Message-ID: <47090708.6060604@opengridcomputing.com>
Date: Sun, 07 Oct 2007 11:19:20 -0500
From: Steve Wise <swise@opengridcomputing.com>
User-Agent: Thunderbird 2.0.0.6 (Windows/20070728)
MIME-Version: 1.0
To: Roland Dreier <rdreier@cisco.com>
CC: general@lists.openfabrics.org, linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org
Subject: Re: [ofa-general] Updated InfiniBand/RDMA merge plans for 2.6.24
References: <adaodfdkv59.fsf@cisco.com>
In-Reply-To: <adaodfdkv59.fsf@cisco.com>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1; format=flowed
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org
Content-Length: 9419
Lines: 230

No mention about the iwarp port space issue?

Here is the status of the current proposed patch:

- needs another round of changes based on Sean's feedback

- Arkady raised issues about the pain this puts on admins

- it forces services like nfs-rdma, which already separates the nfs-rdma 
server by port number, to needlessly use a separate subnet for the rdma 
service.

I'm at a loss as to how to proceed.

Any ideas?

Steve.


Roland Dreier wrote:
> Since 2.6.23 still isn't out, and I've managed to reduce my patch
> review backlog a bit, it's probably a good idea to give another update
> about what I have queued for 2.6.24 already and what I hope to get to
> before the merge window opens.
> 
> Core:
> 
>  - My user_mad P_Key index support patch.  Merged this, although I
>    still owe Sasha a patch to update libraries to use this.
> 
>  - A fix to the user_mad 32-bit big-endian userspace 64/32 problem
>    with the method_mask when registering agents.  Merged.
> 
>  - Sean's QoS changes.  Merged.
> 
>  - Sean's IB CM MRA interface changes.  I merged these -- what the
>    heck, if it breaks we can back them out.
> 
> ULPs:
> 
>  - Pradeep's IPoIB CM support for devices that don't have SRQs.  Sean
>    started reviewing but I didn't see any updated patches.
> 
>  - Moni's IPoIB bonding support.  Seems like we found a clean set of
>    changes, and these will go in via another (Jeff Garzik's?) tree.
> 
>  - Rolf's IPoIB MGID scope changes.  No review progress here.
> 
>  - Eli and Michael's IPoIB stateless offload (checksum offload, LSO,
>    LRO, etc).  Not much review progress here; I'll try to chip away at
>    the series and see what we can get into 2.6.24.
> 
>  - Or's IPoIB/userspace multicast coexistence stuff.  I think we've
>    converged on this; I'll merge this once a final version of the
>    patch appears.
> 
> HW specific:
> 
>  - I already merged patches to enable MSI-X by default for mthca and
>    mlx4.  I hope there aren't too many systems that get hosed if a
>    MSI-X interrupt is generated.
> 
>  - Jack and Michael's mlx4 FMR support.  Merged.  I guess the fix for
>    running in Xen domU may need to wait for 2.6.25, but I'll see what
>    I can do.
> 
>  - ehca patch queue.  Merged everything I think.
> 
>  - Steve's mthca router mode support.  No one looked at it, seems like
>    it's at risk of missing the window.
> 
>  - Arthur's mthca doorbell alignment fixes.  I still need to check
>    various approaches;  I'll definitely merge something for 2.6.24.
> 
>  - Michael's mlx4 WQE shrinking patch.  May miss the window and go for
>    2.6.25, I'll see if I can get to it.
> 
> Here are a few topics that I believe will not be ready in time for the
> 2.6.24 window and will need to wait for 2.6.25:
> 
>  - Multiple CQ event vector support.  I haven't seen any discussions
>    about how ULPs or userspace apps should decide which vector to use,
>    and hence no progress has been made since we deferred this during
>    the 2.6.23 merge window.
> 
>  - XRC.  Given the length of the backlog above and the fact that a
>    first draft of this code has not been posted yet, I don't see any
>    way that we could have something this major ready in time.
> 
> BOILERPLATE
> ===========
> 
> I keep patches in a git tree, available from
> 
>     git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/roland/infiniband.git
> 
> There are several branches of interest in this tree:
> 
>     for-2.6.23 - changes queued for merging into the current kernel release
>     for-2.6.24 - changes queued for the next merge window
