbyFa1pgce6QuniftOQKfP7dcvheNExbZTMfCKjsd9fZxOFLzdVGLDk6F6 v9gf0uni/eFFHhv6PErXDU/1vsP+Rdydxaq9uZ2AZp0RPWe/t1ezfdnMlUx4 aW//vM7vr+0t79LlA4s5LHbHt6s38OKL3Xuf8nFLvOE9kkrfZF38VvsSa18c 1lnBwzUgFtf68EwsjLJyE1zDg7o2vGGtznjS9c5pzAA/aB/PdObkdbweHQTF Om/x0obfs3d7hZeHvuj0ubf0yfrlBb+KfLfRgUzI57zXl5QO69K9h1p59pHp kz7okr7Je2yt/cDb65+b7nop2/XreHGrf7M8ttZ+4NW0la9X8Hb81oU8BG+2 pmmL51A5LUf0csYTb8new4o8dvLteAv9k5vh2Jtn0b+dN8LlTISnr1+PDuyB N6+fuUZ/A29hX/hyD5rN6fbqal/OcwIDr2z3R5i8+V6+gmedbg/U6P6H3k7Q uMVx/MZt2FqDGN9qX8eLW21hb5leaF/HW2jLbO3FWtk3eG5h7U+xcxG8nbZ0 PLfRPoubdGRqaHev5oSXXmhfD9t2uw1Dc674hXU5xaYvcsuBt+D3lCu8kUfH C9vdy/pXvsBbWHuhL5y8+Qu8UZl85nevzx0vbOTbErt03NwWdtGkwy+4Ehf6 LOtXjrtZWuiHuWA9+uPj/g1vR9/Z+pkdvwMv6/I4WecX+jfw9vJN02n9rXw7 3lE53dgDlq9/hbfQ52/1pcv3qHSq+lIQ3fP6XWoHVsXLC+/Wo6HJHoSdfRl4 D9F4ufuPH+gtO7flwXuccretdFFpwuiVvnr44Tm33Gtzx1tIQ6nkbK2p44sQ S93zG6fcre9eNToYeHtvSZEcjtI9VcJo3gp4D9HBJA+71WbGq2ZhDZRc4QEP lasq5/H8ZUZvW8lW+eUjNhhN1PC6fNOMt1s/7nNXuUtlRV+aoo28lW/HKzqe Yk1f0dejtSseV/4kV2C8bWWNL/9peP61PLa5+cDbr997+Xa8osu3e0s7W+cd v9znrr1Pu8CLac5Vd/LteGGvf/6td+t4eSMPi4njHg2lXa4/8KqO16Nd2INO 304eghcW+03JLR/4Rd+8Rqm9fKkvP8xb2iLcPliXOnLB5ugkNtVm6lh8rt+N sdI+umX8pi2aNDpeWkhDidW2fZSB5zb8Nsd2uklqo80DL+q7t1eawlz5e0Pf 3rrM2rdfP57gr3IaebV+c3RQdtZl4D3QZ+dY/AV9ZS9fpi+/57fsve+cW865 zC06sAlTDLUsvJF4t1gOfc5bfen0LazzqQ/6oq+Ka5gIr+69x6lyv7F+ch60 1gW/33qPgbe3L7N13kYHA2+hfyd9iTd+7/IFnjdm5z0k1/c9etnKQ/Ae5Pu2 88HnsBrewvt2b6lEB/r64UaihrfXl3CaY9jtN8Gzi+hPqf3N+vzTvGXndmHt lcrk3vp1vLTVPhePOvte+zBB7Y1baPOpT2Ze0IcXfxreyruxi4Q3l+hgbw06 3opf7hup1l7lF+dfG94iljx5yxd9wY7nH2I/p8R+Wzy7t6anXH8zlTPwFt68 05dm+W7kYXC1X8PLq+iFBk3tdPtESzM3fWmDxt8O77s+Hi7xAd5Wvuirhksl TJPHwBveI2h4at93izesqYJ39h776ED2h9xNdcPr0eTkLff84jIlwks7frmz 8MJ7DLwRPevr9zY3P/D28rBztLHll/UveH39lOhgm+sPvKTz26NJf3jLzW0v E15W6WthDY2GGpxHRieADlkc569/mLc0GNIiblXtS7iHkKWBab4PTRTTiQCr n9AwmJHy/aa1Ox6XlxgvAC/gfKTVz/MYnIfyRu6FDOZ8IsDLzG4ZN0kFucnM 