Received-SPF: pass (google.com: domain of linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org designates 23.128.96.18 as permitted sender) client-ip=23.128.96.18;
Subject: Re: [PATCH v22 12/23] LSM: Specify which LSM to display
To:     Greg KH <gregkh@linuxfoundation.org>,
        Casey Schaufler <casey@schaufler-ca.com>
Cc:     casey.schaufler@intel.com, jmorris@namei.org,
        linux-security-module@vger.kernel.org, selinux@vger.kernel.org,
        linux-audit@redhat.com, keescook@chromium.org,
        penguin-kernel@i-love.sakura.ne.jp, paul@paul-moore.com,
        sds@tycho.nsa.gov, linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org,
        linux-api@vger.kernel.org
References: <20201104234114.11346-1-casey@schaufler-ca.com>
 <20201104234114.11346-13-casey@schaufler-ca.com>
 <20201105092245.GB3439341@kroah.com>
 <31027d8e-50bc-70be-b4f2-a96a84de2bae@schaufler-ca.com>
 <20201107091529.GA23328@kroah.com>
From:   John Johansen <john.johansen@canonical.com>
Autocrypt: addr=john.johansen@canonical.com; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata=
 LS0tLS1CRUdJTiBQR1AgUFVCTElDIEtFWSBCTE9DSy0tLS0tCgptUUlOQkU1bXJQb0JFQURB
 azE5UHNnVmdCS2tJbW1SMmlzUFE2bzdLSmhUVEtqSmR3VmJrV1NuTm4rbzZVcDVrCm5LUDFm
 NDlFQlFsY2VXZzF5cC9Od2JSOGFkK2VTRU8vdW1hL0srUHFXdkJwdEtDOVNXRDk3Rkc0dUI0
 L2Nhb20KTEVVOTdzTFFNdG52R1dkeHJ4VlJHTTRhbnpXWU1neno1VFptSWlWVFo0M091NVZw
 YVMxVnoxWlN4UDNoL3hLTgpaci9UY1c1V1FhaTh1M1BXVm5ia2poU1pQSHYxQmdoTjY5cXhF
 UG9tckpCbTFnbXR4M1ppVm1GWGx1d1RtVGdKCk9rcEZvbDduYkowaWxuWUhyQTdTWDNDdFIx
 dXBlVXBNYS9XSWFuVk85NldkVGpISElhNDNmYmhtUXViZTR0eFMKM0ZjUUxPSlZxUXN4NmxF
 OUI3cUFwcG05aFExMHFQV3dkZlB5LyswVzZBV3ROdTVBU2lHVkNJbld6bDJIQnFZZAovWmxs
 OTN6VXErTklvQ244c0RBTTlpSCt3dGFHRGNKeXdJR0luK2VkS050SzcyQU1nQ2hUZy9qMVpv
 V0g2WmVXClBqdVVmdWJWelp0bzFGTW9HSi9TRjRNbWRRRzFpUU50ZjRzRlpiRWdYdXk5Y0dp
 MmJvbUYwenZ5QkpTQU5weGwKS05CRFlLek42S3owOUhVQWtqbEZNTmdvbUwvY2pxZ0FCdEF4
 NTlMK2RWSVpmYUYyODFwSWNVWnp3dmg1K0pvRwplT1c1dUJTTWJFN0wzOG5zem9veWtJSjVY
 ckFjaGtKeE5mejdrK0ZuUWVLRWtOekVkMkxXYzNRRjRCUVpZUlQ2ClBISGdhM1JneWtXNSsx
 d1RNcUpJTGRtdGFQYlhyRjNGdm5WMExSUGN2NHhLeDdCM2ZHbTd5Z2Rvb3dBUkFRQUIKdEIx
 S2IyaHVJRXB2YUdGdWMyVnVJRHhxYjJodVFHcHFiWGd1Ym1WMFBva0NPZ1FUQVFvQUpBSWJB
 d1VMQ1FnSApBd1VWQ2drSUN3VVdBZ01CQUFJZUFRSVhnQVVDVG8wWVZ3SVpBUUFLQ1JBRkx6
 WndHTlhEMkx4SkQvOVRKWkNwCndsbmNUZ1llcmFFTWVEZmtXdjhjMUlzTTFqMEFtRTRWdEwr
 ZkU3ODBaVlA5Z2tqZ2tkWVN4dDdlY0VUUFRLTWEKWlNpc3JsMVJ3cVUwb29nWGRYUVNweHJH
