Date: Tue, 7 Mar 2006 13:16:53 +0300
From: Evgeniy Polyakov <johnpol@2ka.mipt.ru>
To: Ingo Oeser <netdev@axxeo.de>
Cc: "David S. Miller" <davem@davemloft.net>, jengelh@linux01.gwdg.de,
       christopher.leech@intel.com, linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org,
       netdev@vger.kernel.org
Subject: Re: [PATCH 0/8] Intel I/O Acceleration Technology (I/OAT)
Message-ID: <20060307101653.GA7276@2ka.mipt.ru>
References: <20060303214036.11908.10499.stgit@gitlost.site> <200603061844.07439.netdev@axxeo.de> <20060307074438.GA22672@2ka.mipt.ru> <200603071043.59479.netdev@axxeo.de>
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="ew6BAiZeqk4r7MaW"
Content-Disposition: inline
In-Reply-To: <200603071043.59479.netdev@axxeo.de>
User-Agent: Mutt/1.5.9i
Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org
Content-Length: 18460
Lines: 300


--ew6BAiZeqk4r7MaW
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Disposition: inline

On Tue, Mar 07, 2006 at 10:43:59AM +0100, Ingo Oeser (netdev@axxeo.de) wrote:
> Evgeniy Polyakov wrote:
> > On Mon, Mar 06, 2006 at 06:44:07PM +0100, Ingo Oeser (netdev@axxeo.de) wrote:
> > > Hmm, so I should resurrect my user page table walker abstraction?
> > > 
> > > There I would hand each page to a "recording" function, which
> > > can drop the page from the collection or coalesce it in the collector
> > > if your scatter gather implementation allows it.
> > 
> > It depends on where performance growth is stopped.
> > From the first glance it does not look like find_extend_vma(),
> > probably follow_page() fault and thus __handle_mm_fault().
> > I can not say actually, but if it is true and performance growth is
> > stopped due to increased number of faults and it's processing, 
> > your approach will hit this problem too, doesn't it?
> 
> My approach reduced the number of loops performed and number
> of memory needed at the expense of doing more work in the main
> loop of get_user_pages. 
> 
> This was mitigated for the common case of getting just one page by 
> providing a get_one_user_page() function.
> 
> The whole problem, why we need such multiple loops is that we have
> no common container object for "IO vector + additional data".
> 
> So we always do a loop working over the vector returned by 
> get_user_pages() all the time. The bigger that vector, 
> the bigger the impact.
> 
> Maybe sth. as simple as providing get_user_pages() with some offset_of 
> and container_of hackery will work these days without the disadvantages 
> my old get_user_pages() work had.
> 
> The idea is, that you'll provide a vector (like arguments to calloc) and two 
> offsets: One for the page to store within the offset and one for the vma 
> to store.
> 
> If the offset has a special value (e.g MAX_LONG) you don't store there at all.

You still need to find VMA in one loop, and run through it's(mm_structu) pages in
second loop.

> But if the performance problem really is get_user_pages() itself 
> (and not its callers), then my approach won't help at all.

It looks so.
My test pseudocode is following:
fget_light();
igrab();
kzalloc(number_of_pages * sizeof(void *));
get_user_pages(number_of_pages);
... undo ...

I've attached two graphs of performance with and without
get_user_pages(), it is get_user_pages.png and kmalloc.png.

Vertical axis is number of Mbytes per second thrown through above code,
horizontal one is number of pages in each run.
 
> Regards
> 
> Ingo Oeser

-- 
	Evgeniy Polyakov

--ew6BAiZeqk4r7MaW
Content-Type: image/png
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="get_user_pages.png"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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--ew6BAiZeqk4r7MaW
Content-Type: image/png
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="kmalloc.png"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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--ew6BAiZeqk4r7MaW--
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/