Received-SPF: pass (google.com: domain of linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org designates 23.128.96.18 as permitted sender) client-ip=23.128.96.18;
Subject: Re: [PATCH v3 0/5] Refactor thermal pressure update to avoid code
 duplication
To:     Steev Klimaszewski <steev@kali.org>,
        Lukasz Luba <lukasz.luba@arm.com>
Cc:     linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org, linux-pm@vger.kernel.org,
        linux-arm-kernel@lists.infradead.org,
        linux-arm-msm@vger.kernel.org, sudeep.holla@arm.com,
        will@kernel.org, catalin.marinas@arm.com, linux@armlinux.org.uk,
        gregkh@linuxfoundation.org, rafael@kernel.org,
        viresh.kumar@linaro.org, amitk@kernel.org,
        daniel.lezcano@linaro.org, amit.kachhap@gmail.com,
        bjorn.andersson@linaro.org, agross@kernel.org
References: <20211103161020.26714-1-lukasz.luba@arm.com>
 <c7b526f0-2c26-0cfc-910b-3521c6a6ef51@kali.org>
 <3cba148a-7077-7b6b-f131-dc65045aa348@arm.com>
 <9d533b6e-a81c-e823-fa6f-61fdea92fa65@kali.org>
 <74ea027b-b213-42b8-0f7d-275f3b84712e@linaro.org>
 <74603569-2ff1-999e-9618-79261fdb0ee4@kali.org>
From:   Thara Gopinath <thara.gopinath@linaro.org>
Message-ID: <b7e76c2a-ceac-500a-ff75-535a3f0d51d6@linaro.org>
Date:   Fri, 5 Nov 2021 17:06:26 -0400
User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:78.0) Gecko/20100101
 Thunderbird/78.11.0
MIME-Version: 1.0
In-Reply-To: <74603569-2ff1-999e-9618-79261fdb0ee4@kali.org>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8; format=flowed
Content-Language: en-US
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
Precedence: bulk


On 11/5/21 3:51 PM, Steev Klimaszewski wrote:
> 
> On 11/5/21 2:18 PM, Thara Gopinath wrote:
>>
>>
>> On 11/5/21 1:33 PM, Steev Klimaszewski wrote:
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> On 11/5/21 11:26 AM, Lukasz Luba wrote:
>>>> Hi Steev,
>>>>
>>>> On 11/5/21 3:39 PM, Steev Klimaszewski wrote:
>>>>> Hi Lukasz,
>>>>>
>>>> [snip]
>> Hi Steve,
>>
>> Does your system have enough load to hit the boost frequencies ? I 
>> don't think this patch should affect hitting boost frequencies as 
>> there is no error being returned from topology_update_thermal_pressure.
>>
>> The warning you are getting is because you have boost frequency 
>> enabled and IIUC lmh enabled and thermal pressure framework bails out 
>> due to boost_frequency being greater than what is available in per_cpu 
>> freq_factor. This is because we do not recalculate freq_factor every 
>> time boost is enabled / disabled. IIRC there were some discussions 
>> around rebuilding scheduler domains and capacity with user space 
>> changes to max frequency but it has never proceeded much. Till that 
>> point, I think the right way, is to check whether the new capcity 
>> exceeds the max_capacity of the cpu and if yes use max_capacity in 
>> lieu of new_capacity to calculate thermal pressure.
>>
> Hi Thara,
> 
> I should definitely be able to push it to 2.96GHz, however I'm simply 
> not getting it at all with these patches applied. >
> So, I'm currently compiling multiple applications - alacritty 
> (https://github.com/alacritty/alacritty), and zellij 
> (https://github.com/zellij-org/zellij), as well as running pixz on a 
> 5.1GB file to compress it, and throwing in cpuburn-a53 
> (https://github.com/ssvb/cpuburn-arm) and I'm simply not getting 2.96GHz 
> at all.  Ever.  I don't normally try to push it that high, but I wanted 
> to see if we could ever hit it (the system was also never going above 86C)

Hi,

So IIUC the below logs correctly, you are never hitting boost frequency 
(with or without this patch series). Is that correct ?

w.r.t temperature , how are you measuring it? Do you have LMh enabled or 
are you using tsens to mitigate cpu temperature ?

