Return-Path: Received: (majordomo@vger.kernel.org) by vger.kernel.org via listexpand id S1763169AbXHHOlD (ORCPT ); Wed, 8 Aug 2007 10:41:03 -0400 Received: (majordomo@vger.kernel.org) by vger.kernel.org id S932622AbXHHOkp (ORCPT ); Wed, 8 Aug 2007 10:40:45 -0400 Received: from pfepa.post.tele.dk ([195.41.46.235]:47608 "EHLO pfepa.post.tele.dk" rhost-flags-OK-OK-OK-OK) by vger.kernel.org with ESMTP id S934985AbXHHOkm (ORCPT ); Wed, 8 Aug 2007 10:40:42 -0400 Subject: Re: SD still better than CFS for 3d ?(was Re: 2.6.23-rc1) From: Kasper Sandberg To: Ingo Molnar Cc: Peter Zijlstra , Linus Torvalds , Linux Kernel Mailing List , ck@vds.kolivas.org In-Reply-To: <20070802154228.GA12371@elte.hu> References: <1185536610.502.8.camel@localhost> <20070729170641.GA26220@elte.hu> <1185839164.27166.7.camel@localhost> <1185863461.3092.4.camel@twins> <20070731085713.GA15136@elte.hu> <1186011827.2482.1.camel@localhost> <20070802121018.GA11900@elte.hu> <20070802154228.GA12371@elte.hu> Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="=-yKsNPyMU3f8KzV2ucnip" Date: Wed, 08 Aug 2007 16:38:59 +0200 Message-Id: <1186583939.8420.6.camel@localhost> Mime-Version: 1.0 X-Mailer: Evolution 2.4.0 Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org X-Mailing-List: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org Content-Length: 19212 Lines: 294 --=-yKsNPyMU3f8KzV2ucnip Content-Type: text/plain Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit First off, sorry for the late response. On Thu, 2007-08-02 at 17:42 +0200, Ingo Molnar wrote: > Kasper, > > could you please try the "chew-max" latency-printing utility: > > http://people.redhat.com/mingo/cfs-scheduler/tools/chew-max.c > > if you start it on an idle system it prints a single line: > > $ ./chew-max > pid 14506, prio 0, interval of 99984800 nsec > > and prints nothing else. It continues looping and looping (using up 100% > of CPU time), and the moment it's preempted, it prints a line about that > preemption latency. Under higher load it will print something like this: > > out for 63 ms [max: 66], ran for 5 ms, load 7 > out for 85 ms [max: 85], ran for 4 ms, load 5 > out for 7 ms [max: 85], ran for 0 ms, load 0 > out for 105 ms [max: 105], ran for 3 ms, load 3 > out for 174 ms [max: 174], ran for 6 ms, load 3 > out for 219 ms [max: 219], ran for 3 ms, load 1 > out for 78 ms [max: 219], ran for 3 ms, load 3 > > so that we get a picture of your latencies, could you run this tool why > you are seeing those 'bad' desktop latencies? (Since your CPU has two