Received-SPF: pass (google.com: best guess record for domain of linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org designates 209.132.180.67 as permitted sender) client-ip=209.132.180.67;
Subject: Re: [PATCH v5 5/6] net: maclorawan: Implement maclorawan class module
To:     Jian-Hong Pan <starnight@g.ncu.edu.tw>,
        Jiri Pirko <jiri@resnulli.us>,
        Ben Whitten <ben.whitten@lairdtech.com>
Cc:     "David S. Miller" <davem@davemloft.net>,
        Alan Cox <gnomes@lxorguk.ukuu.org.uk>,
        linux-lpwan@lists.infradead.org, netdev@vger.kernel.org,
        linux-arm-kernel@lists.infradead.org, linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org,
        Marcel Holtmann <marcel@holtmann.org>,
        Dollar Chen <dollar.chen@wtmec.com>,
        Ken Yu <ken.yu@rakwireless.com>,
        linux-wpan - ML <linux-wpan@vger.kernel.org>
References: <CAC=mGziyi1ierhg++SUcHMrq1JQ0vH4gZCKUZgchzb8aD1Rv5Q@mail.gmail.com>
 <20181216101858.9585-6-starnight@g.ncu.edu.tw>
 <20181217140233.GG2096@nanopsycho>
 <CAC=mGziN5KrXPMAXoN_hhfQrtofCeyzTr4AjbbJLOoJ+p2+Nng@mail.gmail.com>
From:   =?UTF-8?Q?Andreas_F=c3=a4rber?= <afaerber@suse.de>
Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
Autocrypt: addr=afaerber@suse.de; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata=
 xsFNBE6W6ZQBEAC/BIukDnkVenIkK9O14UucicBIVvRB5WSMHC23msS+R2h915mW7/vXfn+V
 0nrr5ECmEg/5OjujKf0x/uhJYrsxcp45nDyYCk+RYoOJmGzzUFya1GvT/c04coZ8VmgFUWGE
 vCfhHJro85dZUL99IoLP21VXEVlCPyIngSstikeuf14SY17LPTN1aIpGQDI2Qt8HHY1zOVWv
 iz53aiFLFeIVhQlBmOABH2Ifr2M9loRC9yOyGcE2GhlzgyHGlQxEVGFn/QptX6iYbtaTBTU0
 c72rpmbe1Nec6hWuzSwu2uE8lF+HYcYi+22ml1XBHNMBeAdSEbSfDbwc///8QKtckUzbDvME
 S8j4KuqQhwvYkSg7dV9rs53WmjO2Wd4eygkC3tBhPM5s38/6CVGl3ABiWJs3kB08asUNy8Wk
 juusU/nRJbXDzxu1d+hv0d+s5NOBy/5+7Pa6HeyBnh1tUmCs5/f1D/cJnuzzYwAmZTHFUsfQ
 ygGBRRKpAVu0VxCFNPSYKW0ULi5eZV6bcj+NAhtafGsWcv8WPFXgVE8s2YU38D1VtlBvCo5/
 0MPtQORqAQ/Itag1EHHtnfuK3MBtA0fNxQbb2jha+/oMAi5hKpmB/zAlFoRtYHwjFPFldHfv
 Iljpe1S0rDASaF9NsQPfUBEm7dA5UUkyvvi00HZ3e7/uyBGb0QARAQABzSJBbmRyZWFzIEbD
 pHJiZXIgPGFmYWVyYmVyQHN1c2UuZGU+wsF7BBMBAgAlAhsDBgsJCAcDAgYVCAIJCgsEFgID
 AQIeAQIXgAUCTqGJnQIZAQAKCRD6LtEtPn4BPzetD/4rF6k/HF+9U9KqykfJaWdUHJvXpI85
 Roab12rQbiIrL4hVEYKrYwPEKpCf+FthXpgOq+JdTGJ831DMlTx7Ed5/QJ9KAAQuhZlSNjSc
 +FNobJm7EbFv9jWFjQC0JcOl17Ji1ikgRcIRDCul1nQh9jCdfh1b848GerZmzteNdT9afRJm
 7rrvMqXs1Y52/dTlfIW0ygMA2n5Vv3EwykXJOPF6fRimkErKO84sFMNg0eJV9mXs+Zyionfi
 g2sZJfVeKjkDqjxy7sDDBZZR68I9HWq5VJQrXqQkCZUvtr6TBLI+uiDLbGRUDNxA3wgjVdS2
 v9bhjYceSOHpKU+h3H2S8ju9rjhOADT2F5lUQMTSpjlzglh8IatV5rXLGkXEyum4MzMo2sCE
 Cr+GD6i2M3pHCtaIVV3xV0nRGALa6DdF7jBWqM54KHaKsE883kFH2+6ARcPCPrnPm7LX98h2
 4VpG984ysoq6fpzHHG/KCaYCEOe1bpr3Plmmp3sqj0utA6lwzJy0hj5dqug+lqmg7QKAnxl+
 porgluoY56U0X0PIVBc0yO0dWqRxtylJa9kDX/TKwFYNVddMn2NQNjOJXzx2H9hf0We7rG7+
 F/vgwALVVYbiTzvp2L0XATTv/oX4BHagAa/Qc3dIsBYJH+KVhBp+ZX4uguxk4xlc2hm75b1s
 cqeAD87BTQROlumUARAAzd7eu+tw/52FB7xQZWDv5aF+6CAkoz7AuY4s1fo0AQQDqjLOdpQF
 bifdH7B8SnsA4eo0syfs+1tZW6nn9hdy1GHEMbeuvdhNwkhEfYGDYpSue7oVxB4jajKvRHAP
 VcewKZIxvIiZ5aSp5n1Bd7B0c0C443DHiWE/0XWSpvbU7fTzTNvdz+2OZmGtqCn610gBqScv
 1BOiP3OfLly8ghxcJsos23c0mkB/1iWlzh3UMFIGrzsK3sZJ/3uRaLYFimmqqPlSwFqx3b0M
 1gFdHWKfOpvQ4wwP5P10xwvqNXLWC30wB1QmJGD/X8aAoVNnGsmEL7GcWF4cLoOSRidSoccz
 znShE+Ap+FVDD6MRyesNT4D67l792//B38CGJRdELtNacdwazaFgxH9O85Vnd70ZC7fIcwzG
 yg/4ZEf96DlAvrSOnu/kgklofEYdzpZmW+Fqas6cnk6ZaHa35uHuBPesdE13MVz5TeiHGQTW
 xP1jbgWQJGPvJZ+htERT8SZGBQRb1paoRd1KWQ1mlr3CQvXtfA/daq8p/wL48sXrKNwedrLV
 iZOeJOFwfpJgsFU4xLoO/8N0RNFsnelBgWgZE3ZEctEd4BsWFUw+czYCPYfqOcJ556QUGA9y
 DeDcxSitpYrNIvpk4C5CHbvskVLKPIUVXxTNl8hAGo1Ahm1VbNkYlocAEQEAAcLBXwQYAQIA
 CQUCTpbplAIbDAAKCRD6LtEtPn4BPzA6D/9TbSBOPM99SHPX9JiEQAw4ITCBF2oTWeZQ6RJg
 RKpB15lzyPfyFbNSceJp9dCiwDWe+pzKaX6KYOFZ5+YTS0Ph2eCR+uT2l6Mt6esAun8dvER/
 xlPDW7p88dwGUcV8mHEukWdurSEDTj8V3K29vpgvIgRq2lHCn2wqRQBGpiJAt72Vg0HxUlwN
 GAJNvhpeW8Yb43Ek7lWExkUgOfNsDCTvDInF8JTFtEXMnUcPxC0d/GdAuvBilL9SlmzvoDIZ
 5k2k456bkY3+3/ydDvKU5WIgThydyCEQUHlmE6RdA3C1ccIrIvKjVEwSH27Pzy5jKQ78qnhv
 dtLLAavOXyBJnOGlNDOpOyBXfv02x91RoRiyrSIM7dKmMEINKQlAMgB/UU/6B+mvzosbs5d3
 4FPzBLuuRz9WYzXmnC460m2gaEVk1GjpidBWw0yY6kgnAM3KhwCFSecqUQCvwKFDGSXDDbCr
 w08b3GDk40UoCoUq9xrGfhlf05TUSFTg2NlSrK7+wAEsTUgs2ZYLpHyEeftoDDnKpM4ghs/O
 ceCeyZUP1zSgRSjgITQp691Uli5Nd1mIzaaM8RjOE/Rw67FwgblKR6HAhSy/LYw1HVOu+Ees
 RAEdbtRt37A8brlb/ENxbLd9SGC8/j20FQjit7oPNMkTJDs7Uo2eb7WxOt5pSTVVqZkv7Q==
Organization: SUSE Linux GmbH
Message-ID: <60ff6940-4bcc-750c-ad38-0a183375169f@suse.de>
Date:   Tue, 18 Dec 2018 19:49:03 +0100
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:60.0) Gecko/20100101
 Thunderbird/60.3.0
MIME-Version: 1.0
In-Reply-To: <CAC=mGziN5KrXPMAXoN_hhfQrtofCeyzTr4AjbbJLOoJ+p2+Nng@mail.gmail.com>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Language: en-US
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org
Precedence: bulk

