Received: by 2002:a05:6902:102b:0:0:0:0 with SMTP id x11csp1070255ybt; Sun, 14 Jun 2020 09:20:53 -0700 (PDT) X-Google-Smtp-Source: ABdhPJzBC1el6erXIm058Fixnv+Crzd6rvQaNxhNK63kPpO486xyZ5ZMqdVy2eBfGy49kt++6KNr X-Received: by 2002:a50:f9cc:: with SMTP id a12mr20773214edq.227.1592151652821; Sun, 14 Jun 2020 09:20:52 -0700 (PDT) ARC-Seal: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; t=1592151652; cv=none; d=google.com; s=arc-20160816; b=q7johAziw/XNI99tz0HMviSMmRU2jEftZY8Ozc2dNfBzeWqsmUDBZqZpM7kMJ9FW8y gZxHsP9XBwo3Y7WpbxU/F66BEHJjAWJNCgbfFmCHQfVYZPowslL5RrDQOXRf3fKMfKF9 hfr/JoVkDZolOa/e0O+l27HErrTgoum8Ff+0myu9EmcobTcVfCkFs1vG7EU82J76kgZr IHzP7C9UKTie08QE227N6gM/OlkxDxgDVbPenyG6PU5io0EX7eaLFPESrw29shDkZDy1 GGLGMqhuV8qkJxi7lWx5xkC7s12/YOpgdHkHpG2SkN3IvIwNOftx+6wA8nGLRRiNC8RU SCMQ== ARC-Message-Signature: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=google.com; s=arc-20160816; h=list-id:precedence:sender:content-language :content-transfer-encoding:in-reply-to:mime-version:user-agent:date :message-id:autocrypt:from:references:cc:to:subject; bh=WwbdogSGktlKV1N8KgRQwsfOhD666vqSXr02nybnWoc=; b=Kp7485l0XepgJ9PrTEJ1dPIrLsdCzgvQF4Os0E6/yA2iSBUiXPM5GdeEhRi7Io2j// PRj9jcqNPihh6woOcVcAWEH9n30wiAffO9RN1/Lo0OICrdZK2w5Do1LYNtdjQNFWkLAe uQJzD2QKimDpLMWDTo2LXVpK7QotS47TBWYtx9BAy/tindGZLUMpWJVWeG/ZjhkPCHVy 7k2skheRdD/bXM6SzMumEhIePytyla2oQRKMZss+XORqFxH4lpBhFxun7rfMRN42Mqbf +lwu3QB66zANwmyx7FFPOl3MHH7RvNF/i99txP/UZzADNCA5W8hmEri/VLpFM65Sg5TB 2S4g== ARC-Authentication-Results: i=1; mx.google.com; spf=pass (google.com: domain of linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org designates 23.128.96.18 as permitted sender) smtp.mailfrom=linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org Return-Path: Received: from vger.kernel.org (vger.kernel.org. [23.128.96.18]) by mx.google.com with ESMTP id 30si7633574edr.262.2020.06.14.09.20.29; Sun, 14 Jun 2020 09:20:52 -0700 (PDT) Received-SPF: pass (google.com: domain of linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org designates 23.128.96.18 as permitted sender) client-ip=23.128.96.18; Authentication-Results: mx.google.com; spf=pass (google.com: domain of linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org designates 23.128.96.18 as permitted sender) smtp.mailfrom=linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org Received: (majordomo@vger.kernel.org) by vger.kernel.org via listexpand id S1727036AbgFNQRV convert