 SDAxaWN1LzJuMGpjWVNxWUtnZ1B4eTc4QkdzMkxacTRYUGZKVFptSApaR25YR3EvZURyL21T
 bmowYWF2QkptTVo2amJpUHo2eUh0QllQWjlmZG84YnRjendQNDFZZVdvSXUyNi84SUk2CmYw
 WG0zVkM1b0FhOHY3UmQrUldaYThUTXdsaHpIRXh4ZWwzanRJN0l6ek9zbm1FOS84RG0wQVJE
 NWlUTENYd1IKMWN3SS9KOUJGL1MxWHY4UE4xaHVUM0l0Q05kYXRncDh6cW9Ka2dQVmptdnlM
 NjRRM2ZFa1liZkhPV3NhYmE5LwprQVZ0Qk56OVJURmg3SUhEZkVDVmFUb3VqQmQ3QnRQcXIr
 cUlqV0ZhZEpEM0k1ZUxDVkp2VnJyb2xyQ0FUbEZ0Ck4zWWtRczZKbjFBaUlWSVUzYkhSOEdq
 ZXZnejVMbDZTQ0dIZ1Jya3lScG5TWWFVL3VMZ24zN042QVl4aS9RQUwKK2J5M0N5RUZManpX
 QUV2eVE4YnEzSXVjbjdKRWJoUy9KLy9kVXFMb2VVZjh0c0dpMDB6bXJJVFpZZUZZQVJoUQpN
 dHNmaXpJclZEdHoxaVBmL1pNcDVnUkJuaXlqcFhuMTMxY20zTTNndjZIclFzQUdubjhBSnJ1
 OEdEaTVYSllJCmNvLzEreC9xRWlOMm5DbGFBT3BiaHpOMmVVdlBEWTVXMHEzYkEvWnAybWZH
 NTJ2YlJJK3RRMEJyMUhkL3ZzbnQKVUhPOTAzbU1aZXAyTnpOM0JaNXFFdlB2RzRyVzVacTJE
 cHliV2JRclNtOW9iaUJLYjJoaGJuTmxiaUE4YW05bwpiaTVxYjJoaGJuTmxia0JqWVc1dmJt
 bGpZV3d1WTI5dFBva0NOd1FUQVFvQUlRVUNUbzBYV2dJYkF3VUxDUWdICkF3VVZDZ2tJQ3dV
 V0FnTUJBQUllQVFJWGdBQUtDUkFGTHpad0dOWEQySXRNRC85anliYzg3ZE00dUFIazZ5Tk0K
 TjBZL0JGbW10VFdWc09CaHFPbm9iNGkzOEJyRE8yQzFoUUNQQ1FlNExMczEvNHB0ZW92UXQ4
 QjJGeXJQVmp3Zwo3alpUSE5LNzRyNmxDQ1Z4eDN5dTFCN1U5UG80VlRrY3NsVmIxL3FtV3V4
 OFhXY040eXZrVHFsTCtHeHB5Sm45CjlaWmZmWEpjNk9oNlRtT2ZiS0d2TXV1djVhclNJQTNK
 SEZMZjlhTHZadEExaXNKVXI3cFM5YXBnOXVUVUdVcDcKd2ZWMFdUNlQzZUczbXRVVTJ1cDVK
 VjQ4NTBMMDVqSFM2dVdpZS9ZK3lmSk9iaXlyeE4vNlpxVzVHb25oTEJxLwptc3pjVjV2QlQz
 QkRWZTNSdkY2WGRNOU9oUG4xK1k4MXg1NCt2UTExM044aUx3RjdHR2ExNFp5SVZBTlpEMEkw
 CkhqUnZhMmsvUnFJUlR6S3l1UEg1cGtsY0tIVlBFRk1tT3pNVCtGT294Tmp2Uys3K3dHMktN
 RFlFbUhQcjFQSkIKWlNaZUh6SzE5dGZhbFBNcHBGeGkrc3lZTGFnTjBtQjdKSFF3WTdjclV1
 T0RoeWNxNjBZVnoxdGFFeWd1M1l2MgoyL0kxRUNHSHZLSEc2d2M5MG80M0MvZWxIRUNYbkVo
 N3RLcGxEY3BJQytPQ21NeEtIaFI0NitYY1p2Z3c0RGdiCjdjYTgzZVFSM0NHODlMdlFwVzJM
 TEtFRUJEajdoWmhrTGJra1BSWm0zdzhKWTQ0YXc4VnRneFdkblNFTUNMeEwKSU9OaDZ1Wjcv
 L0RZVnRjSWFNSllrZWJhWnRHZENwMElnVVpiMjQvVmR2WkNZYk82MkhrLzNWbzFuWHdIVUVz
 Mwo2RC92MWJUMFJaRmk2OUxnc0NjT2N4NGdZTGtDRFFST1pxejZBUkFBb3F3NmtrQmhXeU0x
 ZnZnYW1BVmplWjZuCktFZm5SV2JrQzk0TDFFc0pMdXAzV2IyWDBBQk5PSFNrYlNENHBBdUMy
 dEtGL0VHQnQ1Q1A3UWRWS1JHY1F6QWQKNmIyYzFJZHk5Ukx3Nnc0Z2krbm4vZDFQbTFra1lo
 a1NpNXpXYUlnMG01UlFVaytFbDh6a2Y1dGNFLzFOMFo1TwpLMkpoandGdTViWDBhMGw0Y0ZH
 V1ZRRWNpVk1ES1J0eE1qRXRrM1N4RmFsbTZaZFEycHAyODIyY2xucTR6WjltCld1MWQyd2F4
 aXorYjVJYTR3ZURZYTduNDFVUmNCRVViSkFnbmljSmtKdENUd3lJeElXMktuVnlPcmp2a1F6
 SUIKdmFQMEZkUDJ2dlpvUE1kbENJek9sSWtQTGd4RTBJV3VlVFhlQkpoTnMwMXBiOGJMcW1U