Am 18.12.18 um 15:27 schrieb Jian-Hong Pan:
>> Sun, Dec 16, 2018 at 11:18:59AM CET, starnight@g.ncu.edu.tw wrote:
>>> LoRaWAN defined by LoRa Alliance(TM) is the MAC layer over LoRa devices.
>>>
>>> This patch implements part of Class A end-devices SoftMAC defined in
>>> LoRaWAN(TM) Specification Ver. 1.0.2:
>>> 1. End-device receive slot timing
>>> 2. Only single channel and single data rate for now
>>> 3. Unconfirmed data up/down message types
>>>
>>> On the other side, it defines the basic interface and operation
>>> functions for compatible LoRa device drivers.
>>>
>>> Signed-off-by: Jian-Hong Pan <starnight@g.ncu.edu.tw>
[...]
>>> net/maclorawan/Kconfig  |  14 +
>>> net/maclorawan/Makefile |   2 +
>>> net/maclorawan/mac.c    | 555 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
>>> net/maclorawan/main.c   | 606 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
>>> 4 files changed, 1177 insertions(+)
>>> create mode 100644 net/maclorawan/Kconfig
>>> create mode 100644 net/maclorawan/Makefile
>>> create mode 100644 net/maclorawan/mac.c
>>> create mode 100644 net/maclorawan/main.c
>>
>> I don't get it. In patch "Add LoRaWAN API declaration for LoRa devices"
>> you add headers for "API" and here you implement functions. That is just
>> weird. Does it mean you can have other implementations?
> 
> LoRaWAN defined by LoRa Alliance(TM) is the MAC layer over LoRa PHY.
> This part is soft-MAC as Andreas mentioned
> http://lists.infradead.org/pipermail/linux-lpwan/2018-December/000010.html
> 
>> Also, you don't really have any user of this API in the set. Please
>> introduce at least 1 driver, preferably more (I see that Andreas has
>> multiple ones in his patchset). You cannot push kernel infrastructure
>> without kernel user.
> 
> The soft-MAC is suitable for the LoRa chips' device drivers, like
> sx1276/77/78/79, RFM95/96/97/98W ...
> Still waiting for Andreas' sx1276 version 2 patch and more discussion.