rfc822-to-8bit (ORCPT + 99 others); Sun, 14 Jun 2020 12:17:21 -0400 Received: from mout.kundenserver.de ([212.227.126.135]:34499 "EHLO mout.kundenserver.de" rhost-flags-OK-OK-OK-OK) by vger.kernel.org with ESMTP id S1726772AbgFNQRV (ORCPT ); Sun, 14 Jun 2020 12:17:21 -0400 Received: from [192.168.1.167] ([37.4.249.202]) by mrelayeu.kundenserver.de (mreue009 [212.227.15.167]) with ESMTPSA (Nemesis) id 1MGQaz-1jhW5s25Xx-00Go22; Sun, 14 Jun 2020 18:16:57 +0200 Subject: Re: [PATCH v3 070/105] drm/vc4: hdmi: rework connectors and encoders To: Maxime Ripard Cc: Eric Anholt , Tim Gover , Dave Stevenson , linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org, DRI Development , bcm-kernel-feedback-list@broadcom.com, Nicolas Saenz Julienne , Phil Elwell , linux-arm-kernel@lists.infradead.org, linux-rpi-kernel@lists.infradead.org References: <020de18840a1075b2671736c6cc2e451030fad74.1590594512.git-series.maxime@cerno.tech> <20200602155421.niyvpwqc42xh5c7v@gilmour> <6cd190e0-c81c-8e47-3ca8-22360de9b46d@i2se.com> <20200605143536.i6cc2v57eupmlvtn@gilmour.lan> <197a3164-828b-510e-47a7-f18ce1300d9d@i2se.com> <20200611133444.narsdlxmko2wgyj7@gilmour.lan> From: Stefan Wahren Autocrypt: addr=stefan.wahren@i2se.com; keydata= LS0tLS1CRUdJTiBQR1AgUFVCTElDIEtFWSBCTE9DSy0tLS0tClZlcnNpb246IEdudVBHIHYy CgptUUlOQkZ0NmdCTUJFQUN1Yi9wQmV2SHhidkplZnlaRzMySklObW4yYnNFUFgyNVY2ZmVq bXlZd21DR0tqRnRMCi9Eb1VNRVZIRHhDSjQ3Qk1YbzM0NGZIVjFDM0FudWRnTjFCZWhMb0J0 TEh4bW5lQ3pnSDNLY1B0V1c3cHRqNEcKdEp2OUNRRFp5MjdTS29FUHh5YUk4Q0YweWdSeEpj NzJNOUk5d21zUFo1YlVIc0x1WVdNcVE3SmNSbVBzNkQ4ZwpCa2srOC95bmdFeU5FeHd4SnBS MXlsajVianhXREh5WVF2dUo1THpaS3VPOUxCM2xYVnNjNGJxWEVqYzZWRnVaCkZDQ2svc3lp by9ZaHNlOE4rUXN4N01RYWd6NHdLVWtRUWJmWGcxVnFrVG5BaXZYczQyVm5Ja211NWd6SXcv MHQKUkp2NTBGUmhIaHhweUtBSThCOG5oTjhRdng3TVZrUGM1dkRmZDN1R1lXNDdKUGhWUUJj VXdKd05rLzQ5RjllQQp2ZzJtdE1QRm5GT1JrV1VSdlArRzZGSmZtNitDdk92N1lmUDF1ZXdB aTRsbitKTzFnK2dqVklXbC9XSnB5MG5UCmlwZGZlSDlkSGtnU2lmUXVuWWN1Y2lzTXlvUmJG OTU1dENna0VZOUVNRWRZMXQ4aUdEaUNnWDZzNTBMSGJpM2sKNDUzdWFjcHhmUVhTYUF3UGtz bDhNa0NPc3YyZUVyNElOQ0hZUUR5WmljbEJ1dUNnOEVOYlI2QUdWdFpTUGNRYgplbnpTektS Wm9POUNhcUlEK2ZhdkxpQi9kaHptSEErOWJnSWhtWGZ2WFJMRFp6ZThwbzFkeXQzRTFzaFhp ZGRaClBBOE51SlZ6RUl0MmxtSTZWOHBaRHBuMjIxcmZLaml2UlFpYW9zNTRUZ1pqak1ZSTdu bko3ZTZ4endBUkFRQUIKdENCVGRHVm1ZVzRnVjJGb2NtVnVJRHgzWVdoeVpXNXpkRUJuYlhn dWJtVjBQb2tDTndRVEFRZ0FJUVVDWElkYwo0Z0liQXdVTENRZ0hBZ1lWQ0FrS0N3SUVGZ0lE QVFJZUFRSVhnQUFLQ1JDVWdld1BFWkR5MjFPVEQvOUdpWkxkCnRSWWNteVJKZ2x0aVFRekFp