bad is not the exact word, its pretty good, certainly better than old vanilla scheduler, just not as smooth as could be. > cores it might make sense to run two instances of chew-max.) its a singlecore socket 754 firstgen amd64 :) > > record the latencies like this: > > ./chew-max > chew1.out & > ./chew-max > chew2.out & > > and send us the chew1.out and chew2.out files (bzip2 -9 compressed). > Thanks! i've attached it(bzip2'ed) i've come to think it is IO related, but not entirely related to reiserfs, perhaps xfs. i will conduct some tests as soon as possible. > > Ingo > - > To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in > the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org > More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html > Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/ --=-yKsNPyMU3f8KzV2ucnip Content-Disposition: attachment; filename=chewout.log Content-Type: text/x-log; name=chewout.log; charset=ISO-8859-15 Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 QlpoOTFBWSZTWVyaLIYF9LdbgEAQQAR/8AANCq+n30BgTh8+pTjopEJU9mgVbY0oRa1bKpUttLS1 NWqJaDTVTTFSIqaG2q+mUdNCJoJUDVWt2V2DQCqKAAACilBUrjbYADINCgAAAAAAAUVABqfAAfeM EWwAAAAB6AABSkgUV7aCKKFVWgAGhEJAAAAD3oQ1ZbZGWCIBQ0NUAgaQA0wglVDQZAGQAaehISqg NGj1AAAlPKQoVUNBkAZABJ6pJKRSZAADQAJqSqp+hRtTIA0GhjUCklEkRNAAAaBwKIl+cqRV/DIA uBFSo/Mion7YgEaIJ/uJSriCVyFU6IiXUoFOiK6BByVTqRLkiXSOqDoFxTikukcOBXRcuUp1XU4o 5yr8/FS886quclVQ4RzgQLkpXiBRLYSqi/jSp/XoCUl6oVAf8CUlvh8PyEvyCNJ/m1St4gykF+BR H5nDf4WbZtaErTJbAqQPpBB2/idOFM6MU41wXRPWn2LrffcxQZ2Fj40yGIEqaaTUCcSYDVSKYXsY Yt61GNmmWMLJmZm3r7Xh1sxxwQaac4mtGNvG9oncottiBd/DzmjzxwUGkWL06LRCO+2cFm+acbZZ J1RJlKfFjbTt5EC0OvL5CET2bd4kzwK7ZguirLqionRPlfoPCTPg6NfHa/vjygLqEyF+aOjS5Pp8 Za/DMObNLghAJ0cPROt2NideWrxDPsMfhECN0Xtglmz6DBJVwQMIsGyrVQENN245G4acuuwXd5e8 87VnGJjLFsRrKOTL7OL7tHKhY5QgxavPtwsF9T4mVA2jrXBLgGOvNI001CRUI1EJfCTibMsig2on I32Mznjk6aDdCJ9uy1pfGWNBnx0XM61oiOi5JaoYqQcaEBK+iWip8cRwwbjaguaZGYhisOmlZu0y jWFLi2awqkhp7yh95YdognkFRyyn5PUjBhAhrFzwm0lpmTjkRPrmlMDKJdM4NpxvRhdcqyI/OlMf mgzxa6w4NmtQvIEbismKudsIhIPPZW16WE7ybtOfDhpnBcMUrWh3Z44B0VHZMF272alNBrBCVQ48 Q/Ifu3leuENbaj9Qnv7235LDCBEg8fnUd+YsuiTVmmRWDLLk5+yYI81SV5ZR3LrbVkFCFOISGMGi fGt1rx3XZeKS4l64wWt0UOjyPKJrXjHqpRdcZI8WyukfjpDHkB58PXHYipWRuKzIheSQBevZRXJA 2oTTXMM1IkMOS3VkLZsXW8oy3WJIgKUjEZ5Q9YeE2w7BDQpoQY9uWWbt56wr3lXuV4c5K7AJCK8h zQ94bD1k+MafrZxZfDpwNnjhGwIkp368PeQ4WUNxPuy5YZw8ruxZ40ktIm0wTBHjIL5vEJtOec++ PnJ0aCXXL4w2sY8RaGOFZEmNSLdvLmp3jxx8siO7du8ExbiNMXwvHTFlM30L8iw1vL7zw4nOwagm x5CeIvsyRFUaDQrWkMWhYS80QY8ubrYCNS9Z27PWhRoTL1E7VEL44e6147OD2w6JQ7GxaKFEt82L