Return-Path: Received: (majordomo@vger.kernel.org) by vger.kernel.org via listexpand id S1754685AbdDDT6u (ORCPT ); Tue, 4 Apr 2017 15:58:50 -0400 Received: from mga02.intel.com ([134.134.136.20]:54000 "EHLO mga02.intel.com" rhost-flags-OK-OK-OK-OK) by vger.kernel.org with ESMTP id S1754491AbdDDT6s (ORCPT ); Tue, 4 Apr 2017 15:58:48 -0400 X-ExtLoop1: 1 X-IronPort-AV: E=Sophos;i="5.36,275,1486454400"; d="scan'208";a="1150953307" Message-ID: <1491335924.7125.87.camel@tzanussi-mobl.amr.corp.intel.com> Subject: Re: [PATCH v2 0/5] minitty: a minimal TTY layer alternative for embedded systems From: Tom Zanussi To: Andy Shevchenko Cc: Geert Uytterhoeven , Stuart Longland , Nicolas Pitre , Andi Kleen , Greg Kroah-Hartman , Jiri Slaby , "linux-serial@vger.kernel.org" , "linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org" , "linux-arm-kernel@lists.infradead.org" Date: Tue, 04 Apr 2017 14:58:44 -0500 In-Reply-To: References: <20170401222119.25106-1-nicolas.pitre@linaro.org> <87pogur0y9.fsf@firstfloor.org> <92fb1e4a-d6df-f55b-c0a1-9c1eb78e3943@longlandclan.id.au> <1491325150.7125.62.camel@tzanussi-mobl.amr.corp.intel.com> <1491328749.7125.66.camel@tzanussi-mobl.amr.corp.intel.com> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8" X-Mailer: Evolution 3.10.4 (3.10.4-4.fc20) Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org List-ID: X-Mailing-List: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org Content-Length: 14854 Lines: 416 On Tue, 2017-04-04 at 21:04 +0300, Andy Shevchenko wrote: > On Tue, Apr 4, 2017 at 8:59 PM, Tom Zanussi wrote: > > On Tue, 2017-04-04 at 20:08 +0300, Andy Shevchenko wrote: > >> On Tue, Apr 4, 2017 at 7:59 PM, Tom Zanussi wrote: > >> > On Tue, 2017-04-04 at 00:05 +0300, Andy Shevchenko wrote: > > >> > I was focused at that point mainly on the kernel static size, and using > >> > a combination of Josh Triplett's tinification tree, Andi Kleen's LTO and > >> > net-diet patches, and my own miscellaneous patches that I was planning > >> > on eventually upstreaming, I ended up with a system that I could boot to > >> > shell with a 455k text size: > >> > > >> > Memory: 235636K/245176K available (455K kernel code, 61K rwdata, > >> > 64K rodata, 132K init, 56K bss, 3056K reserved, 0K cma-reserved) > > >> Thanks for sharing your experience. The question closer to this > >> discussion what did you do against TTY/UART/(related) layer(s)? > >> > > > > I'd have to go back and take a look, but nothing special AFIAR. > > > > No patches or hacks along those lines, and the only related thing I see > > as far as config is: > > > > cfg/pty-disable.scc \ > > > > which maps to: > > > > # CONFIG_UNIX98_PTYS is not set > > But on your guestimation how much can we squeeze TTY/UART layer if we > do some compile-time configuration? > Does it even make sense or better to introduce something like minitty > special layer instead? > > I believe you did some research during time of that project… > Yes, as a matter of fact I did, and just found some notes I took at the time. I didn't dive into the code in detail - that level of analysis was supposed to come later but I did have these notes mentioning that I thought it would show the largest savings for a single item (outside of networking) 'if we could do it': "- Largest is still drivers - drivers/tty and serial is the biggest obvious win if we can do it - break down into granular config options - leave simplest possible tty/serial