UWRjSUQ3OGxHb1dwL3grci92Y1U2YjZqdVl1ZVR3Z1Iwclc3djdsMklSQnlEN24KSEp4YSt0 SVNvUVpCZ2hvbE1JZmI5TXRoR09KTENZNzdrL1FoQWhuMzJOR1prZWp3OXR6a3MvNDBtclpT VVQ4NApaeWJzUVhyTE0vSFI2VElJL0RlUEIwbktEM0ppcHBzMlVIUUQ5cUQySWpFd1NRUGxI akNPckVaaDQ1UFo3bTkrClo5M0x6aVRlc1dabFlRdUxpSndzNHJLcHRIVzFkL3dSZWxzaG1t NlFxY0wybDRDL2U0MGVEQjlncTRkU1poOVgKUEVZbGxpeU5RaDdhMkxTZHVtRTFyK2NTd0lq RS91ZHRSdmRPOWFLb0psT2JVSzVkTmpTUEg3d0tUYndkWGRZRApHUHdEaFhkNThOQXdyK1BY QmxQajB0STFMQ3ErTEJ4ZUt6aFdYK0dWcTlEb2pWanlVREV4Rk5Ga1h1b0M3ZzhtClY5VDB0 ZUJpdVpSbm91WEt3VjJGcHRaT0hIN0JVRVd0a0t0aGgxZXRmT1dwaWdCemtVN2JQc2ZJWVQr cnk5dGIKMW9KK3Y0MVBOYXFaRW1QVXBKeHZmek5UN3Ayd01lRDdaajlmMHJ1YlJQdExBSjJR R2pyRkhzdVh3QU9xcHl6ZQoxOEVidHNZazBOMHp1SEVoY2orUEJJQmZoMFlJWWQ1MW9mNkdJ aU95UjlxMFhYdHBsVUo3VDIvSDF1UXFrWGxwCitnVzRWa2lmc2NJckl1eWZueFpXMTJlSXZq NnlicVdMN2FZS0dZbVQ2aUxDUGJIWXlZY2F5bDRFa0ZjckNGN0UKZTBXVC9zY1ZNaE8vNVgv SGFOQTVIQngvcjUycGdMY3Y0aTlNeExRbVUzUmxabUZ1SUZkaGFISmxiaUE4YzNSbApabUZ1 TG5kaGFISmxia0JwTW5ObExtTnZiVDZKQWpnRUV3RUNBQ0lGQWx0NmdCTUNHd01HQ3drSUJ3 TUNCaFVJCkFna0tDd1FXQWdNQkFoNEJBaGVBQUFvSkVKU0I3QThSa1BMYmpic1AvamdqYVNz NUh0bGtBSXZXUytGcm15N2MKaG5jT0F4TFRWL0Q2UkV3SU95R0poRkt3d29pck55UTJnOXZV YTNZQ1lDZjFmSjh3RWhhS09COWQwTHBNUm5MNApkRVQ4ZDgyMzhFL3BLK0hxTktpSXNKaHM2 SnNLOFpnalZRR3JtbWZua0dyWisxdjBIQnV4ZGljZ0duUC9XdHVBClVsOGw2Mi9BTGJheXlq KzYxQ2xyc0V0UklhcU82N0xJWXdQaVBEUkkrWGlNek5pR3pIRi8xUTZHUjAyUkg2YTMKRjg5 ejhhUHhjSGkxWnZDdDJ5a3o2VUVjaHpQMHI1Z3FGSisvTC9VcHU4ME1YaVk0djVlSWFCNTJn VlBnaXlNQQpsTDJkRHMxbUladm5yUkxSWTJ0YjNtQVlOa1Y1QjVJRFQzcGtXeTZrS281T0Nn SytZZFlPUjhGTloyb04ydDhPCnJLK1ZudGFLN01NU0tIbG1ZL3NPd3RSbEVoMU9CbXJjQ3dH d21wLzA1R2tSNDZmL0lzaFJWZUZPUmF3K0dBcXQKUDIrQ0ZhMkNOQS9JSG5aTm95aWtsRHpQ UUhVVUdzck5wcERyaFg5Sm1oQm1nMXYyeXdIMU5YdTFpRGZQMUJBdwpLZ29rdDVmNVVhUkY5 c0FBNTN2V0V2YlVVTjllZXNGR0x6UFdkSkdRNWhwZC9WSDVJUXk5U0JyaC93SWNla3E1Cm4w a042cGJUSHhHRTUyU2kvTVZJa05UdURaM2FwbjJqbERaNHBPdHBCWEkydlAzYlBPK05pcUJa anNVM3R4TGkKV2R2MkZqeXp6NlhMUndlV1JZVkw1SGE2TER0eG9yMnZ1NlVQMDdwOXh6MXhS WmFPRFczb1lsSEZ6WXBhNFc1ZwpMSGIybEVrSXVVZlNjaWNHYmpqQXRDbFRkR1ZtWVc0Z1Yy Rm9jbVZ1SUR4emRHVm1ZVzR1ZDJGb2NtVnVRR2x1CkxYUmxZMmd1WTI5dFBva0NOd1FUQVFn QUlRVUNYSWRlaHdJYkF3VUxDUWdIQWdZVkNBa0tDd0lFRmdJREFRSWUKQVFJWGdBQUtDUkNV Z2V3UEVaRHkyeUhURC85VUY3UWxEa0d4elE3QWFDSTZOOTVpUWY4LzFvU1VhRE51Mlk2SQpL K0R6UXBiMVRiVE9yM1ZKd3dZOGEzT1d6NU5MU09MTVdlVnh0K29zTW1sUUlHdWJEM09EWko4 aXpQbEcvSnJOCnQ1elNkbU41SUE1ZjNlc1dXUVZLdmdoWkFnVERxZHB2K1pIVzJFbXhuQUox