6ufdDK4aa3gcOwdzrUyOwbJ3UwcGuTl1o+CN+gT2sTsYP+RZ+3Z4iaMDmRoK 7np+CZelftCn4Ltoklm/V9jw+EClkbtZgr+cB/U80U9vmhjc3UEHOpd3DU14 QfCut0bH7iKHt9xaUyOxc+JoI8SLPDxMlHXk3fAtkvLyLilbamZrL7cnxIu+ tFSMD5USv3QBPB3R6HjKCZKWsrE8Mvf1oz+fmPEx4pgC+tJ8b6/Pm/UrfDrc GzmPRy/KnvcHxvYzbhnH06ihoeK2PvX2hMLnS72R3DyZy4kjPmHAd0lJIHip vZymQAoa3ITH+pLs5WY5w488ztZ5N3Na+Hxpw2Nrn9zlbpvEVybkOGovcbc/ Jryk4ll5vzQo3lfFk+j+AY+svXHPU1ev8RynDE/7o1lntn8l6nhS0IA94GiN ovtl7a/hsT5LZyu5s77IZczCL3vzXefooK8mFa8XXGh/uLs9/VnecnArd4ss uZ2kuzsBMaQhJwLu0ghT34gFs9XmXDg2rbLb0tnaY3aUYD1e4frQRWsFLxJZ 7b3Chpc49qtRxfOJRyGSH7d4ywmXhfXLib2vnN+84o3Yrxy55dYaDLyi4zk+ nYxKnezerTwEDyG+hudjT2CGd9vF4geeWIMrnswQ4sTMi8r4gRd1vE6fMmWm 4+G8YMPLgnfx5oGbx2mqxO4qfyXjPKO3UrlS8JjflzOxE96KPuBle+jL5s0f GnnF/rVyM1q63gZi5GmA0PvmFCisb2NoeEyfzDimy+l1uV6NsvHeV627XLDh 4ai8taIvV7xcj1yLX1+3m9egbYnRMh7rS76cH/aWtw+iZ8wU07Awjr7p/MbI +iJ96QsevZOKT3EXDfNL0YsjDOWVAOCxPHj/XvFckBMkYZjCRmrAeVrt9o6G h2jISm0t18v5XHN0yizf3lE4d3vC42j8imflZkLKpS3rX3HrN1ImvJq2eLHn luD3h+SWd+nifi1vpVJ349bwXTJk7S1XIopbv5824Vl19YzcIk2xqeXYNNe+ elu8oNJn5O4cSIOt1SFdHS/DOsv5IIU+5tce/MZX/OraN+hLr+kTvKLLw3GC it3G1n6Px69BeyuVMLzEpMgXb4Hz7qgW1sXpuVYAQ56ef1XxJBdh+nj97G63 Dbyo42W5nJjWL/JNa2aPJ/ymouC138YVBzzz556nGOi5R1i/MOSh3F0klWI5 2H3xvu6CV8wez2F7kO7wQXuiD2QF5TaQYpFseCszsSWd77YplvyuTQmn14m1 QO95knSwfnc8VJAantPwvI98IoxqJR43TdJ9hHQUIqq1oQOPK8U3PMnViSKP XJoIPvDW9HH0csVzWR5KwtviqB2k+AZP5iJu9AWWD8m302c2eAFFK8Jj+1fy ubYRcVsE37PLryMHqZz6KRf0E57l6EDmIsrl7rGIYAlPUDeVJ3tAV8YGnIfX 9m8wEr3Ivb1XvCryhbdkU5jdplYXDNderMzYXvBsf3OGow32lmmKDn5tb7nm 1mvSsC4e2mz5/Ff7wjoWCoYrEf2O+xuexFYR1s91vKX1O/DSFg/eUmI11ytX ijXwtQoe5x43PM+5MN7HE+kWaJ9TvdHAK4v1s0cXvsemc2y1pK+ou2PEkiyP Eb0s1+/AW6yf4RllXj97w1vTt1g/e5wH7fT5V/SJNV3wi76HyHenLw0PlV0r 7z2u8BD9cV+wxB6L6/IVvKDiBc8hC6wBQ1e/uXf2wEsav+Mj3dVknBXRrKeu Djzd+vWPbvLmYY/H1rmKN7rcnRUdQqqAynhmfa6oZFvVOh/01aTgUeng2L98 