-- 
Warm Regards
Thara (She/Her/Hers)
> 
> analyzing CPU 4:
>    driver: qcom-cpufreq-hw
>    CPUs which run at the same hardware frequency: 4 5 6 7
>    CPUs which need to have their frequency coordinated by software: 4 5 6 7
>    maximum transition latency: 4294.55 ms.
>    hardware limits: 826 MHz - 2.96 GHz
>    available frequency steps: 826 MHz, 902 MHz, 979 MHz, 1.06 GHz, 1.21 
> GHz, 1.29 GHz, 1.36 GHz, 1.46 GHz, 1.54 GHz, 1.61 GHz, 1.69 GHz, 1.77 
> GHz, 1.84 GHz, 1.92 GHz, 2.00 GHz, 2.09 GHz, 2.17 GHz, 2.25 GHz, 2.32 
> GHz, 2.40 GHz, 2.48 GHz, 2.55 GHz, 2.65 GHz, 2.75 GHz, 2.84 GHz
>    available cpufreq governors: ondemand, conservative, powersave, 
> userspace, performance, schedutil
>    current policy: frequency should be within 826 MHz and 2.84 GHz.
>                    The governor "schedutil" may decide which speed to use
>                    within this range.
>    current CPU frequency is 2.84 GHz.
>    cpufreq stats: 826 MHz:54.84%, 902 MHz:0.02%, 979 MHz:0.02%, 1.06 
> GHz:0.02%, 1.21 GHz:0.08%, 1.29 GHz:0.07%, 1.36 GHz:0.09%, 1.46 
> GHz:0.04%, 1.54 GHz:0.02%, 1.61 GHz:0.02%, 1.69 GHz:0.02%, 1.77 
> GHz:0.13%, 1.84 GHz:0.04%, 1.92 GHz:0.04%, 2.00 GHz:0.02%, 2.09 
> GHz:0.03%, 2.17 GHz:0.02%, 2.25 GHz:0.02%, 2.32 GHz:0.01%, 2.40 
> GHz:0.02%, 2.48 GHz:0.02%, 2.55 GHz:0.02%, 2.65 GHz:0.02%, 2.75 
> GHz:0.02%, 2.84 GHz:44.38%, 2.96 GHz:0.00%  (8066)
> analyzing CPU 5:
>    driver: qcom-cpufreq-hw
>    CPUs which run at the same hardware frequency: 4 5 6 7
>    CPUs which need to have their frequency coordinated by software: 4 5 6 7
>    maximum transition latency: 4294.55 ms.
>    hardware limits: 826 MHz - 2.96 GHz
>    available frequency steps: 826 MHz, 902 MHz, 979 MHz, 1.06 GHz, 1.21 
> GHz, 1.29 GHz, 1.36 GHz, 1.46 GHz, 1.54 GHz, 1.61 GHz, 1.69 GHz, 1.77 
> GHz, 1.84 GHz, 1.92 GHz, 2.00 GHz, 2.09 GHz, 2.17 GHz, 2.25 GHz, 2.32 
> GHz, 2.40 GHz, 2.48 GHz, 2.55 GHz, 2.65 GHz, 2.75 GHz, 2.84 GHz
>    available cpufreq governors: ondemand, conservative, powersave, 
> userspace, performance, schedutil
>    current policy: frequency should be within 826 MHz and 2.84 GHz.
>                    The governor "schedutil" may decide which speed to use
>                    within this range.
>    current CPU frequency is 2.84 GHz.
>    cpufreq stats: 826 MHz:54.84%, 902 MHz:0.02%, 979 MHz:0.02%, 1.06 
> GHz:0.02%, 1.21 GHz:0.08%, 1.29 GHz:0.07%, 1.36 GHz:0.09%, 1.46 
> GHz:0.04%, 1.54 GHz:0.02%, 1.61 GHz:0.02%, 1.69 GHz:0.02%, 1.77 
> GHz:0.13%, 1.84 GHz:0.04%, 1.92 GHz:0.04%, 2.00 GHz:0.02%, 2.09 
> GHz:0.03%, 2.17 GHz:0.02%, 2.25 GHz:0.02%, 2.32 GHz:0.01%, 2.40 
> GHz:0.02%, 2.48 GHz:0.02%, 2.55 GHz:0.02%, 2.65 GHz:0.02%, 2.75 
> GHz:0.02%, 2.84 GHz:44.38%, 2.96 GHz:0.00%  (8066)
> analyzing CPU 6:
>    driver: qcom-cpufreq-hw
>    CPUs which run at the same hardware frequency: 4 5 6 7
>    CPUs which need to have their frequency coordinated by software: 4 5 6 7
>    maximum transition latency: 4294.55 ms.