hlFoLbNEtMZtfyGfPRzJvoaxIwIMFdUTPeHw+6/tzTsx+o/diSZ7p83rnPRL2Jw56UZfr8ZcEEbo 0gEj5w0Kjsamppe3bfC8U62a2utahbqaENrw544JXznriKKzeT65miKpy9SfOe/bvkk104JdjyDn IlRL7mxUziEEEzHHw+NL9ZDFUJU+jXSl68BaLOCDGLGjFqMkaTAsaX3JFr44g8ZBUK8+mPD591pL hRQWbtlEuj+4n0lV+sDda0h511kXa7cdNVqPJu01B92dsLsHyjRzjVOZx1XJz5zimyQo37p+5nUy /XkO/i9c3HbBSGRRZFDwpH8Y0L4dYdmOC6djX12LwzwlCGEggG0SBNQEaPKQIWa5+eNDCM3rlDBs wFkG5ABMYoDpwyq/cmWtJP6DU8MPXCXq2B1KsJwXjIq262b2TPHBZBZzjoGKmkCJ4tMrdSc5JHnU OOpmvLLOOHmczUOUXUFlsE4Paxp7kQapkIg62ERIt1Kyl1bEn5wZTFoqaJrvJpTDiHnRnVrZoqSO HSkF6LYkxU5tJ7XUx4C0TLKSBWOnG9vi+5LglEPRAEFlY/eVho5v1xXr4LIYxDTynK1zYdLotbz0 xjCMkYCF40fEWY5eXQs7JIEGOBLx+Grxh7dkdFe7JJkjI8omYU79KaPAAFwi11FwrEMMf06rm9eO jTGCbVxYlRBESNpUl7c3LppI61S7mIcb+K35uGCqa8zi+qQaIRiDdXHZ4diCwkGOaPiAiT7FOQHP McDJIB0i9gbQGHieWefdYxKEJnG9Q4hNBE35jgCUFw5yR321QTY+ixihgwOSRwI9SV8dwexM3LXJ ydc2IN7ZqSOYbEIJnYwWqRXY5KtitMG1mQkH1zUZvZDj0TjEZ0UMoumBfuPbxVNehScWx3u5dEjd 64CT7zxIDQasxpTzFuQu8yNCz41COsP3PTA5jUaLaHpLHneaKPkEIX1aljLdPfDTEtM+O10UTrgw 6bog0N3d2+s4OK58S5zQhBJDDZBT7ktafzglRUzIiCUMiY0Ma62tLGl4gqYzFVyTODRTHfLTeR7t xz45Krmbzvk4dQUmomTsUSZhSEWKUDKVJHrq7s1YSmedPsGSQ18maqVYD2LtmVChx467wVMYrrnp TNYa0015vh7xkI5IWRSBxDWgfFxVKmuy4kPZBBFi6SR1Wc35hVTHr0p8LooZwBbHDKJAAjBAcjyQ IeSPufiiO0bsAMGqxh72h2FxAcVCiO7HrDhS65Z6qnhYgoAdZ95/V7i4JRhOJQfH98j03tiHO3vc LbGuGKGcbwxGebSomZ0vWrHmi43uunNz43eE6UoS0qliYLmYodrOTLt+urW0K3lyoCtpiYmBm25F gZBYxMYg0oFKwGkC0xiAidlmS2JfR67L5wheaRaILyEZgKAABu2oIhOBTc+Rz9Z77PI1Br5LGLhO TUJRfW1z8OXb89FSc3birXbZj+kxQ527u8419WuCxiZgUgC05YjpeVErEAPNVkTPtTB8QPESNBOi Q7rWiNf3Gj51CaM+liPNHWhGtDxPfufHOJUS5otliGzDjVENxBXDAzW1W12SI6+gT2xcMTM0aPCX hQS8bGiNZ0z3uD5VTxRCDQrQ2kxGtKCWdM4LRc1hfud5udF0YzGLgz46JRbZ+V3bMn6yZowlFgdQ kBeNzlNFQ60+ccfGSExXtmiQ2k9cFBHw0Rrwoa3mdMkcOGWtnOOkTZWCGwQbMihRDKbTFnk3w5AZ 3lJhHgbSzzTECUVLtW0bRTHhW2Z8J61i+PuBJWxbregYIIXLMzOvmKhARDBsvF18tZvG1JaGAs3B B9GC6dNrQdJhmlGrtH3mGLF4vMqy33rwi7Q3UI3HKhqEBWoSdI9uDxM9l+nEK9u7JCIBnnWvvntP jPXeXUqFxZKPapurHkGCaQ7XJQRS6RRYeBCOEWXI9yXdj1qmfGh2Rl7jpIJWS+Sy2UOBnrdDjxqz pl2xLhoccCPFvJS4HBZ7jFGqjpu+miDPigEfW1K1Rd+OKI1Ph9ezFSbYkTnaoIRlHGoZr7Gan195 Zq3XkSCirFkj8UM5WetDJDAYgUihwNMovdItTe5rYthNsBuyEWGjUOjV3Z1xxKSOiW+TZiumVpbl odAOLOXj8eKIw5cT3EIQL5cQUrMCQ7Z2JWEfFxPzeuX46LjA3AASD3WofCa0s4PX03V2L0Tvm9bK hjjxaAkWW5v22pAtanzu671sSZPudFWLRuRaVRuDhCJI6a/XcXvaHaQC2vbfm4NLe9AiPThITSI8 QDJuy5W5kHRXbtCRm/SvG7VNLHLmRXnK7uWCRsKhwpGyFFmKHCBS8K+LZTTFr3LZGoR36zdiQLov RcfP2zlLWS27y7WJ4UBsRgWA9i012WBG/CWm4F6mRrjtYKtvPmpGCQxNJcQttUUOFuzsXJk1oEVo bYmLm3E6g7C8TqDtk40/pSHXOIRpK1BDVkEoJE7LrzN1oEGJpvMAbQZBMw0KME7R2fbolGwxM0zx