dUxGWFhlUWQzVVpjQzVyMy9nL3YKU2FNbzl4ZWszSjVtTnVEbTcxbEVXc0FzL0JBY0ZjK3lu TGh4d0JXQld3c3Z3UjhiSHRKNURPTVd2YUt1RHNrcApJR0ZVZS9LYjJCK2pyYXZRM1RuNnMv SHFKTTBjZXhTSHo1cGUrMHNHdlArdDlKNzIzNEJGUXdlRkV4cmlleThVCkl4T3I0WEFiYWFi U3J5WW5VL3pWSDlVMWkyQUlRWk1XSkFldkN2VmdRL1UrTmVSaFh1ZGU5WVVtRE1EbzJzQjIK VkFGRUFxaUYyUVVIUEEybThhN0VPM3lmTDRyTWswaUh6TElLdmg2L3JIOFFDWThpM1h4VE5M OWlDTHpCV3UvTgpPbkNBYlMremx2TFphaVNNaDVFZnV4VHR2NFBsVmRFamY2MlArWkhJRDE2 Z1VEd0VtYXpMQU1yeDY2NmpINWt1ClVDVFZ5bWJMMFR2Qis2TDZBUmw4QU55TTRBRG1rV2tw eU0yMmtDdUlTWUFFZlFSM3VXWFo5WWd4YVBNcWJWK3cKQnJoSmc0SGFONkM2eFRxR3YzcjRC MmFxYjc3L0NWb1JKMVo5Y3BIQ3dpT3pJYUFtdnl6UFU2TXhDRFhaOEZnWQpsVDR2MjNHNWlt SlAyemdYNXMrRjZBQ1VKOVVRUEQwdVRmK0o5RGEycitza2gvc1dPbloreWNvSE5CUXZvY1pF Ck5BSFFmN2tDRFFSYmVvQVRBUkFBMkhkMGZzRFZLNzJSTFNESGJ5ME9oZ0RjRGxWQk0yTSto WVlwTzNmWDFyKysKc2hpcVBLQ0hWQXNRNWJ4ZTdIbUppbUhhNEtLWXMya3YvbWx0L0NhdUNK Ly9wbWN5Y0JNN0d2d25Lem11WHp1QQpHbVZUWkM2V1I1TGtha0ZydEhPelZtc0VHcE52NVJj OWw2SFlGcExrYlNrVmk1U1BRWkp5K0VNZ01DRmdqclpmClZGNnlvdHdFMWFmN0hOdE1oTlBh TEROMW9VS0Y1aitSeVJnNWl3SnVDRGtuSGp3QlFWNHBndzIvNXZTOEE3WlEKdjJNYlcvVExF eXBLWGlmNzhJaGdBelh0RTJYck0xbi9vNlpINzFvUkZGS096NDJsRmR6ZHJTWDBZc3FYZ0hD WAo1Z0l0TGZxemoxcHNNYTlvMWVpTlRFbTFkVlFyVHFueXMwbDE4b2FsUk5zd1lsUW1uWUJ3 cHdDa2FUSExNSHdLCmZHQmJvNWRMUEVzaHRWb3dJNm5zZ3FMVHlRSG1xSFlxVVpZSXBpZ21t QzNTd0JXWTFWNmZmVUVta3FwQUFDRW4KTDQvZ1Vnbjd5US81ZDBzZXFuQXEycFNCSE1VVW9D Y1R6RVFVV1ZraUR2M1JrN2hURm1oVHNNcTc4eHYyWFJzWApNUjZ5UWhTVFBGWkNZRFVFeEVs RXNTbzlGV0hXcjZ6SHlZY2M4cURMRnZHOUZQaG1RdVQyczlCbHg2Z0kzMjNHCm5FcTFsd1dQ SlZ6UDRqUWtKS0lBWHdGcHYrVzhDV0xxekRXT3ZkbHJEYVRhVk1zY0ZUZUg1VzZVcHJsNjVq cUYKUUdNcGNSR0NzOEdDVVcxM0gwSXlPdFF0d1dYQTRueStTTDgxcHZpQW1hU1hVOGxhS2FS dTkxVk9WYUY5ZjRzQQpFUUVBQVlrQ0h3UVlBUUlBQ1FVQ1czcUFFd0liREFBS0NSQ1VnZXdQ RVpEeTIrb1hELzljSEhSa0JaT2ZrbVNxCjE0U3Z4MDYyUHRVMEtWNDcwVFNucC9qV29ZSm5L SXczRzBtWElSZ3J0SDJkUHdwSWdWanNZeVJTVk1LbVNwdDUKWnJEZjlOdFRiTldnazhWb0xl WnpZRW8rSjNvUHFGclRNczNhWVl2N2U0K0pLNjk1WW5tUSttT0Q5bmlhOTE1dApyNUFaajk1 VWZTVGx5VW15aWMxZDhvdnNmMWZQN1hDVVZSRmNSamZOZkRGMW9ML3BEZ01QNUdaMk93YVRl am15CkN1SGpNOElSMUNpYXZCcFlEbUJuVFlrN1B0aHk2YXRXdllsMGZ5L0NxYWpUS3N4Nytw OXh6aXU4WmZWWCtpS0IKQ2MrSGUrRURFZEdJRGh2TlovSVFIZk9CMlBVWFdHUytzOUZOVHhy L0E2bkxHWG5BOVk2dzkzaVBkWUl3eFM3SwpYTG9LSmVlMTBEamx6c1lzUmZsRk9XMFpPaVNp aElDWGlRVjF1cU02dHpGRzlndFJjaXVzNVVBdGhXYU8xT3dVClNDUW1mQ09tNGZ2TUlKSUE5 cnh0b1M2T3FSUWNpRjNjcm1vMHJKQ3ROMmF3WmZnaThYRWlmN2Q2aGp2MEVLTTkKWFpvaUFa