EyHh+b5+d/3DjLzvryLc8CQXzHXgUe7L+1epDTU89N2cTPnc8KwJB32sL7O1 V+gTPK/z23PVcMpVl/b0wIs6ntCHmzpTOq/fFi/p/PJ1hkzfkau+wFP15Vg/ 4Jkb3s/ylr7C3fj+5kU53wRH3OLfFKt1bclTpn/XFrywRXhBxRNtYW958b7q 7uh4TscTacCaRramZS9dVGKdDTq/XVuwO/xZ+1Tr1/GShvepiVUO2sK5Qt7l ql76bs5273HG6x8d5Ua2Q69zo7F+jmPdas4v/ni5fDUdtyfEy+uvp77Wgcex 5AWPZgL7IVq5t5di4/W9mhNeUPGk2Uury7dat2V8hcfRyxWvyItRPh2vX5v1 i2ITXlDpK9L3Bh7f67p73XzCyzp9eLPhjLd5oazh4aZJ77xR5VFEHrH0Iur2 dfMJb7F+xnJCnse9qS/piyperkctovO7eTFuwsuqPlcpX+OFKM6N0q4P76tn ecibMNWcK7vy0WMqzPY06cj1NfpgT+XER98Pnd/m6+1HXglwPPXiWV+8eg8w zX0AT6aGLnj09BHWD/dG41stnYM++8X+gMFseKLPV7x45IIOgSCV5PFqo/ae 7Iy3pQ94qK11PH6f9qd5y85t1KR75lYGLmZu13hiDa54Hlepw1s6VGKtrevX fQkPfQAn7ymupIvdi64+udVDujf6Smb64kK6hr0T3TPp+ArQpjPH+4d3PI7F F3g0PoPdm46ZSb/rmh947H2rO92i3EJg5IIWLzCJ9mXhV3lPccYrCh55AdPl 6xEd0N3gZMGi+obBgVdUPBvZpNBq+FA7Xn3Ek9e0b3iJrbMHXp9qIrywwMML Ub6/OHXHizxlVolfI/SRYkftxSTCQ1/LyfuC1V9ev+aCC2bkOFqDtV9HawWl Ke/kbqULnperseGbPT28TE9DTutn7/QJXlHxXI9eIN9RSSx9/Zb0yV1NN/qy 5IKTPOIkDwWP5ZG5E3DD6/JNB17Yyjd2vLSjL5lDvqWvn7p/uQ868MK575sy l1/9uAcYL7zl7n0ZzCv0SfR3xrOJH+/O3hy3yG+jqwe8MM2B2My3+m9e8Jvw JBq64vGLdplf0cBXT2/WKPIQfRH7d8HDrQ+fHv3BHlgz2atf21veuQ15yy20 z8od9yM2qMtYaOAlFa/KGHaM/UWYY/V078Z9ACeVU0UarH1H7EIv4JQeW7lv 8fJRGZLXfU2dpPstfTHLVdaxv4/3EDsXqTTJGy41aJU1m3GLt3K3yF0eEpsu 8CIStgpfGvF8Q5SJdqog/IHsgFHxZAazhnPui3d42wajEwaJ1s8m6pO1sKgs di/3aQdePL+27BKaY5jZ5coaFTs2uWVxrH9FrN8Fj9uGjSh/vDhlt/LoeOJ9 r3jyrBZqERJobSuxhfuMTmYmr3gJT9qwvvCt+VPupq4fn9BwMjN5xevWqoT+ pgRexNpEf0b4Tao8eq7Pubnv+2PIQ9G/LV5zVtBnfhGL7UGYcqM1Xtb57bUD 7F/gmbLdv5b3r9xWcsGjAu2IJvlVBLxpMuzLBk/Tl7bmFfYAcxtcZqMpwjxV sq/8snyr0+jDBqHYBZ0jlInopEEETdqJKJ95JttJZ+GKlzLO3kTK9VMCqW2h SR5Vr7TnzNHGwDvPtH/wiEDL4EfnIxg+r9/oS7+6t7xzmzDF4OQFq5pvryOT TIIZN2fR40nr82k+szXwMoNZL29zB7xm4nFewOPoG81aUFBO9QMNj2cIvdxF c8ET63e2VpFmOMj7KjN1jT5oizcSq13wZKqEZ8zCXHleVE6f8MKRu1meaKcT GutK9hNePe5W6jNmu6mXCa9oeD02RWU8jT6UW1rngedVeZwr2bx+aVfJHnhB