functionality - allow tailoring to specific hardware - also helps in effort to get rid of char devices - 65740/815190" Basically 65k out of an 800k text size could be partially or mostly saved by addressing that one item, which looks like it pretty much matches Nicolas' numbers... So no doubt it would be worthwhile to address one way or the other. Whether to do that by refactoring the tty layer or partial refactoring and creation of a parallel minimal version would best be left up to someone who actually understands it I would think... BTW, since I'm quoting my own notes on the subject, I thought I'd just include the whole thing, which covers a bunch of other areas possibly ripe for tinification, in case anyone might be interested (some of it should be taken with a grain of salt though ;-) Tom -------- galileo SMALLEST_SIZE $ size vmlinux text data bss dec hex filename 699668 186432 2271592 3157692 302ebc vmlinux Not using this, because $ size xxx.o shows all 0s with LTO ---- Using this: galileo SMALLEST_SIZE with LTO off $ size vmlinux text data bss dec hex filename 815190 165696 2272760 3253646 31a58e vmlinux This corresponds to LTO size: $ size vmlinux text data bss dec hex filename 677183 179528 1207280 2063991 1f7e77 vmlinux $ ls -al arch/x86/boot/bzImage -rw-r--r--. 1 427264 Mar 12 22:34 arch/x86/boot/bzImage And booted size: Memory: 235388K/245240K available (534K kernel code, 100K rwdata, 52K rodata, 14 8K init, 64K bss, 3172K reserved, 0K cma-reserved) virtual kernel memory layout: fixmap : 0xfffa4000 - 0xfffff000 ( 364 kB) vmalloc : 0xd05f0000 - 0xfffa2000 ( 761 MB) lowmem : 0xc0000000 - 0xcfdf0000 ( 253 MB) .init : 0xc10af000 - 0xc10d4000 ( 148 kB) .data : 0xc1085b9c - 0xc10ad120 ( 157 kB) .text : 0xc1000000 - 0xc1085b9c ( 534 kB) ------ Totals - details below ------ - make ptrace configurable - this should help the hw breakpoints and x86 perf disable patches upstream - 5k - remove things not needed for CONFIG_SMP - 5k - support configuring out kswapd - about 5k in vmscan - support configuring out vmstat - 0 - kernel capabilities - 1k - exec domains - 1k - tsc 3030 284 40 3354 d1a ./arch/x86/kernel/tsc.o 332 0 0 332 14c ./arch/x86/kernel/tsc_msr.o - support configuring out signals 11852 36 4 11892 2e74 ./kernel/signal.o 3188 1 0 3189 c75 ./arch/x86/kernel/signal.o - about 15k - kernel/pid.o simplification - more for dynamic memory - simpler pidhash 1868 160 4 2032 7f0 ./kernel/pid.o - about 2k - remove kernel/exit.o - assume processes never exit - remove lib/kfifo - about 2k - remove kernel/irq/spurious - about 1k - make sys configurable - about 7k - remove xattr - about 4k - /drivers total possible savings, some percentage of: - 136000/815190 - /kernel savings - say 30000/815190 savings - /fs savings - 30000/815190 savings - /arch/x86 savings - 20000/815190 - /mm - 5000/815190 - /lib - 10000/815190 Totals without mmu: 146k + (2/3)*136k = 235k 235k/815190 = 30% savings - x86 nommu - about 50k Totals with mmu: 285k/815190 = 35% savings Applied to the 534k boot figure, we end up with text size of: 374k mmu 347k nommu We could probably go lower with more fine-grained analysis, but we may also need to add drivers, etc. ----- NONET details ----- - Largest is still drivers - drivers/tty and serial is the biggest obvious win if we can do it - break down into granular config options - leave simplest possible tty/serial functionality - allow tailoring to specific hardware - also helps in