WVpEKy9pTG01VGFLV042b0dJdGkwVmpKdjhaWk9aT2ZDYjZ2cUZJa0pXK2FPdTRvclRMRk16 MjhhbwpVM1F5V3BOQzhGRm1kWXNWdWE4czZnTjFOSWE2eTNxYS9aQjhiQS9pa3k1OUFFejRp RElScmdVek1FZzhBazdUCmZtMUtpWWVpVHRCRENvMjVCdlhqYnFzeXhrUUQxbmtSbTZGQVZ6 RXVPUEllOEp1cVcyeEQ5aXhHWXZqVTVoa1IKZ0pwM2dQNWIrY25HM0xQcXF1UTJFNmdvS1VN TEFia0NEUVJiZmw5REFSQUFzRExjYStMbFAydm5mdEVHaHBjQQpCR1ZOUUVGbkdQckNhdVU2 SGhOODA1V3RQVHRtc1JPdUp6cWdVVDBtcHFXSWZacTZzTXd5dkhLOVRzL0tIM0paClVWYlJD M3oyaDNLZmhIL0RhZjk1cGQ2bVBjL2g5dkYvT3kzK2VUV2hnR25QNmNBNWtsUitmTzFXaEc4 VnJpWHYKck5lUkcyMHN6emplSG9jblNJY1Q1WHVaUjB1REhPaUd4T2l6MXNNUkZUR3h6R095 MTlSOXJ2dTYzdGlJM2Q3dgpnYzc1T0NBZGtlQi9TZUNFbGFSdzBUZjdMWmJQampzRjI2M0JZ bk1mNGtrTkVLdnFXY1UyaWNNcCtxZXpqeW5CCnB2ZXVlMHJDVFFCWUFRbG9GQ1ZUR0hyV1dB NkQ0VzVPMkFmSWRJYzF1MUpDWnAyZjVMV1ZvVUZUVklyUW5RUVUKU0hDaWZyOU1aeExUdFBK ZFU1Mm9TUHczZGs0aExQOGlKSUx1dnYvYXZhakNzUVlIRXR3WXNiZUZaeGl1TGdscApBN1lj Sk5ObXBnQ3BNRDR3VWh2bEN0QUtOQlFXeXIyOTc2OThFUVRuNDZlQmVVNkttMkNpaFhrZ3dD eWY4ZXlLCkxFM3NYZXdhcTVrZ1pXdk5xNml1NXFZSVJCOXl3K2NYYzYwZE9aRE9scTkzWDVT QVJZemFvZXBrSHo0cmtMa1AKUG8rdENIeUhRUHNHblBYYzlXVDgwREM5Tm5KR2R2VWx5NXJk TUk0eHBaeWdlb2tqd293VlFsUFV1Y1M2TXluNwpmOHc4Y2dmQjdDMklBSWNEeDJwUC9IendY dmtDT1FOQTdtVjFsTTA4bitnVmtUcnpweGlwNURicTRDSW9ZeDJNCkpaVDhiR1JINlhqY1VE S2EwOVFoeVpzQUVRRUFBWWtFUkFRWUFRZ0FEd1VDVzM1ZlF3SWJBZ1VKQThKbkFBSXAKQ1JD VWdld1BFWkR5MjhGZElBUVpBUWdBQmdVQ1czNWZRd0FLQ1JCVnhETFBjVk1NamNkc0QvMFJo QXN1UVlPeQpyMTNCbDNOaFhrWUFaR3AyWkZER3VrZTdPU2tWOG9qT09UZFR5ei9jT1JHQ2J5 ZEQrRGd2cUZ5VmRuT1hLZ08wCmxKbUd3ckdlTGRnZ0F2aDBpaHJwNU8wWVVKOWJCU1htR01t UVRZSC9BbUxUR2FkYnVqQ1dqNWZGVWtDeXd4aW0KSHV5MFBiMjRwelR2UzUwR1k1WStxSDBG SE5haWdka2tpV04zcnVnN0haRXUvQ3lsUFpqT1h6K0QxUVBNckV4dwo3ZC9NS2FiVis5YU5i UVlabGRJajk4UXd2VUYxS1N6YThqbFVJdnBoUnEyN0FUOGZER1lHUGZERU1nMmNCT2FlCkty N29uUXM0YjdhV082aWZEbHhRVHB6c3pvK0FuODA3Tk1TdFZFRmYrczNBaFZEM2U3bmY4SkJh dmJWckFlMGsKb20yNm96elBubnh6K2xxVlZ0dzZVazRYTUl6dGl4L0h3SFl3dUNuY1VYWndL MEkzeUFKd2pZd29vck9DaEozUwpFVWJKUVB0R3NneFJERXhWQkZlNk5MUC82MnhQOU82dGFj d09kYjBNbVAxYjM5cFJBVEM3YmdkMWxkVUxpNzVaCmxKckowL1NpVkVyb3FOWXk3OXRmbWdB WjJVeFptczlTckV5Nm85UVNmc24xYVh2K01QTDlKYUNHbWtQNnpiTFEKTm5kajBKY2FRbmtD MHZneWRPMUJtNk11OTZQOXVmbEtaY0FTNndtTE01SWRIT3lqTDg4d0h3anVjakFPQnRjdwpw MG9HVG5WT25Sc05ZU084VzhZWi9LZGJ1Nzg1ZGF6TXFKMmlOakFEdUJiZG02TjRqNUVkTW5r TG4wQklmUEpwCmRnbTR2bDJVcExqd1JHci9NM3dtbTVwdnMrNnVCN2hrL0ZKaUQvNGxsRU5Q NGVNMWg3U200aitWcTZOMSt6VEIKSVhKQWViSXFhc0RwNXlaUzdYcnk0STM2bjg1WEVZZkcw MWx0QXlob05WMkRPOFNJUlFwdWkydHErOVJQM1JLMQpKREJ4eEVKWTJFTzVKWjhNeGFQSFEw