nNzXM8WA22IxmYxNjTDsf3ldVSAXjTII771QKT0p1sPle2oUahCC55Q+xHfPoCkMCGddmW0RZ11c jtYWgjZv5hTnGN9FqixOFWSBx+vOUoGIGKiXb02gjjiOCBUF1yXtmsjiL7dUV+85oa57tnUFIoJI SOSizOnTEzdeIMaAVEoYgxAyA5u2EmvXNTFNZHlPRw4hxn3Zby/Lea9cdi83vOJ51/b55bsxw/Vt d+2vGpqcPqHXBTiOwBJPOwEVx1ySfqTrIE55vJ3eoIGWtYume19PjgJ24buTWlUwTEN8cUeO+qtS oouElbTEGKIzAyCXY14hQyo8i76Pz7suKpxzznPe0O8zYgX3zyhPTJrXa+krmyI4+1hhWlpmioqf GSdnDEqMTR4beyTF6vLHiWx0YDNVGl6p7efXA3z+F0S55nGu+e+wctGlncQ0zDjFDTLUWusNIsnj NNDZH01AZaPTLUfEibTTs91WDXuVBXVOnhmt46NAhCWvZBQDWwUbEexON+05t1yPeNnO7EmdSHl3 WEe43jlnxa8msjQYzEdahpY0gXVYXm0xDQq2Yq+zK04Wv4Vvw/N0FyDXld9dKk3mAoYlwyGLTNEs VOnOabVDI+/WC4NPYojRiQjoxIKJMxmwUlrFRWcyP1xzU+s4L1wlVM+JUHXOIKcTJwWReph3kvPR q5WZ+cNWIPr5zjebA9yXj8rX9YubqyyLtYGaDkVRK8dUmBBgZmi2rpDeSIDFW8lUj1plLXkMvuRZ 8Nw8JpaCF2oLXPEI5CCvR5Ak8wiKw4+Wr62tkndqlkwMQKtqvkSxlMTOtTXcXW88JWDzgp6pzAxj 5sotbSBkEGK+e8eHnDEGOtMXDKLWQiBAu1rOGZdedM0SDMBAmL4mtINI1sS+FvyGC0xLlfbVNM9x 0SEI+eNe5DRAMORBnjWmsaoA2nEMIqyFiAw1zexYhErLtCyl2dd2hRhCA7Dm5owBwk8NQaXtkXm4 LvmkGLhvW2TS5w+JN1Fsbw0KKsaXGq0johWWg6xTUIRUWyJb5zfPl8Q+2c0c0ccBmKDMSBGyeNFh 13ligoIMbaDAbeB1vIMVbSI8BLkUIuLfRI1505AemA0KIUFDIYlAGJBimvILAN5IUghcsxiYTloh L28JnxmiAMQo0gWHzxna1BF9ypSr0znBKsUOcj1rBCpjVbBHe6GqasGKGuZbLg1mQ59QhfnDECpg ZRUjdIhVpMjXuOiyGVUNSozU0cdjJDzmHnNc4/f1n3li63wwKWyujaxr0hrqERsSBdFSIuKLmcSR +vx3FOJVkP5LlwRa01khL3deFHMCPKoRhshYddg7EB6DmaXyDXBTzkquC4HONla7uxuwzCJoNbV9 Z7vZ0zsYQWOiawQCgZGovl5ojefm73bvvd6ndxANZNSRpQnBRr6zr7bqTzYkNcUL5XOGvYj3d57u 5zBxrJwWyPu2K5Cbmd1XSd1CXSbkyQVU+RVDWfiucXkFy0TimLZSpaXCD2Z6wLYQKVZYaxgUONCi aLbJrGtNiI1KFkkWTERgTNMkAEQU0saES/mIo2aQAASn8W422K8iNXN0ouXNiiq5O65qogkixBbn KpBiDCHMUmRZzFJFJJjEUblcucyGLlyKya5czINIRkybctzRoqLFnXAkiZpiJASBgEmRu7dXduXK i5k3K6Fo2NRsUlMoxIEUVjXK5WjSQgRc5oNBSTu5zmNSTJzrBRBpd5oqZw1ypLlCOZJYMkM0HuE8 ISCslZlV3bsNmcuOHOY5J3bpCUSLCFqKyWLJySMFzFrIRBImjbcvNXzV5zXNu7tgit20UaYbm6Yo kDyvvt50GTXwwySkMUNigHO+jOncUOhuaaOlkwZqAoRhQTGyCRlgdBe3bdLA92LhzTuo0RXK0w0K YBRIEWQSMQRSCNF3cnYvNzm6/na+JmZY0F5qWYQHXze2vCbutcI1gpKESaGKSxiToGD17rec7uq4 a5bRcIsbFFO6mGUpkjnIWSskJDu6BQZKQ0QyxiSd4VHDI3XnuyZjuuwJKNXpbzdqB3joLeSm5ru6 5oKIopkkdi9dy8Kjc4QmSuHJIjTI915ffeWki8TUzZJBdwScx3cmC2Ik7t2k2MUUaJIjX3bzvXpV eYxd11EYi2RhRc5y3KddXTEJJJRi1zqmSM7ot0xOmXbdGu65kNSR3dW5c1DKIuVBrssmx0105XZa Awu6uimEsbEl7pxcwUTL3dmYti5bhyObuu3LcFMrWSKawhtkiJNg1m7kqIihCIU0EB6LYtGryUkQ 3ZK93ZzsRESAkksublDSu5btKJjjECIuCKKIhRCkE01jqAyzeurpslctculcV81u+7tUzHNu6dXJ AyU7roetSjmk4I4lICzine94KTUglfmyt+j732X2L973t+KQutzLziESUbwlACddznujRQGunONc 9+99ffUZdiyRqAiTm4U7KRMhTuXmmWKLnKOk3XuwTlw4aJzB5Nm6TpCVJxOHOOpY4nblzdDkRt0d