pa/jhfCy0p55isvLmys3POkskE3o9NVd33LgFR0vuWn9fOd37S0PPFW+Qd6c YX1GLaLO72/e9UXwrL4/Qr8nNuJ1MdkfJ/oWeJJ73ORRuRI7ohdMhe3ky/ZA bta82gP5GNCnteM2gXWlM/PUFY1JMd65kxLwIiC9mPXpr5t7v12/jife/Ion M9m8fv6FPDpeUenzEq3O+rLXZ8Fzkptf6ZMzC0wf64t5Q1/vpFzx+gmX+LIP f+Dp/Kaj8yGHEYnfgffDvGXimUkq1ancirXCe5RsqCkzX3fNE0aGve99mbu2 TF1ftn5ba9rxel/minfqIg/vtsHjGUzvden2qSGeEqg3vJv2DTyv8utSmaZe nqekfOKZTi+n9a94MdYpOuAJ/ryrvIz1U63B+Eh9HrFWVCleW6uEA6QND/LN xiQlumLfYjLtDgp+j/Nf9/VLbE25b0RPfZysaZQZapwgyVzUNudY/KrPqDT5 gFz1hpfKdFq/8GGI+goP3ojwTvwmmcHEPbaVW8D2FV4wKl6dbs1n+tKl8ndZ P67leD4vrdA33TIueL5P5WjR5MArQcXz03nGK7+qPeh41e3wMFOMF9Soxbpb v4Gn89vx3JhCeocXkQve8ZKcgIA8/Av963i6vmR0tqTWxKY1m11fld+PXOIV wyA0dyCBYHYTfXd94RNWnl+VuNMn58PBb+2i3tEn2Ux06vpx8NX3B+SR5vPI P81bdm69qs3ZHeeDDBtq4na3OwQv6KsnfUHWvnzG0yoRAy/q2me4Usd9Bcbb 7w6eEvBxYV3KdJcKWwPS5o11ecALYbJ+bF3cK/qKvnu7NQAey8Nud4fgJbu1 Vrg5S9bvFX1J15fU+6B+WKuXeEm3zm5cLT7Wz2/x8GaN92ms37nSFLkvk+hc hYwT5i5frRPA72+24MAYDa/tD9f1xRqmb29dLFu/PLz5Cc859r44f/jiPHJb P+Y3G5Xf/pFs2XUmdoGHKRWfnUpf/4j9Ji2p3XnVAy+o6zfoy/oUzU2fY2Vr n5NKn8V7mQHv8VlczODLOBGlnLf0eJab8CT6s+c3k1Kgl3gNfGmk6NnGVCHf rJ7+93L+0OcebZxfQJTKOL//armzFfv7qpp94fdaG17V6NOmctof2FSKO14x Gn2Plef7+nU8ZzR+q9gXzJUgcD2/pv1re8s7t55j3eJU6VaxVpips331NjNc A89r0qWZyWkmEVMR27fXn/CKO04P95m/7YzewIsrPK7UHTOTx1vue7yk4fX3 PFHZYENY/S73jXw3i+cTH5mvzjlZF/phb5ALclqzzQUjSiveF/Hm/lqpm05U SCW77iovA0+swQUvdRMa+2vLFPFuct/o2Fqt8AL3uRmP+75+N3XQ8arV+ZVK J2aoZSpi5tet+K1OpW9U1lC54vUzb9ZvhfftiYpohF+J7a942XUlGfoXNqfX D7yg4yXH+4MqnSl2fte1koGXdDxZP660X/bHFk/X547H6xe+oK90+k7nm9MR EjT9cx/pc2/0eY9njERDtH4saorW1jPyvEEbXk0K3vhYcHsMB5YVtRzTvbn/ zFNIAZertVWT6C9o9oWe/ex3P9Eqnu4GuuDxCURUhAkvKrUmeoKJZoBhGumN aRJM8yK//D2xTSzpJA3HXd9gJFaL6RL70dPjPrU0S55SK8110ASW/ziWrjvj cRc+WJFGMhe8ZiWcwVupgVogbYt4vlmlxb+KNbAwb4TH2pcvlTWPpnqkF3rk tK/ju0+cHpvyc6wNz2l4LTxjb0fWxaESS30PDyVRZyYtnycLVrzlBa/FpsdM MVo+tm1dihhCo13ZHQNPYt0LXnFlVCY9RxvRU92J8LTd9oRny+DXg1Q6BXbg