RFQwNWxSRmpLMkFsaGRFSXRqTGpwSjNmVW05c3FMeE1XeHpQNlV6M2lpCjJ1YTR1bnJ0Nk9D VHFRd2lqRi8zYlRXaXd2VkFBSG5NRlVpb1hzaEhhb2hWRGNWZm5lSU1mVjBiUUNYWWkzTnAK WTB2MFp3Y2lGSCtnU0M3cUQ2WE51aHBWR1NMNElpbGlGeS9TemNhSkV6QUhlTERTaFpQMkNX ZG5DNHZnbDM3dApocHg4aDU1WWhKbjZIU3VVelBnaGFLdFZCMmsrajdaZXlaK1NGeHA3SXVi SEN3TEhsUWhUNzVSd1EzaUF4S242CjBxajUxY1lUbnF4ZFpYVzZmSDNQa3VNellVNUdwcVIv MU9sNWMvd2ZJNmc2QW04eUtXLzBFVUx0K0tuNExGc1MKbTdZM201SDV2MTJVNkpCWXZWK3Ix M2paaW9zNEVFREU5M0Q1c05IMk1JeVJ6Q0RxMXpkZHQ0WHV5S0ZqUEtXMQo5aWJaRGZGVjdL dUNzdnVMMjNzQmMxc0NNb3ArRTFtVC9ReE9JQTZvRFQxTVFzdHdPVnVReURDdi9PdktTZ2Z6 CjhGWEdMNkFQY2xqQ3FqOEFKaHhReXN4ZG9pUVA4bS92dStialdHR3Z4dzVzMWxncGlSRFRS VVBnY0pKTmFHWTIKVklEclpRaTROU2lOUTBOSWkrZGp1NGZOTW1DcFFxZzh0YkMzY0FhNnl3 bTZvUUIxU0JobURYMmUxMWdSbGx1SQpPblRHUEUwSFRvM2w3MmxoYmc9PQo9cVpNVgotLS0t LUVORCBQR1AgUFVCTElDIEtFWSBCTE9DSy0tLS0tCg== Message-ID: <8ad354c1-203c-e4bc-ef24-36a2a7b4a9b5@i2se.com> Date: Sun, 14 Jun 2020 18:16:56 +0200 User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:68.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/68.8.0 MIME-Version: 1.0 In-Reply-To: <20200611133444.narsdlxmko2wgyj7@gilmour.lan> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=windows-1252 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8BIT Content-Language: en-US X-Provags-ID: V03:K1:rtiwTQMsPS/se7X3GdDOEtCTTPYt8I5nhhBNzq8Abh3xxBsWkGR QkmSxiuUEXRKMs6blKRIuHNUbT92zx+IbJlFsLWTC+9opGRtAXUaBAD5F9SFFxgGF+NB1WQ an98wkcqJWB8SDAxmTmBuJXoNzwLNd3zHlEV6QvKsuImLtUhPjoOt34VDHuvAwg0yRlvrhm I9oTpa5rAdT/RHEYnurmA== X-Spam-Flag: NO X-UI-Out-Filterresults: notjunk:1;V03:K0:kstBPpUqEoI=:8dDXHgO2amzzph2M6wQEs0 wWdR5/Uvf73nG44HsxMmszPF0PnLEd/all13ktskwJl61mj6dW3z0TTgXqgLMyU+TPX+ah9dt udCWUy3q+o7OmNlaOci1LY0UQktSnPeaWK5BQ7HBqCYOnC9in/cEYVviWlJI6vz+g6kPE3jGw IJ/J5ypxG1T8rWPi+LrHOkFf+WRfeP4fmsOhpu49x3NqBj7dRsLxokJAtbKd0+BPTsbqjMzpd t6cAeZGASRHLqETdceTKGy76HB38iRQWPqtwoRdQIhOwremd+DSeLGTvmQmKCmPZiQLpIxjKB g7Onb15GXqR5EFyI1Mr6+obt8/pymWyvDn1wDvRDuIIxrV1ZvVTDM+pzjEwHPfpZh5oOAZn17 /Phv8SG2liT+H1VmB00N+IlZB/fwllBtqHapDE+rtuxMFEGnXmjjnhl5bPgVp/dlqGh04nLhE 5hOuI/iIJwT5m7/79qkc7bTsxVZn0Nz9uIRcDxjfssFKQdK9S9eVYDG/I6M+r9MYptaF1d93f M+OuvdJJBzizn3k0rcSqMevr/Rzdm5nQp/k7BKUTBcV1hd2s4t8+0yUC0FdBCm1cwgUncWFK/ 8L+q8CtHyyQzDftb15hftMnqSaK+r5TiSOE6P4w75oJK1RDT2SV3xEIlGHx3wGc0IfBeIkAzM cfgN9phFwfd76QISprmK5/yNn5onx2pjVYs4JmJwepsCJxrjFDrJJQuA9GTx9gbD2lPY1N8qJ PP3b0IQGiqXzeEJW0BIIQzJf5tHqvflDK6Nr64MJj5ac4yln0erhEuo7rFQo6KOj9bugmedAB