>    hardware limits: 826 MHz - 2.96 GHz
>    available frequency steps: 826 MHz, 902 MHz, 979 MHz, 1.06 GHz, 1.21 
> GHz, 1.29 GHz, 1.36 GHz, 1.46 GHz, 1.54 GHz, 1.61 GHz, 1.69 GHz, 1.77 
> GHz, 1.84 GHz, 1.92 GHz, 2.00 GHz, 2.09 GHz, 2.17 GHz, 2.25 GHz, 2.32 
> GHz, 2.40 GHz, 2.48 GHz, 2.55 GHz, 2.65 GHz, 2.75 GHz, 2.84 GHz
>    available cpufreq governors: ondemand, conservative, powersave, 
> userspace, performance, schedutil
>    current policy: frequency should be within 826 MHz and 2.84 GHz.
>                    The governor "schedutil" may decide which speed to use
>                    within this range.
>    current CPU frequency is 2.84 GHz.
>    cpufreq stats: 826 MHz:54.84%, 902 MHz:0.02%, 979 MHz:0.02%, 1.06 
> GHz:0.02%, 1.21 GHz:0.08%, 1.29 GHz:0.07%, 1.36 GHz:0.09%, 1.46 
> GHz:0.04%, 1.54 GHz:0.02%, 1.61 GHz:0.02%, 1.69 GHz:0.02%, 1.77 
> GHz:0.13%, 1.84 GHz:0.04%, 1.92 GHz:0.04%, 2.00 GHz:0.02%, 2.09 
> GHz:0.03%, 2.17 GHz:0.02%, 2.25 GHz:0.02%, 2.32 GHz:0.01%, 2.40 
> GHz:0.02%, 2.48 GHz:0.02%, 2.55 GHz:0.02%, 2.65 GHz:0.02%, 2.75 
> GHz:0.02%, 2.84 GHz:44.38%, 2.96 GHz:0.00%  (8066)
> analyzing CPU 7:
>    driver: qcom-cpufreq-hw
>    CPUs which run at the same hardware frequency: 4 5 6 7
>    CPUs which need to have their frequency coordinated by software: 4 5 6 7
>    maximum transition latency: 4294.55 ms.
>    hardware limits: 826 MHz - 2.96 GHz
>    available frequency steps: 826 MHz, 902 MHz, 979 MHz, 1.06 GHz, 1.21 
> GHz, 1.29 GHz, 1.36 GHz, 1.46 GHz, 1.54 GHz, 1.61 GHz, 1.69 GHz, 1.77 
> GHz, 1.84 GHz, 1.92 GHz, 2.00 GHz, 2.09 GHz, 2.17 GHz, 2.25 GHz, 2.32 
> GHz, 2.40 GHz, 2.48 GHz, 2.55 GHz, 2.65 GHz, 2.75 GHz, 2.84 GHz
>    available cpufreq governors: ondemand, conservative, powersave, 
> userspace, performance, schedutil
>    current policy: frequency should be within 826 MHz and 2.84 GHz.
>                    The governor "schedutil" may decide which speed to use
>                    within this range.
>    current CPU frequency is 2.84 GHz.
>    cpufreq stats: 826 MHz:54.84%, 902 MHz:0.02%, 979 MHz:0.02%, 1.06 
> GHz:0.02%, 1.21 GHz:0.08%, 1.29 GHz:0.07%, 1.36 GHz:0.09%, 1.46 
> GHz:0.04%, 1.54 GHz:0.02%, 1.61 GHz:0.02%, 1.69 GHz:0.02%, 1.77 
> GHz:0.13%, 1.84 GHz:0.04%, 1.92 GHz:0.04%, 2.00 GHz:0.02%, 2.09 
> GHz:0.03%, 2.17 GHz:0.02%, 2.25 GHz:0.02%, 2.32 GHz:0.01%, 2.40 
> GHz:0.02%, 2.48 GHz:0.02%, 2.55 GHz:0.02%, 2.65 GHz:0.02%, 2.75 
> GHz:0.02%, 2.84 GHz:44.38%, 2.96 GHz:0.00%  (8066)
> 
> 
> 
> After removing this patchset, and rebooting and just compiling zellij:
> 
> analyzing CPU 4:
>    driver: qcom-cpufreq-hw
>    CPUs which run at the same hardware frequency: 4 5 6 7
>    CPUs which need to have their frequency coordinated by software: 4 5 6 7
>    maximum transition latency: 4294.55 ms.