rfnNKr8lHCcqPE9ZHHiatRp4RZVHMTkcePYFfXyzYXCif/l0c2CLDji6In2W KZpSdlMqVvaHk9w8n62B47tzXKp9xjshrSaMssADv67r3wUvVwLxPONNgVbC YRzgqfrH93QGF3S8IoOwiP4IOtJsDnLfqtUiBl4yCzxaNPQdHF6gS54cMejT vIflu7iCE/tyvunPhmS4vEnyEOj6QTnpk1X5Jt6/ruvzCa8tGUenNBXGgSat oswAq/YFgwqElzS8tuHGDDXvX+AlwstaLj3wuj5f6ONBcXhLh9oV3Th04K3p qyp9LUoaM8Wu5k5ffsTzRpMHHbxKF/pycwC47SBrufkDnpdDw5gShWpT8YT+ BuP92t7ya249l+dYW7B6fkzw69rH1s+LdSnnu0V6bJRpRg+ftijx42ANsmoN 0Pib8E67t/law7cJkLbAMFCDk7Rllq5/i0eH6/3QFky90GSsw4yeOtE+8KQS ccXrtxQTHp8IaOojeGVHn47neq5FeCia0LkZ5jep1pnPgza8oOLJXUGwpggU 2gbceiO07QmvqPwGM2Jnh3tsXYxdHuru7Xg+Cd5J//ooE6wB+m6u+AnP3tdv i2cqXwVO95I69GWor3qVx0xfFH2W2Pl8CzoNi+NT1CJgCCmckegqK9Gk5Rnq 4MV7XG5Vb6tFREV6j5IvjSyNa9kfUdOXIPIV73G9m4UPMaKLy/fOJsfeY6Uv 3HcLXqz9Gc9ReDXky+sX4lkeF++B8InatEHD81Y6KUmKqB8qZu30hYcsQ+8j X+kTPLbO0Ge6G4i9kWrtn/DKyC2FvraKO+/R8bwmD9dPMLE+Y3+U4Y3U6IWn 4ELwKn3tS1wbqt0bwf5dvO+sL1y7Cr1vfsEzgRNyqh14RJNkiA7vdpfvwFPl azDz3OUBPDN731/bW9655Qn5ELgy2dP54d0KV1544p61xe9mTsfqcWx6xZPr maZKE/VxpHKqVRIPvKDiOb5CAAFu4AukR+VPq5zyZGDDyyq/Ntg+GiB3T5C5 Xt8L6fkqOsJLOn0y0xn73R2UWx6V4rs2d7yi8mv8fDcQ1q+xHgCj8zvwioL3 qX3GNvW7d2jYcH3T1QOeNXKs5bgXkmabtnhiTau6fkZGe3gCnXPz/IY+mYq4 rx9bF9QiuNJE52lRaVIrpwMvaPr8qf0NDcw88y3todOn5loDT5Pvp5p4zBDy +eFYX/G7wOOEDe/Jijzi7iazsT+iun8/NciVGKDP3eR73x97vFzLgcfRhgs7 +nB9N+GVjneudMrdSjX1qTq6X3Mz82yq0Df0+YwnM/I4wZR4f4z9ptorI/Ko TsVL9eCXb3Kkqb+N/TMc/Q28c+U0VEQvDn1kRAd4JWBd2e14/GJhlmM2n0Mo EKHFG0zu+cUzek7CMF7R8Fq2QJ4bE8dcuQ95tqc/zFuy+W3cciXxxi0OzSXM G+N5hMbttm9k+H23FR49PEgY3EdBbhnC7mY5I95yhQdjEeNxd0zyadeVNl6k K973Jl2QX8PYbV5Om1u9b2TwqEfDKyqeo7dq2r7PpVf+Ys6783OGS8srPL4i otlG260VHc/e7I4H+j6orOF+Q5lqcna+++TOL9+6HbK+Ozw9YfKhEBOWjf6A yThvSfV2lT6cbg7Zq/LNFs1yyv7kwvHazKHHVI56PtdE5jcHnV/5yCcWelFs M6Uy8CSaXODhlnse9w5m10c2rGBPeHxTHRvW7RTNQZ+6fv0j3piRoph7RV/a WNMzfQ/r1/G28sAM6zt+O56qfwMvnOSxxvNSe5EpHwVv1JrE8ckbGrZ7jxnP