uyhbJyd17FEcHXnMF3tLC0b/DRHSJIw6TUKhYapLByWEYjstQjFVZDEnpRRxteFDVL1k6uv Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org Precedence: bulk List-ID: X-Mailing-List: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org Hi Maxime, Am 11.06.20 um 15:34 schrieb Maxime Ripard: > Hi Stefan, > > On Sat, Jun 06, 2020 at 10:06:12AM +0200, Stefan Wahren wrote: >> Hi Maxime, >> >> Am 05.06.20 um 16:35 schrieb Maxime Ripard: >>> Hi Stefan, >>> >>> On Wed, Jun 03, 2020 at 07:32:30PM +0200, Stefan Wahren wrote: >>>> Am 02.06.20 um 17:54 schrieb Maxime Ripard: >>>> FWIW this is the first patch which breaks X on my Raspberry Pi 3 B. >>>> >>>> Here are the bisect results: >>>> >>>> 587d6e4a529a8d807a5c0bae583dd432d77064d6 bad (black screen, no heartbeat) >>>> >>>> b0523c7b1c9d0edcd6c0fe6d2cb558a9ad5c60a8 good >>>> >>>> 2c6a651cac6359cb0244a40d3b7a14e72918f169 good >>>> >>>> 1705c3cb40906863ec0d24ee5ea5092f5ee2e994 bad (black screen, but heartbeat) >>>> >>>> 601527fea6bb226abd088a864e74b25368218e87 good >>>> >>>> 2165607ede34d229d0cbce916c70c7fb6c0337be good >>>> >>>> f094f388fc2df848227e2ae648df2c97872df42b good >>>> >>>> 020de18840a1075b2671736c6cc2e451030fad74 bad (black screen, but heartbeat) >>>> >>>> 4c4da3823e4d1a8189e96a59a79451fff372f70b good >>>> >>>> 020de18840a1075b2671736c6cc2e451030fad74 is the first bad commit >>>> commit 020de18840a1075b2671736c6cc2e451030fad74 >>>> Author: Maxime Ripard >>>> Date:?? Mon Jan 6 17:17:29 2020 +0100 >>>> >>>> ??? drm/vc4: hdmi: rework connectors and encoders >>>> ??? >>>> ??? the vc4_hdmi driver has some custom structures to hold the data it >>>> needs to >>>> ??? associate with the drm_encoder and drm_connector structures. >>>> ??? >>>> ??? However, it allocates them separately from the vc4_hdmi structure which >>>> ??? makes it more complicated than it needs to be. >>>> ??? >>>> ??? Move those structures to be contained by vc4_hdmi and update the code >>>> ??? accordingly. >>>> ??? >>>> ??? Signed-off-by: Maxime Ripard >>> So it looks like there was two issues on the Pi3. The first one was >>> causing the timeouts (and therefore likely the black screen but >>> heartbeat case you had) and I've fixed it. >>> >>> However, I can indeed reproduce the case with the black screen / no >>> heartbeat you mentionned. My bisection however returns that it's the >>> patch "drm/vc4: hdmi: Implement finer-grained hooks" that is at fault. >>> I've pushed