>    hardware limits: 826 MHz - 2.96 GHz
>    available frequency steps: 826 MHz, 902 MHz, 979 MHz, 1.06 GHz, 1.21 
> GHz, 1.29 GHz, 1.36 GHz, 1.46 GHz, 1.54 GHz, 1.61 GHz, 1.69 GHz, 1.77 
> GHz, 1.84 GHz, 1.92 GHz, 2.00 GHz, 2.09 GHz, 2.17 GHz, 2.25 GHz, 2.32 
> GHz, 2.40 GHz, 2.48 GHz, 2.55 GHz, 2.65 GHz, 2.75 GHz, 2.84 GHz
>    available cpufreq governors: ondemand, conservative, powersave, 
> userspace, performance, schedutil
>    current policy: frequency should be within 826 MHz and 2.84 GHz.
>                    The governor "schedutil" may decide which speed to use
>                    within this range.
>    current CPU frequency is 2.84 GHz.
>    cpufreq stats: 826 MHz:16.01%, 902 MHz:0.08%, 979 MHz:0.05%, 1.06 
> GHz:0.06%, 1.21 GHz:0.37%, 1.29 GHz:0.17%, 1.36 GHz:0.15%, 1.46 
> GHz:0.20%, 1.54 GHz:0.18%, 1.61 GHz:0.21%, 1.69 GHz:0.17%, 1.77 
> GHz:0.22%, 1.84 GHz:0.32%, 1.92 GHz:0.37%, 2.00 GHz:0.22%, 2.09 
> GHz:0.20%, 2.17 GHz:0.20%, 2.25 GHz:0.19%, 2.32 GHz:0.19%, 2.40 
> GHz:0.21%, 2.48 GHz:0.18%, 2.55 GHz:0.18%, 2.65 GHz:0.21%, 2.75 
> GHz:0.16%, 2.84 GHz:79.49%, 2.96 GHz:0.03%  (5315)
> analyzing CPU 5:
>    driver: qcom-cpufreq-hw
>    CPUs which run at the same hardware frequency: 4 5 6 7
>    CPUs which need to have their frequency coordinated by software: 4 5 6 7
>    maximum transition latency: 4294.55 ms.
>    hardware limits: 826 MHz - 2.96 GHz
>    available frequency steps: 826 MHz, 902 MHz, 979 MHz, 1.06 GHz, 1.21 
> GHz, 1.29 GHz, 1.36 GHz, 1.46 GHz, 1.54 GHz, 1.61 GHz, 1.69 GHz, 1.77 
> GHz, 1.84 GHz, 1.92 GHz, 2.00 GHz, 2.09 GHz, 2.17 GHz, 2.25 GHz, 2.32 
> GHz, 2.40 GHz, 2.48 GHz, 2.55 GHz, 2.65 GHz, 2.75 GHz, 2.84 GHz
>    available cpufreq governors: ondemand, conservative, powersave, 
> userspace, performance, schedutil
>    current policy: frequency should be within 826 MHz and 2.84 GHz.
>                    The governor "schedutil" may decide which speed to use
>                    within this range.
>    current CPU frequency is 2.84 GHz.
>    cpufreq stats: 826 MHz:16.01%, 902 MHz:0.08%, 979 MHz:0.05%, 1.06 
> GHz:0.06%, 1.21 GHz:0.37%, 1.29 GHz:0.17%, 1.36 GHz:0.15%, 1.46 
> GHz:0.20%, 1.54 GHz:0.18%, 1.61 GHz:0.21%, 1.69 GHz:0.17%, 1.77 
> GHz:0.22%, 1.84 GHz:0.32%, 1.92 GHz:0.37%, 2.00 GHz:0.22%, 2.09 
> GHz:0.20%, 2.17 GHz:0.20%, 2.25 GHz:0.19%, 2.32 GHz:0.19%, 2.40 
> GHz:0.21%, 2.48 GHz:0.18%, 2.55 GHz:0.18%, 2.65 GHz:0.21%, 2.75 
> GHz:0.16%, 2.84 GHz:79.49%, 2.96 GHz:0.03%  (5315)
> analyzing CPU 6:
>    driver: qcom-cpufreq-hw
>    CPUs which run at the same hardware frequency: 4 5 6 7
>    CPUs which need to have their frequency coordinated by software: 4 5 6 7
>    maximum transition latency: 4294.55 ms.
