MIME-version: 1.0
Content-type: text/plain; charset=utf-8; format=flowed
Content-transfer-encoding: 8BIT
Message-id: <55CCF156.8010302@samsung.com>
Date: Thu, 13 Aug 2015 21:34:46 +0200
From: Krzysztof Opasiak <k.opasiak@samsung.com>
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:31.0) Gecko/20100101
 Thunderbird/31.4.0
To: Amit Pundir <amit.pundir@linaro.org>, linux-usb@vger.kernel.org,
        linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org, linux-doc@vger.kernel.org,
        linux-api@vger.kernel.org
Cc: Mike Lockwood <lockwood@android.com>, Benoit Goby <benoit@android.com>,
        Colin Cross <ccross@android.com>,
        =?UTF-8?B?QXJ2ZSBIasO4bm5ldsOlZw==?= <arve@android.com>,
        Peter Oh <poh@broadcom.com>, Greg Hackmann <ghackmann@google.com>,
        Badhri Jagan Sridharan <Badhri@google.com>,
        Android Kernel Team <kernel-team@android.com>,
        Greg Kroah-Hartman <gregkh@linuxfoundation.org>,
        Jonathan Corbet <corbet@lwn.net>, Felipe Balbi <balbi@ti.com>,
        Andrzej Pietrasiewicz <andrzej.p@samsung.com>,
        Laurent Pinchart <laurent.pinchart@ideasonboard.com>,
        Yegor Yefremov <yegorslists@googlemail.com>,
        Philippe Reynes <tremyfr@gmail.com>,
        John Stultz <john.stultz@linaro.org>,
        Sumit Semwal <sumit.semwal@linaro.org>
Subject: Re: [RFC][PATCH 1/2] usb: gadget: configfs: add MTP function
References: <1439493140-22207-1-git-send-email-amit.pundir@linaro.org>
 <1439493140-22207-2-git-send-email-amit.pundir@linaro.org>
In-reply-to: <1439493140-22207-2-git-send-email-amit.pundir@linaro.org>
Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org
Content-Length: 3583
Lines: 77

Hello,

On 08/13/2015 09:12 PM, Amit Pundir wrote:
> his MTP function is based on years of work originally done in the
> Android kernel tree by:
>      Mike Lockwood<lockwood@android.com>
>      Benoit Goby<benoit@android.com>
>      Colin Cross<ccross@android.com>
>      Arve Hjønnevåg<arve@android.com>
>      Peter Oh<poh@broadcom.com>
>      Greg Hackmann<ghackmann@google.com>
>      Badhri Jagan Sridharan<Badhri@google.com>
> I've folded the series up to make it easier to review, and to provide
> a coherent patch description.
>
> Post Gingerbread (Android v2.3), Android dropped USB Mass Storage
> in favor of Media Transfer Protocal (MTP), which is widely used for
> transferring media files to digital music players and similar
> applications. This USB gadget function implements MTP functionalty.
>
> Historically this function has been a part of Android composite
> gadget driver. Android composite driver was Android's solution
> for dynamic gadget function switching prior to the ConfigFS gadget
> being merged. There were failed few attempts in past
> http://marc.info/?l=linux-usb&m=132451695808552  to upstream Android
> composite driver as well. Now this Android MTP gadget function has been
> re-implemented so as to be used as a generic ConfigFS function instead.
>
> Again, many thanks to Mike, Benoit, Colin, Arve, Peter, Greg and Badhri,
> as they are the real authors of this work. However, I've folded their
> patches together and modified it enough that I don't want them to be
> blamed for any mistakes I've made condensing their patches down.
>
> Cc: Mike Lockwood<lockwood@android.com>
> Cc: Benoit Goby<benoit@android.com>
> Cc: Colin Cross<ccross@android.com>
> Cc: Arve Hjønnevåg<arve@android.com>
> Cc: Peter Oh<poh@broadcom.com>
> Cc: Greg Hackmann<ghackmann@google.com>
> Cc: Badhri Jagan Sridharan<Badhri@google.com>
> Cc: Android Kernel Team<kernel-team@android.com>
> Cc: Greg Kroah-Hartman<gregkh@linuxfoundation.org>
> Cc: Jonathan Corbet<corbet@lwn.net>
> Cc: Felipe Balbi<balbi@ti.com>
> Cc: Andrzej Pietrasiewicz<andrzej.p@samsung.com>
> Cc: Laurent Pinchart<laurent.pinchart@ideasonboard.com>
> Cc: Yegor Yefremov<yegorslists@googlemail.com>
> Cc: Philippe Reynes<tremyfr@gmail.com>
> Cc: John Stultz<john.stultz@linaro.org>
> Cc: Sumit Semwal<sumit.semwal@linaro.org>
> Signed-off-by: Amit Pundir<amit.pundir@linaro.org>

In my humble opinion adding such function to Linux kernel doesn't make 
any sense. By design, MTP is a protocol which requires access to 
userspace features esp. file system. It is very important to run MTP 
daemon with suitable user and LSM label and many many other issues which 
should be handled by userspace access policy.

Moreover this is not a fully functional USB function but only some 
interface which can be used by mtp-responder (mtp-daemon - call it as 
you like) to communicate with host. As we have FunctionFS which allows 
to implement any USB function in as a userspace service. As MTP nature 
is more related to userspace I think that porting MTP daemon to use this 
is a right way to go. This should be much more reasonable than adding 
new function which also requires daemon for proper working. So why add 
another interface while we can use a generic one?

Best regards,
-- 
Krzysztof Opasiak
Samsung R&D Institute Poland
Samsung Electronics
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/