my updated branch, if you have some spare time, it would be >>> great if you could confirm it on your Pi. >> yesterday i checked out your latest rpi4-kms branch, but i was still >> facing similiar issues with my Raspberry Pi 3 and multi_v7_defconfig >> (heartbeat stops, splashscreen freeze, heartbeat is abnormal fast). So i >> tried to bisect but the offending commit didn't cause an issue the >> second time. >> >> By accident i noticed that a simple reboot seems to hang for at least 8 >> minutes (using b0523c7b1c9d0edcd the base of your branch). This usually >> take a few seconds. So i consider this base on linux-next as too >> unstable for reliable testing. >> >> Is it possible to rebase this on something more stable like linux-5.7 or >> at least drm-misc-next? This should avoid chasing unrelated issues. > I've rebased it on 5.7 here: > https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/mripard/linux.git/log/?h=rpi4-kms-5.7 > > And it looks to be indeed an issue coming from next. That branch can > start the desktop just fine on an RPi3 here. It would be great if you > could confirm on your end. > > Thanks! > Maxime thank you very much. The good news are that the "black screen, but heartbeat" issue and reboot hang are gone. Unfortunately the "no heartbeat" issue is still there. Here are more details about the issue. It doesn't occur everytime. I would guess the probability is about 40 percent, which made bisecting much harder. It is reproducible on my 2 Raspberry Pi 3 B Rev 1.2. It is also seems independent from the display because the problem occured on my Computer display and my TV. Yes, i can confirm that i was able to bisect the issue to this commit: commit 7b7e335f98c6f3199dcc7db83469dccac66dca1e Author: Maxime Ripard Date:?? Tue May 12 11:36:13 2020 +0200 ??? drm/vc4: hdmi: Implement finer-grained hooks ??? ??? In order to prevent some pixels getting stuck in an unflushable FIFO on ??? bcm2711, we need to enable the HVS, the pixelvalve (the CRTC) and the HDMI ??? controller (the encoder) in an intertwined way, and with tight delays. ??? ??? However, the atomic callbacks don't really provide a way to work with ??? either constraints, so we need to roll our own callbacks so that we can ??? provide those guarantees. ??? ??? Since those callbacks have been implemented and called in the CRTC code, we ??? can just implement them in the HDMI driver now. ??? ??? Signed-off-by: Maxime Ripard