me49it3Ltxz8YoQLrlQFlGS1hK1A8MiHnDcAde3Ltf5P8XrkeyZwju9nwL1E 0nFGyMyAv7bD3Kzflt35qsm3An4B2HfIK8AHE5O/pnDYBPV2zVKPWRrz4aP6 Nat4HPGWYRM2t3V2G/OKwLGJVUA8FCVPkdgHQK7wyrTPksIvdrGw/ABY38vk HeC0hmkPKIFgKVsh46FzcSTmlZ0pZYd3NtSvhFxfc/xun/DR+AeZdC/wewBO FF5N6wLQbvV6tjUPLIuQZaprBcjREQvFboX8Ei8dSvO08YRjt9XCeQnDO47d a5k87JNB4R7wNFb9CtC/0GtzF/JP859dIGFr/KEyHPtzLetRBcPvJWDJOGvc bjq8KrkIkBYU7gF/g07HFxrjvqEw7W31EcI9eSepAtSyFfIctJa9kAXvve1/ 2sUYiIkyvvd7yAQUPgHOWvOkhq8AJ//5TiYN8HXU9eBMuO0VzdY78YNe8vxq 3YaFTmTyxtu9Cgv5Pc1o9t7pNwDuvRPLREl1VhvvHSAv4YM/7gT+fjIWAreW gTdyv1tiR6AVJfR741pGKvEkkk7gG++pcPzTvOc7ds/lqFfrt3fH893hLwXy BvBdzOrYzDz440MFHwogA+93swqi03vAKQh+tNRC4T7f/obCDvjaLLx0Tj37 PPfABuCUHz9EIN0u9GzxfNizf8zutIY7OyMc94BBx5v2yZNMhEDbnZMOOMdc D0vYAbupXgBO++RByMLyE+BE4UNI8w4Qz3m/y4/fAeK+BQn9/RshW7dVmrmU +ZbALeA3QhZA/0JrvtknT4D5azXs5eCFkI+Q5rxRfpr/fMcuLhPn+APHzKCC asz6Du8LUz0At3sErzS7d2bhFeAXyeI3gK+cyQBc7bqjBSNR9UMRqe+6uN0k fA/QCJJe2Jm4dSZzhealTNJrrXlpqtNWJl9YQn4cPdr8wn++qgi8A/xCazpg 2TuT1/Xqd3jfqLXI5D3gS++0j5G+iP074D5I+iIE6Wv4APg+/RRAZ7Yb5X3z c+DtI4Z8pJ8vCbRv48yf3fzs7PrfW8BL2//tJumAe9v/RfrZAfe2mlVwWMKV CtoqTz02vP0uRsD13KucAPeWFTrtnr0TAeLswRPg267TRGH5XYKk/xeARYQ8 DNf1LhqewaSIge8BpiHtgPOMSSWQHfwa71tTzRd1Rj8MoX5ZzhdLyBQ+AEa4 z1Gh/waQS743Ck+PYn3F8gLwpa059PoBkNNPnpk3+538Co8GlXvN4nch8Pt9 8gXgTibvAcu3psH3poQOOG+UkzX8Uf5zlvCW3Zfl9Nd4v0VjypbAPEo0rzVm C7jsbm9Y3gK+Na2vAeda5jv/+bSGk5A3TZ33S5jfG8KvZbIrCbzm+O0YyJcU /o56/RucSQ/8F87kXfo5EbjH25lq+5sAvzDVwrHbbzz/fuMJheG1Xr/ceOm1 NXxgmS8Nir7PFS6E7I+C9aZaOOGVLYFc3PPfEFi3Qv7/I/082A2/n7tjjQm/ m53pFD7surzexgvAPiHwP3UmA+91wPWwizug3+6RefDl5RL6F5bwuSpFgLgM 5h3gOyELYNjK5LcAboWSp0MIm8bYa7zfoNZxK+RvZNIBX+yTV96ps5xey+Rp 470C5I0yQvVXgPvYv35exv4v8aZQ/e0SdsDHofeXav0A+LKdOmlNr50tAOvX WjMcvD5bMt0KeGrE/Dj/adjd9brZgt2jnP7kTF7hfWEW8IAZAW41BvPpUst8 3MXlBeBqPOz/AvQ9XMsyEwEA ---556791216-321133549-1045260877=:24530-- - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/