>    hardware limits: 826 MHz - 2.96 GHz
>    available frequency steps: 826 MHz, 902 MHz, 979 MHz, 1.06 GHz, 1.21 
> GHz, 1.29 GHz, 1.36 GHz, 1.46 GHz, 1.54 GHz, 1.61 GHz, 1.69 GHz, 1.77 
> GHz, 1.84 GHz, 1.92 GHz, 2.00 GHz, 2.09 GHz, 2.17 GHz, 2.25 GHz, 2.32 
> GHz, 2.40 GHz, 2.48 GHz, 2.55 GHz, 2.65 GHz, 2.75 GHz, 2.84 GHz
>    available cpufreq governors: ondemand, conservative, powersave, 
> userspace, performance, schedutil
>    current policy: frequency should be within 826 MHz and 2.84 GHz.
>                    The governor "schedutil" may decide which speed to use
>                    within this range.
>    current CPU frequency is 2.84 GHz.
>    cpufreq stats: 826 MHz:16.01%, 902 MHz:0.08%, 979 MHz:0.05%, 1.06 
> GHz:0.06%, 1.21 GHz:0.37%, 1.29 GHz:0.17%, 1.36 GHz:0.15%, 1.46 
> GHz:0.20%, 1.54 GHz:0.18%, 1.61 GHz:0.21%, 1.69 GHz:0.17%, 1.77 
> GHz:0.22%, 1.84 GHz:0.32%, 1.92 GHz:0.37%, 2.00 GHz:0.22%, 2.09 
> GHz:0.20%, 2.17 GHz:0.20%, 2.25 GHz:0.19%, 2.32 GHz:0.19%, 2.40 
> GHz:0.21%, 2.48 GHz:0.18%, 2.55 GHz:0.18%, 2.65 GHz:0.21%, 2.75 
> GHz:0.16%, 2.84 GHz:79.49%, 2.96 GHz:0.03%  (5315)
> analyzing CPU 7:
>    driver: qcom-cpufreq-hw
>    CPUs which run at the same hardware frequency: 4 5 6 7
>    CPUs which need to have their frequency coordinated by software: 4 5 6 7
>    maximum transition latency: 4294.55 ms.
>    hardware limits: 826 MHz - 2.96 GHz
>    available frequency steps: 826 MHz, 902 MHz, 979 MHz, 1.06 GHz, 1.21 
> GHz, 1.29 GHz, 1.36 GHz, 1.46 GHz, 1.54 GHz, 1.61 GHz, 1.69 GHz, 1.77 
> GHz, 1.84 GHz, 1.92 GHz, 2.00 GHz, 2.09 GHz, 2.17 GHz, 2.25 GHz, 2.32 
> GHz, 2.40 GHz, 2.48 GHz, 2.55 GHz, 2.65 GHz, 2.75 GHz, 2.84 GHz
>    available cpufreq governors: ondemand, conservative, powersave, 
> userspace, performance, schedutil
>    current policy: frequency should be within 826 MHz and 2.84 GHz.
>                    The governor "schedutil" may decide which speed to use
>                    within this range.
>    current CPU frequency is 2.84 GHz.
>    cpufreq stats: 826 MHz:16.01%, 902 MHz:0.08%, 979 MHz:0.05%, 1.06 
> GHz:0.06%, 1.21 GHz:0.37%, 1.29 GHz:0.17%, 1.36 GHz:0.15%, 1.46 
> GHz:0.20%, 1.54 GHz:0.18%, 1.61 GHz:0.21%, 1.69 GHz:0.17%, 1.77 
> GHz:0.22%, 1.84 GHz:0.32%, 1.92 GHz:0.37%, 2.00 GHz:0.22%, 2.09 
> GHz:0.20%, 2.17 GHz:0.20%, 2.25 GHz:0.19%, 2.32 GHz:0.19%, 2.40 
> GHz:0.21%, 2.48 GHz:0.18%, 2.55 GHz:0.18%, 2.65 GHz:0.21%, 2.75 
> GHz:0.16%, 2.84 GHz:79.49%, 2.96 GHz:0.03%  (5315)
> 
> 
>>>
>>> Thank you for the fast response!
>>>
>>> -- steev
>>>
>>