sx1276 regmap conversion was pushed to my staging tree together with
Ben's sx1301 final conversion last night, lightly tested.

https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/afaerber/linux-lora.git/log/?h=lora-next

TBD: rename to sx127x, implement regmap fields, only auto-detect reset
when no OF node available (all low priority atm, patches welcome)

(and for sx1301 I still need to update my DT overlays with the new clk)

> For example, how to make PF_LORA and PF_LORAWAN like Ethernet, PF_INET
> and PF_INET6 don't need separate devices either, both use eth0.
> https://lkml.org/lkml/2018/8/3/266

Jiri, I am expecting the maclorawan driver to lower packets from
ETH_P_LORAWAN to ETH_P_LORA in a generic way, so that any of the LoRa
device drivers can benefit of it, with maclorawan using the LoRa netlink
commands that the individual drivers implement.
Not sure what if anything is missing for that in the current revision?
Still dealing with the lower-level infrastructure and my test setup ...
progressing slowly.

I'll probably need to queue the remaining generic LoRaWAN part 1/6 in my
tree to resolve this circular dependency between Jian-Hong and me, so
that only the soft-MAC implementation remains a separate patch series.
The hard-MAC implementations will be on my plate mostly, as both SX1276
and SX1301 need the soft-MAC.

Regards,
Andreas

-- 
SUSE Linux GmbH, Maxfeldstr. 5, 90409 Nürnberg, Germany
GF: Felix Imendörffer, Jane Smithard, Graham Norton
HRB 21284 (AG Nürnberg)