 SU1sdTRMdkJFTEEvdgplaWFqajVzOHk1NDJIL2FIc2ZCZjRNUVVoSHhPL0JaVjdoMDZLU1Vm
 SWFZN09nQWdLdUdOQjNVaWFJVVM1K2E5CmduRU9RTER4S1J5L2E3UTF2OVMrTnZ4KzdqOGlI
 M2prUUpoeFQ2WkJoWkdSeDBna0gzVCtGMG5ORG01TmFKVXMKYXN3Z0pycUZaa1VHZDJNcm0x
 cW5Ld1hpQXQ4U0ljRU5kcTMzUjBLS0tSQzgwWGd3ajhKbjMwdlhMU0crTk8xRwpIMFVNY0F4
 TXd5L3B2azZMVTVKR2paUjczSjVVTFZoSDRNTGJEZ2dEM21QYWlHOCtmb3RUckpVUHFxaGc5
 aHlVCkVQcFlHN3NxdDc0WG43OStDRVpjakxIenlsNnZBRkUyVzBreGxMdFF0VVpVSE8zNmFm
 RnY4cUdwTzNacVB2akIKVXVhdFhGNnR2VVFDd2YzSDZYTUFFUUVBQVlrQ0h3UVlBUW9BQ1FV
 Q1RtYXMrZ0liREFBS0NSQUZMelp3R05YRAoyRC9YRC8wZGRNLzRhaTFiK1RsMWp6bkthalgz
 a0crTWVFWWVJNGY0MHZjbzNyT0xyblJHRk9jYnl5ZlZGNjlNCktlcGllNE93b0kxamNUVTBB
 RGVjbmJXbkROSHByMFNjenhCTXJvM2Juckxoc212anVuVFlJdnNzQlp0QjRhVkoKanVMSUxQ
 VWxuaEZxYTdmYlZxMFpRamJpVi9ydDJqQkVOZG05cGJKWjZHam5wWUljQWJQQ0NhL2ZmTDQv
 U1FSUwpZSFhvaEdpaVM0eTVqQlRtSzVsdGZld0xPdzAyZmtleEgrSUpGcnJHQlhEU2c2bjJT
 Z3hubisrTkYzNGZYY205CnBpYXczbUtzSUNtKzBoZE5oNGFmR1o2SVdWOFBHMnRlb29WRHA0
 ZFlpaCsreFgvWFM4ekJDYzFPOXc0bnpsUDIKZ0t6bHFTV2JoaVdwaWZSSkJGYTRXdEFlSlRk
 WFlkMzdqL0JJNFJXV2hueXc3YUFQTkdqMzN5dEdITlVmNlJvMgovanRqNHRGMXkvUUZYcWpK
 Ry93R2pwZHRSZmJ0VWpxTEhJc3ZmUE5OSnEvOTU4cDc0bmRBQ2lkbFdTSHpqK09wCjI2S3Bi
 Rm5td05PMHBzaVVzbmh2SEZ3UE8vdkFibDNSc1I1KzBSbytodnMyY0VtUXV2OXIvYkRsQ2Zw
 enAydDMKY0srcmh4VXFpc094OERaZnoxQm5rYW9DUkZidnZ2ays3TC9mb21QbnRHUGtxSmNp
 WUU4VEdIa1p3MWhPa3UrNApPb00yR0I1bkVEbGorMlRGL2pMUStFaXBYOVBrUEpZdnhmUmxD
 NmRLOFBLS2ZYOUtkZm1BSWNnSGZuVjFqU24rCjh5SDJkakJQdEtpcVcwSjY5YUlzeXg3aVYv
 MDNwYVBDakpoN1hxOXZBenlkTjVVL1VBPT0KPTZQL2IKLS0tLS1FTkQgUEdQIFBVQkxJQyBL
 RVkgQkxPQ0stLS0tLQo=
Organization: Canonical
Message-ID: <04b4adf9-9313-7f5a-e7fe-6132e0c5fc4f@canonical.com>
Date:   Sat, 7 Nov 2020 14:05:20 -0800
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:68.0) Gecko/20100101
 Thunderbird/68.10.0
MIME-Version: 1.0
In-Reply-To: <20201107091529.GA23328@kroah.com>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8
Content-Language: en-US
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Precedence: bulk

On 11/7/20 1:15 AM, Greg KH wrote:
> On Fri, Nov 06, 2020 at 04:20:43PM -0800, Casey Schaufler wrote:
>> On 11/5/2020 1:22 AM, Greg KH wrote:
>>> On Wed, Nov 04, 2020 at 03:41:03PM -0800, Casey Schaufler wrote:
>>>> Create a new entry "display" in the procfs attr directory for
>>>> controlling which LSM security information is displayed for a
>>>> process. A process can only read or write its own display value.