effort to get rid of char devices - 65740/815190 - pci is next largest - assume we can break down into granular config options - leave simplest possible pci functionality - allow tailoring to specific hardware e.g. no discovery - 47144/815190 - drivers/base - simplify driver core for a small set of drivers - simple_char: New infrastructure to simplify chardev management - 25389/815190 - total possible savings, some percentage of: - 136000/815190 206992 29331 6556 242879 3b4bf ./drivers/built-in.o 65740 16888 3132 85760 14f00 ./drivers/tty/built-in.o 32077 16680 2688 51445 c8f5 ./drivers/tty/serial/built-in.o 21628 15892 2644 40164 9ce4 ./drivers/tty/serial/8250/built-in.o 47144 1172 2100 50416 c4f0 ./drivers/pci/built-in.o 25389 1324 112 26825 68c9 ./drivers/base/built-in.o 15733 636 20 16389 4005 ./drivers/spi/built-in.o 11504 136 28 11668 2d94 ./drivers/clk/built-in.o 9605 460 72 10137 2799 ./drivers/thermal/built-in.o 5066 624 912 6602 19ca ./drivers/char/built-in.o 8531 480 36 9047 2357 ./drivers/i2c/built-in.o - 2nd largest is kernel - should be able to cut *something* from time and sched - we have a handful of processes at most - we have very simple time needs - say 30000/815190 savings 150742 6376 8209 165327 285cf ./kernel/built-in.o 40951 1105 4720 46776 b6b8 ./kernel/time/built-in.o 21760 1318 112 23190 5a96 ./kernel/sched/built-in.o 9800 388 1328 11516 2cfc ./kernel/irq/built-in.o 4956 4 4 4964 1364 ./kernel/locking/built-in.o 1847 88 184 2119 847 ./kernel/printk/built-in.o 1757 33 0 1790 6fe ./kernel/rcu/built-in.o 1408 356 44 1808 710 ./kernel/power/built-in.o - next is fs - completely turn off proc - requires userspace changes to cope with it - 22046/815190, 100% of this - simplify/featurize some core vfs? - e.g. namei, small set of file names, no need for complexity - disable vfs completely? - init reads executables directly from storage - all state in memory, no need to save anything 133526 1506 1552 136584 21588 ./fs/built-in.o 22046 140 40 22226 56d2 ./fs/proc/built-in.o - next is arch/x86, mostly in arch/x86/kernel - not much to save here, maybe 10 here and there - maybe 3k in boot: video* - maybe 5k in cpu: amd, transmeta, cachinfo, etc - cut about 10k in arch/x86/mm for nommu 120755 50209 52712 223676 369bc ./arch/x86/built-in.o 100201 29261 19828 149290 2472a ./arch/x86/kernel/built-in.o 21713 8693 720 31126 7996 ./arch/x86/kernel/cpu/built-in.o 17480 5486 6324 29290 726a ./arch/x86/kernel/apic/built-in.o 10385 4365 532 15282 3bb2 ./arch/x86/kernel/cpu/mcheck/built-in.o 18237 208 30776 49221 c045 ./arch/x86/mm/built-in.o 14276 412 256 14944 3a60 ./arch/x86/pci/built-in.o 1345 8 28 1381 565 ./arch/x86/platform/intel-quark/built-in.o 1345 8 28 1381 565 ./arch/x86/platform/built-in.o 590 8228 16 8834 2282 ./arch/x86/vdso/built-in.o 379 12500 8 12887 3257 ./arch/x86/realmode/built-in.o 477 0 0 477 1dd ./arch/x86/lib/built-in.o - next is mm - cut about 5k for percpu - cut about 40k for nommu 119008 13688 1824 134520 20d78 ./mm/built-in.o 1358 0 0 1358 54e ./mm/gup.o 10612 32 24 10668 29ac ./mm/memory.o 1072 0 0 1072 430 ./mm/mincore.o 2453 0 0 2453 995 ./mm/mlock.o 9918 176 8 10102 2776 ./mm/mmap.o 1403 0 0 1403 57b ./mm/mprotect.o 2155 0 0 2155 86b ./mm/mremap.o 520 0 0 520 208 ./mm/msync.o 4358 0 8 4366 110e ./mm/rmap.o 6355 57 28 6440 1928 ./mm/vmalloc.o 710 0 0 710 2c6 ./mm/pagewalk.o 92 0 0 92 5c ./mm/pgtable-generic.o - next is lib - no need for vsprintf if printk