ve9Hkve8pLRzW2do2cSGxiajR1c1XHNdzZJJyRloqhcLc496BxzOq4N9t5FfpjT9fvb47pBfv3vZ 5u3C0h6ndQ6VXNNkWFbmHBFzraj3ZXEZIEUg21E8IAmKoVwyyRxqV0hgEGIY4ZLjGA5uVVQrVeNg jGZwnFYlJsDliWsfo8A6CHZ7936T3+H17fquzBc0EmIvqZruWun13SyqrBZAnFeW7a5IjpkJY2m6 mR9kiDMWBiBBgYgoitGi1GgsDMoxoSNExBRixFkopBBMUkBDMWCJKBMyNX6LJiwUkNYQIGgv2S7z eRRkTcxtc3KrnLlGtzW4WI2uW6SVyxtw0bk7jc1G5FGxi5a5Eai2I1JRGKNy5iLJGxsRctdLc5kq 7uwHLJW5o2kCkSOR3dauW5G3Nk3OE7tyrlrnJNCFCU7uiLd3Z3XIcdxgOcijJqIopAhwxcUCrKsF UFJWHJJxQWQmpcWZwRCsmhoQRgCMANjQRXOYsbFyi4aCy7rpFOdOdu7gaaStzkSY2BmK5cua4dXm Si2ExjbFvXdtdMhTNc770RU9r5YklIIuOuEOIpM5JDhOQ4ZWRUHOcuQHNGM66CjpdIx3dd25pzpM mAxYi5rkd3UWALG3yre7tsWq5qd3K6ubGi7u4w0KQxJjGlANCiVL+/XxPzi7uc7l1NJJX5gMWe6t ypVJZNFV+mJRJ99Po1vjW+199fX1en2YiosRIjRNkJSBJMWZNPApJfdrzRvLRWLHNEcg3K5Y24MR mZgSwaXd0OXHOExVzcA0pmliu1zy6L70vr6DDQplea6aMXNX1BRGN7e+7fKW+gvt1dfd54RaMaSM o0xZAk0RBTEiKTFfKRl7716KvlwpNRo1y5zXDY2QxsY1c1zlzY3NojCUikYUISNGoru5u6uRYrl2 YwQGikzu5hkzFIkRSZ22M+uu3fPt8qQyu64yXLF0GIMVuVvsJBKb768023lL696vMaKEQyYne9rv dVypc7FdSCiSumuFJc5s0l3p1fvvRNvmvkkrnD3csRJKUQCgU7qUMbu63KrmxbkEbFpMYaBZMZAx QFOpj3eyaivy+afdzKlS+7psiUEbjItHNx12Du5KZTFHOuhdMxDJYhsSKRkTdZ0WOG3GJRAWTu6S JXHFRRygGKZMBp1yeV5qI1GozIASSKXu5rNMJJk0ly3ZBgLdK3aBUc3KZBWGxmLm6EZMnK6YQrld m5dDMjA3XV0Cyu6uGiMpmbO6uomO7cnddgwp3XbnEVzjBJigKQE2WEyIhF1tXthMHtwyHu4DFGOX bd1zdOXd05dM0QSddzMgaObpjjZLJBM7jqQJx3ZzKcOdveJe7mIxoYFW5FtzZXzaV33nJzcrnC5S Rjd3bm5q5cuFGxGvfe+e91m2jmWMRGOOjSuKrVihCGjvfKJ643a+GmLX1+d9eX2O9d9Lr5zXhBNd VwvbupD04ZIXcy6XcZwHPSg15yVJ1xi5RMLg1jkjzIee73Wx/cn6eevNIoCk3XTJrwxCm0qDiIpI 1KjSoozUo4rVGaKDg7LOKUcTTOJVkTE4Km8LeDIrr3p3e51pVsIqaxYXNTW5cXNh1tOYpYxKwyEs xagnGNeNWWkTojuWa6SJZqaaURNMwWpNArts6mq7TmtohFMNYgjgzkTkuxu5FZKkswtkKhuZw9zm Li4NCiinbIxHupnVcBTXSsiMtZZJaHm1Or3hw6gpcxToe5zH3vYPoQjneHDjKqnDQ2JA2YRDnKza ajJInGhTI7ASMlIGUpKoLRn23YOoM7bjFCdTRbbayHdJQI20ixECtJqTFtdY0otqcQUyKsjvCbxD 4uKGtljmu7WRU0LXnjO3uefd9ju/Dc746/D/X6fyBRJ8X4/oJD7FKeS/J6vUqL2BD2efjexUeope +vX4/Kk+KR79b8vYeifXLozPOdm+zkpypcvjyKngK84DqRiZLzp0aza+d79dVT1KvL48oq8FJ4+v FDyUvnRdVaYzZ785U8E8dEcJYsR7y6xTJXjlFyoaVimWTNYMDulclaWk1qxWVOe+FXhDuh0GMZMl 5yrkO45M1iZTzpHVTDFmYYPOJyrVhjWrFzkui002ZaaWljLVpYYdy5bYy0xrWaps1LKUqZXOpLNJ CRu7dSloDQpkySkNd3RtFsUZE0YN296tW9ttt7e++ylelIxK0SfblToXn177L0MsbWFiPrkHUTvP FPJGmq7XzPFWKe+PKR4Jeco5DJpZo1aO4OpatTaysmqYGTWs1tMMrSTH87XbXt2rq0zEotKjCU2a ylCfduopSpmS2KTF93ZkmySVls2pVs0rx0HFPnByn11xZjGHzqXQyw9OnVs20ssmFppfu1dteXns +7qlmzKUqmmLGIj+u5MTLzdJlf1dbdrLTaK/pcivddpkSTNkmyYWKmIsZ/XV1KYIiKUAmIRJjfzt f1Nbt12QtamlFaabFF/jomJ81c0GKNy+92oopNoixRsWxJJsY5Xm3m0VjRg0mxa5q5oi3OImxndX