>>>>
>>>> The name of an active LSM that supplies hooks for
>>>> human readable data may be written to "display" to set the
>>>> value. The name of the LSM currently in use can be read from
>>>> "display". At this point there can only be one LSM capable
>>>> of display active. A helper function lsm_task_display() is
>>>> provided to get the display slot for a task_struct.
>>>>
>>>> Setting the "display" requires that all security modules using
>>>> setprocattr hooks allow the action. Each security module is
>>>> responsible for defining its policy.
>>>>
>>>> AppArmor hook provided by John Johansen <john.johansen@canonical.com>
>>>> SELinux hook provided by Stephen Smalley <sds@tycho.nsa.gov>
>>>>
>>>> Reviewed-by: Kees Cook <keescook@chromium.org>
>>>> Acked-by: Stephen Smalley <sds@tycho.nsa.gov>
>>>> Acked-by: Paul Moore <paul@paul-moore.com>
>>>> Signed-off-by: Casey Schaufler <casey@schaufler-ca.com>
>>>> Cc: linux-api@vger.kernel.org
>>>> ---
>>>>  fs/proc/base.c                       |   1 +
>>>>  include/linux/lsm_hooks.h            |  17 +++
>>>>  security/apparmor/include/apparmor.h |   3 +-
>>>>  security/apparmor/lsm.c              |  32 +++++
>>>>  security/security.c                  | 169 ++++++++++++++++++++++++---
>>>>  security/selinux/hooks.c             |  11 ++
>>>>  security/selinux/include/classmap.h  |   2 +-
>>>>  security/smack/smack_lsm.c           |   7 ++
>>>>  8 files changed, 223 insertions(+), 19 deletions(-)
>>>>
>>>> diff --git a/fs/proc/base.c b/fs/proc/base.c
>>>> index 0f707003dda5..7432f24f0132 100644
>>>> --- a/fs/proc/base.c
>>>> +++ b/fs/proc/base.c
>>>> @@ -2806,6 +2806,7 @@ static const struct pid_entry attr_dir_stuff[] = {
>>>>  	ATTR(NULL, "fscreate",		0666),
>>>>  	ATTR(NULL, "keycreate",		0666),
>>>>  	ATTR(NULL, "sockcreate",	0666),
>>>> +	ATTR(NULL, "display",		0666),
>>> That's a vague name, any chance it can be more descriptive?
>>
>> Sure. How about lsm_display, or display_lsm? I wouldn't say that
>> any of the files in /proc/*/attr have especially descriptive names,
>> but that's hardly an excuse.
> 
> I still don't understand what "display" means in this context.  Perhaps

its the LSM thats context is being displayed on the shared interface,
ie. /proc/*/attr/*

thinking about it more owner or even interface_owner might be a better
name


> documentation will help clear it up?
> 

yeah this needs documented.

> thanks,
> 
> greg k-h
>