off, 10k 30654 24647 5 55306 d80a ./lib/built-in.o 9964 0 0 9964 26ec ./lib/zlib_inflate/built-in.o -next is init 8456 16437 81 24974 618e ./init/built-in.o ---- Net sizes, maybe later... galileo SMALLEST_SIZE_NET with LTO off - this is without ipv4 net-diet - includes ipv6 $ size vmlinux text data bss dec hex filename 1368973 181184 2288560 3838717 3a92fd vmlinux --- NET details --- - net now largest, larger than drivers (and drivers goes up too) 465384 13818 17364 496566 793b6 ./net/built-in.o 183144 5409 7948 196501 2ff95 ./net/ipv4/built-in.o 128583 4648 6432 139663 2218f ./net/ipv6/built-in.o 108158 2092 2804 113054 1b99e ./net/core/built-in.o 15268 264 0 15532 3cac ./net/packet/built-in.o 14787 465 148 15400 3c28 ./net/netlink/built-in.o 4011 676 0 4687 124f ./net/sched/built-in.o 967 12 0 979 3d3 ./net/ethernet/built-in.o - drivers second largest 255026 30512 6604 292142 4752e ./drivers/built-in.o 359 20 0 379 17b ./drivers/reset/built-in.o 2155 152 32 2339 923 ./drivers/pps/built-in.o 8870 580 0 9450 24ea ./drivers/net/phy/built-in.o 42421 861 8 43290 a91a ./drivers/net/built-in.o 30650 233 8 30891 78ab ./drivers/net/ethernet/stmicro/stmmac/built-in.o 30650 233 8 30891 78ab ./drivers/net/ethernet/stmicro/built-in.o 30650 233 8 30891 78ab ./drivers/net/ethernet/built-in.o 47144 1172 2100 50416 c4f0 ./drivers/pci/built-in.o 11504 136 28 11668 2d94 ./drivers/clk/built-in.o 25389 1324 112 26825 68c9 ./drivers/base/built-in.o 15733 636 20 16389 4005 ./drivers/spi/built-in.o 5066 624 912 6602 19ca ./drivers/char/built-in.o 9931 548 76 10555 293b ./drivers/thermal/built-in.o 4927 224 36 5187 1443 ./drivers/ptp/built-in.o 65740 16888 3132 85760 14f00 ./drivers/tty/built-in.o 32077 16680 2688 51445 c8f5 ./drivers/tty/serial/built-in.o 21628 15892 2644 40164 9ce4 ./drivers/tty/serial/8250/built-in.o 8531 480 36 9047 2357 ./drivers/i2c/built-in.o - kernel next 157407 6376 8209 171992 29fd8 ./kernel/built-in.o 9800 388 1328 11516 2cfc ./kernel/irq/built-in.o 40951 1105 4720 46776 b6b8 ./kernel/time/built-in.o 6665 0 0 6665 1a09 ./kernel/bpf/built-in.o 1408 356 44 1808 710 ./kernel/power/built-in.o 21760 1318 112 23190 5a96 ./kernel/sched/built-in.o 4956 4 4 4964 1364 ./kernel/locking/built-in.o 1757 33 0 1790 6fe ./kernel/rcu/built-in.o 1847 88 184 2119 847 ./kernel/printk/built-in.o - fs next 134562 1534 1552 137648 219b0 ./fs/built-in.o 1395 276 4 1675 68b ./fs/ramfs/built-in.o 22743 168 40 22951 59a7 ./fs/proc/built-in.o 1446 44 8 1498 5da ./fs/devpts/built-in.o - arch/x86 next 120755 50209 52712 223676 369bc ./arch/x86/built-in.o 379 12500 8 12887 3257 ./arch/x86/realmode/built-in.o 14276 412 256 14944 3a60 ./arch/x86/pci/built-in.o 590 8228 16 8834 2282 ./arch/x86/vdso/built-in.o 18237 208 30776 49221 c045 ./arch/x86/mm/built-in.o 477 0 0 477 1dd ./arch/x86/lib/built-in.o 1345 8 28 1381 565 ./arch/x86/platform/intel-quark/built-in.o 1345 8 28 1381 565 ./arch/x86/platform/built-in.o 17480 5486 6324 29290 726a ./arch/x86/kernel/apic/built-in.o 21713 8693 720 31126 7996 ./arch/x86/kernel/cpu/built-in.o 10385 4365 532 15282 3bb2 ./arch/x86/kernel/cpu/mcheck/built-in.o 100201 29261 19828 149290 2472a ./arch/x86/kernel/built-in.o - mm next 119008 13688 1824 134520 20d78 ./mm/built-in.o - lib next 33042 24647 5 57694 e15e ./lib/built-in.o 9964 0 0 9964 26ec ./lib/zlib_inflate/built-in.o - crypto next 30068 284 0 30352 7690 ./crypto/built-in.o - init next 8456 16437 81 24974 618e ./init/built-in.o