LGjm6BhHnb++uJKYjH3c0ibGIg0KnduFnOdcvevDMgtRUSYggo5XDzkW5XMFa5t2axRyrlqNYkiK gxqi52b73W9Cjc6GxebcJIV3VckwaMGjbF5HMhgYmMIkkSYNCkyQJsQRsVGwnO5s7hknTC856ulR kryN5a3lijd3va5RsaKDctuWMSWNipMVe7grFUlJtG2I1y3c6NkuGuGSjIVFUakxWKNzTrqjT3Xv utcvlYAqLXIuGJ92uVea55uXu6hC5ci3N2eXMzG3LX3uNc1XEiLBJo3zVdL5xPdHYMpoxrFF8rdJ MYwRtiMWI0vO5bu6jXI2NjZMmp3crd3bGxY3NfLeVFGg0m2IrEYkRHhu0GU7rt3c93e5NzJLt3Ig BTHP7V6GAxGF5xpQ0TF+bbJCXEFmJCUS7x1HcM5UqiiipNG84RY2BJCSIsUW93FiuO6KNg0KKjYi rluaP7fNt8+ZKe683m3OaKZitEY5uaDl/S9mIq85JosGi2ObRdN3dXK5aNCVG5VcqoxjaKTYCzEs BiiohK5YrnK3OcoBlHK4za5cuFum+Vyx5tuRaKTURt3do1cuUZNJjYjbuu2I1G2Sxbm3d2q5ooij lroaNpK5quaInO1InNeW3mNt/FctFRqjPu3NjRo1uW6aNrG2TGktEQRkr5XvXNMGmMIMjIyRN/fV x53OJGUEQSLIYvnCSDSPLpglJdOaSTFJlAcNCqRJLZFZDu5OOyzWpRJZXpo9NYCjG5XQAh3XSind XKDRgSNy1yjEVXBQSicyVzKf7NnHYhaJsRqMbJBIjuuO6OPrq89JAwmu67Ygtfz3V5GlcycXeWcQ 5JLUI4uIhJppbENGY0C0Q4islglTiLtK5tuV7y65zve+77JEQCCBWKDzmJJIqJNFFcrlgii5XYm0 EwtM3SuUhRu7oulxMcNdmIxtubiGLfNXXl13dRtJrKMjf4Lzb00lRoU5jkKjQwygQstkkzh1zdh6 3r1uuu1Fukc4u7y9QxjXl2WXDsamBu7jMh7jXe7uux03LmpMbRRc3KMykTSdZm02L651zVOPY0dI qFcoHcTuE6HWb5zeW7f4dcglBNGHttpBLNtiBjEAYAGGDQrug7Y17SBTFxTaIacld3V0u6aDcK4T nFXOUbRTd0hysXOcnbydcw1MOuSYodSVySFcrIN5uomchKGTBZOVsTRCKKKiK+odZkubG2xu45KT kTGNVZhUI4dTRw2YnKyeZZbEiJOSLkRYpkhOZhOFcosG897oqRNkUZnddm+/vv33aDfu6NGLXmrz elRWLcukWucjJGibc7ZlBJbNJ01DU1DRNQnBEDrhqeUkWjY5XQxiIS5O6KJ3a4UMIrlyQpNO7gai jSXLXNd3Wiyh0ypUrRDilEtytTnL283uTVnTpoyb825jRq5XJmvTlEGipNzhza7HdzRy4YguVXZs RG5ciJ3XLGkg25tcsWxzruzuRTl1ys4ULNa6m7Q62OW7a8U955xbGTH5cu7sJogpA0XJhKiqYvfH Nb3750+Kirgq+oWg3OkWJAkw7nd3bjGJcrLHA86OsiK27ubMsKWWHm5t5yLrjuJAGvdya/r7vEit NqSmKkLGDQojopGlwgggxZkWsjuua5aMcrm652wix3dmIzOdx21yI5rh/HKxTMP47F5zEX3dqA0K w52o0bFSuciEzG7riiXfz15YvLcLF3dUYt3dsRM3d2gkKKd1cwUzcxbiaTaDaxjXOYxRiItzciiC sURr85Ge7jJld3ZSSZru7Du3j92+yo8rdKTY2J3cszAWSMb5bprmi1dI1QY1GML3bcosRCmry15r 3u1yvd1CeblGKosaKMbFFoyaktCVciuGiia5u0DiNEgiTAuOVY1CiwiM3vXly/v3zYjBgyMQDEae 6uVyc64bnL7uTYhPLkpL3cKSNg3muYh3Xd3DXNzEBrNnOAWuVeRurBOGS1r0fPc6I2MFIqnUnMU1 JxhkZySpVClgknBmMERKWUKpiF2LYXMkwm5uaownvd33Vr5sYIoZfOc3LF8tysRqMBotGkIrz3n7 3zfEyW+XNRjURe7sbQZNsWxV13F07O7Gy5bsOOFEQqUpTimSQ4lEqHKA1wnnY6nHIe6T8jfd3A6x ij5cxJQaELde7bwojXlVzPdcsVvcnva5slSGybzXNqNjYg1ZkSB3L72vI2xsd11GxsbRY8q77reb yxgyea3Sry3NRc3a53K65O933t8gxjGksZ92+J5c1d3Vi81ea9x2MaNBfx0oo15wu5dzlRrm2GLu q6TX3eW9CLTHdVyIijRa5uG3d1ZBKLRQVct5Xve72wWNaZrBBWLBszT3XZGQNYtoqKu7rSeVXOco 1CQBSWTebkUT11cxFoxUbXlp3Um3dwaNqNum4YKKLGw5xaLG283a9OxJURi5tc1Fi0bOOtcxi+bc LcrvdcqKiDQaMm2Y52zCjYSDcndbmtyEtR5W6WK3lrlz5reVy5JsVJRrc3Pe7zZe6o1dvuq5WNEa vd1jRiTQV7ury1y1zW6XdxTd1XTFjGubcxndubUVHNuXzn5uGxUUAUbfOWg0MNuXSoucp3W3ZRRS WndzEVioLRY0GLO+715R3O0RJfxvTz+lr964EN85dbyqMgY0BZkqLSyhDWWsoVmqE2VDZVtUbAtk Q2VUbVU2qAxoJbVJNg0KmZKjZAzSlsUGxVmJW0qVkWEs0KmwJbJJrIW1JsBsVSzSk2KTZC2iVpWi VsitYTZQ2EWMo2pso2jWUtobVsu8v5BKS+IV56PLdtona7VXajlrRo22jVbGtFY2oxo2bQXZWx2E 2ibWxLaaNiLWxVYraLFtjViyG0jZG1U2Q2mybBW0B2UOzM2rtTtEbJ2pXNajbRWjVjUbajQQhtK7 FXZNhbU2W1soZiWwFspO0rtUtpE2lq5zaxijRtHNyi2tjaqNtcrs1tFixtFYrRtO31g80JtsthPM VdoW0VsqthLYU2gNoGxO0q++LzI2pGwtltAtpsklsI2UlbFsU2A3pxUoXaJE/L16DQqkvPR4ybS2 jZGyLY7UnNBtFtQrVGtFjVjWubWuaLRaKK2ii1zkaItQVsVG2Ki1a5a/pVryxFW8o2rlEWsUlRVz cN/X+Pa28tWMWKiNrRsbG/Nc1fmuy2i7UO2xNq9xO1tIfM9xXmDZIq2RtJKMlVQxSI+yVSkwTzSv NEd1uWito1G0XNtuaxq5uaqMGNqLaNbYtYq/i1crFjFRaxVjaIrRVRbeVzajFbWKLbG0WsWtFRa3 Kuawa2Nti2L83LWiry5a5qsdN/FubRaxaC1fla4baiqKxtQVai1sVGjFWPlra5bY1babUqUmbAVU woFPqrUtcjUmo2jBrRbHm3Majc5rluQa2ixaii2g23NVzG07qxq5tyNsVwsVi1P51q6WtefxXN5b QmxtQRXlL1zqeMvGU2R2ulURVFyK7LbFaNiisW2Nf0rmtFajy1zajWLRGqNotFtGottjWMJY2i2i KK0FeVc1jGSqej78nmtjY2N863cu7mw/d2wbBisSa2jaN5yt5LsqzD76jtRsVV9GnY2lBWiN+flb eYotFkqSxrUW0R5ba5jblq5Gvy3NRirJqvNuRttX3dWEo23lqubGsbcty0c1uajEa3mubbf5Nuaw YqNEW/yXDYqLfm3LaP53bXm5r+OyvLcotEGKM7sVzWDWjbX387eaiirFUfKuaig35bs8Z2Ntlu6d hN6+3/EpVE/0gqJ/4o6EdKji5U0GRllZMxWslSieVUiT9RUX0zahJYmiSrGxkEsMiG0VWaBWsg0K zITYq2pJtSBq1slKbEbKobBVbFRtrUi2im1RsRsIZkqtqLZKtYFspLZRsEXyCUl7fEEpLygSkvqC Ul9Pr+/y/zzUBH0qlUlqJSsFZRRF90CUl7d7vb/YEpL2BKS8ASkvsBKS3rbwCUl7VUUl17gSksCU l9vv+AEpL5/rVRSW+cCUl6VUUl7/vQ0KgP/MUFZJlNZrX/cQwRaTFuAQBBABH/wAAqhh59AYDo/f Qu9U8jUH1Qgmmq222ZAtrZsrWzaHXHQbRWMgKo1WgrS2IbDAAAACgBRQFUPoA6AAB0SAIg0Kkitb RjWWA9e89KUAAoAoDQoAKATsAGgSSitDIaagVSKihQlQPvUaGSUGp4RNKgAMgASnoiiKoaehADEE mUlESoADIAEnqkkqJJiYAABNSqjSekxGIYank0CklKkMJpgjBMOoFRL7lSJNEJKo+6lAelEgqxIn NELskKjqpI6VAXFSinIlxIk4kdJTlJLonKnUqujguVGK1HOB0ajNRzQ7ipEnIeJESXChKS40lQH/ oSkvH+WZ+iRx/pI4p+Gp+Eq7rYhv4m+TM5MOZUF0nyth6yn13K71u8e9fXsZVOQXAUv6wzXp1FyW B+iVzTyfre76qfXVHk3x0h+pKgKHvWJ3FBJFiRPXK5XIi+PbOffIE23xFw86Hx8QrO9p6nrhzRxQ FDxwlPnne7vZ2uWhRoWgZb1hGEG5YUIWJkONnCsSKph7TbtDWFkXFV4wzpUnLdnc5SGnj5YuLsh6 5N2vTNVz1MlmagUTFFUOjAZ1z5fLmuXoyHji4RFxcVRVyuVtmESMYg+wrjdoeujmifPxncyoHxOc SZ6BR5iWDfKbh963DkOcNc7oBUFwRfslmJN+JieVMSUQxY/lKC7loXTlX5XO07VGnb48K4/aFffv Hx2Od6hRcE7CglX5aZxONyPV1j640hzCKToQ77bnY8rsu1RiRd8Z5D43fyOOd3FucuFfdXlX8rfL Gt5tcd25tGxosVYkCQy32xt3yxvIcyaoXSKNu7sXMbY23LdDVzRZQKiTKaTZVXqOdpy7Lr1u60jS 73QHvWF5AUBQ8ybmQUJUk6lFxzg5Mc87ToQAkyqTpw0KbdWOqTBIu9W5N0ucqjJZztEY0YqdxXAr u6/q/dfLfJNWDRi83Ly5pOmublcvyrm84VBvKuFJXlpx2vld7tFG3Kj+jl5uFG0Fvy5jG3kHDQrP yL0BIA0Knqdso1tKz7rKHmdhcplFDw2caSGTE6cF+wyoa8lXpEM1BSNRElhbAXKooRJAnBJlwouC cpzjnzpBfK7D62Occ6QPJODmT3derc1zbXIvm8tCZe65sbGUDSCqSt63JyHJyerAvnZmg2Kdxc77 vLXhqPpulGFBcuBdVzurc76yZT8cSY8rmc5BI5UXDz3S5muKpi6nIFQsbmHO6VcI+XS/nvz0VfnO nGk06HLJyaTfE7pQzQXoI5inJG7aHJUNCuKuuRzFZFjFGM7oL711PdtfNcxT3Gym5xIpnK4etgkX BJFASE+rz5x1Tu6JDnKcrjzicjpqFTFzFyOYuRNeQzUPEyd5TxAqa4fbPOmV5Nb8mE8nt9fND1Us mYRxk9ASbnYJhyhVgJ6jKB1BO3zp6CQFAnedg5xyC4vMbmcErmIFFwTJjnE7YehZB3Rj+O96+oE7 Lhfx2JXyThpTDQlBRCVvvRyYhF347XS8vm523JschIedvO86cHKmXNc+uGVMfjHoKKJ5bUiCkcBV Ebmd21/DXLRt5uYiHdLJISdWfPcThWr1tIE4nYjcr55o25q88Nv6Nc2DX7usawcLZniYaqCrnb5T REa5EXMnnHONz/Hcm3OnQhUZSiMp9fnr1TORNlwLpwuJNp+unA0KvNi5bmqI/lXZfm3we7RecJsN Qfs280+WfE5A9+9ukQjnxMI4FH4h2sAr4gah2zAsgKKQQ0bX5q8tFvNu+7fvu2gq+b57et6BEFwy Oa1wUx+wip4nOVFJkFMXkj3NybyBOhy4J+dKoa1yuy/NxQK5yosRcXA5znK2xtnu5o1EHNeby2N5 rkTJp04FUh0mfrc5EL5YJ0hfbThHZcHJejfWcuFOQ90pnWfXM5eixMXD4l2ZF2HxzIrUz6q8tFeW /lrwo2/qXSrm3NvgoLmEalQGwXMXbSqfbMFA7SZ82BRR18Q8TnkrVvRpy2VyJu+t9c5UzXOao5EU fIRIhUqlnywGsXbb623uvHJXthrbfmhTvt8OokieBVXG7ziUykHSow75G9xOpduRQfbfsl0trFfU jfkqpnOmz1s9k8DwifrtKfkHkkyrjnTPJO/VSRT02UnAu9W366FV/EPjy1icErspJyBIibmonHdB zhdy0HNsQXzj7q+em3lbpvAkVoF0M5qQJJy4XE4UPjyLl52hFUFXclUgpdH76Bd5PKcQEqb47HIT PJlJ1mQqn1C7bnEOCTKphQygpOWEytCgToTyYkCYf5784NGoDQooc5rlTB2ApZMCpFcPq8e42LXK 0VxN+bpRfy+EakfYQ5jiP1resuEVzPUCCC5GNSCHrHE9tv1mHYogyCi4yGp9fiaIoRw5MCNswb92 LubZkTIsmqTcOa8q5vNM6973hoBJCK9tNjootyRSuNtgoktt0dyRldc9sE5cD+xpO9AocilQZTTh QnH5WFDnZZFyj6JBTC7ru+u3L1idlCo+M741yTGLnLdMc288vl81fK5t8o5c3MbdLGjYXO5tzBjk DnnTO06STCmU0k4UN6jyBIvnDQpIFMEOHokHqTCnJzjnDQLss4WdID1zjz5OZ2Bd57rKF1tzud5A 4V5x6gnHJhQ51ROFAU+JjkwuFxyZ+WNIKYEQ0gTzITsSAq7LO3N8jHncyEmGI3nTsa3hFRG5Vc5T 3Frlq8C+WkF2FNly83rkBQUOcNXNGLe7rearmxUlRjFtzhrM2xpwoMSJ8/fvz2PrtIfHnhF30Q8z 3raHcrpNpkxOkNOlfJueV/UOcJ0phSQ0g9cgKLhzycSGW7SpMcXKkxCOGc8qZcCnVOAknB3a5D9Z NzSBEwZ5Ytgvx596D0fIe6b2lxCysnJjz5PdG/UPIoerbKTgnU6roVcihd1X5yiIryt3WNyacuxo dOPId1e7u+MHIoCJlFxooJay5ccyZTSYkynIu05oUJnZSHXyOduasKCgV94h3IC5EynusHPxIduf 104Ux+PnB1GnaQFCGRTGr+VcK8v4elo2Lzb3urzY2ncgcgHOPjicTg3JjnacKZm0FMyxmCgfXRUr zhBDxzVWxn0b6nO9W866DQr97E8guNOwoTvjLdPE84nKTtPCPR3QTzmREVzrN2cx+9M7Tym2bbRH LILHcHblsYixul3v5ffQXTUeiJjZKJNJONJhScEmk0/KMcgTtKhp2UMTpAnAC7LlBTFRO3k3k6gk F3lcI77t5reUQzajb5s90WN7uuaKDQrmirmuGrlzW5o3CKrlUa5uY3LmLGs7tjVc0bRouM1c3LpT ujAfbA0K5ENag0v3S6wxEI5BxVAF31xp08g9DQpgkmScshDpAR2UqJVRQCdDio+dYFy4OQUqAUFJ JkxOJwC40w487k6pDkk5 --=-yKsNPyMU3f8KzV2ucnip-- - To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/