>     for-linus  - changes I have asked Linus to pull upstream
>     for-mm     - pulled by Andrew for inclusion in -mm
> 
> I frequently rewrite history and rebase my tree, so the best way to
> track it is to keep a clone of Linus's tree around and then pull a
> fresh copy of my tree with
> 
>     git clone --reference /path/to/linus/tree \
>         git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/roland/infiniband.git
> 
> If you would like me to merge a patch, please send it to me as soon as
> it is ready.  Do NOT wait for the merge window to open; if your change
> is not strictly a fix and you send it to me after the merge window
> opens, then it will likely have to wait for the next merge window.
> Please let me know if your patch is a fix that should go into the
> current release or if it can wait for the next merge window; if it is
> a fix, please describe the severity of the issue your are fixing, so I
> can make a good judgement about which release it should go into.
> 
> Including a good changelog entry that explains what you are changing,
> why you are changing it, and how your change accomplishes your goal
> will greatly increase the chance of your patch being merged promptly.
> Getting an independent review and a Reviewed-by: line also helps a lot.
> 
> The files Documentation/SubmittingPatches and Documentation/SubmitChecklist
> in kernel source tree also have a lot of good advice that makes it
> easier for me to handle your patches.
> 
> DETAILS
> =======
> 
> Here is the complete list of patches I have in my for-2.6.24 branch:
> 
> Ali Ayoub (1):
>       IB/sa: Error handling thinko fix
> 
> Anton Blanchard (3):
>       IB/fmr_pool: Clean up some error messages in fmr_pool.c
>       IB/ehca: Make output clearer by removing some debug messages
>       IB/ehca: Export module parameters in sysfs
> 
> Dotan Barak (1):
>       mlx4_core: Use enum value GO_BIT_TIMEOUT_MSECS
> 
> Eli Cohen (2):
>       IPoIB: Fix typo to end statement with ';' instead of ','
>       IPoIB: Fix error path memory leak
> 
> Hoang-Nam Nguyen (4):
>       IB/ehca: Use remap_4k_pfn() to map firmware contexts to user space
>       IB/ehca: Fix large page HW cap defines
>       IB/ehca: Fix mem leak of firmware ctrlblock in ehca_create_srq()
>       IB/ehca: Adjust 64-bit alignment of create QP response for userspace
> 
> Jack Morgenstein (5):
>       IB/mlx4:  Display misc device information under /sys/class/infiniband/
>       mlx4_core: Support ICM tables in coherent memory
>       mlx4_core: Write MTTs from CPU instead with of WRITE_MTT FW command
>       IB/mlx4: Implement FMRs
>       mlx4_core: Increase max number of QPs per multicast group to 56
> 
> Joachim Fenkes (11):
>       IB/ehca: Refactor hvcall tracing
>       IB/ehca: Print return codes as signed decimal integers
>       IB/ehca: ehca_gen_warn() should always print
>       IB/ehca: Add check for max #SGE to create_qp()
>       IB/ehca: Path migration support
>       IB/ehca: Serialize MR alloc and MR free hvCalls
>       IB/ehca: Replace get_paca()->paca_index by the more portable raw_smp_processor_id()
>       IB/ehca: Bump version number and change its format
>       IB/umem: Add hugetlb flag to struct ib_umem
>       IB/ehca: Only use MR large pages for hugetlb regions
>       IB/ehca: Return srq_attr->max_sge in ehca_query_srq()
> 
> Michael S. Tsirkin (2):
>       mlx4_core: Enable MSI-X by default
>       IB/mthca: Enable MSI-X by default
> 
> Peter Oruba (1):
>       IB/mthca: Use PCI-X/PCI-Express read control interfaces
> 
> Ralph Campbell (1):
>       IB/core: Fix handling of multicast response failures
> 
> Roland Dreier (14):
>       IPoIB: Make sure no receives are handled when stopping device
>       IB: find_first_zero_bit() takes unsigned pointer
>       mlx4_core: Don't free special QPs in QP number bitmap
>       IB/mlx4: Use __set_data_seg() in mlx4_ib_post_recv()
>       IB/ehca: Include <linux/mutex.h> from ehca_classes.h
>       IB/mlx4: Fix up SRQ limit_watermark endianness
>       IB/iser: Remove unnecessary includes
>       mlx4_core: Change capability decoding: SRC->XRC
>       IB/umad: Add P_Key index support
>       IB/umad: Fix bit ordering and 32-on-64 problems on big endian systems
>       IB/uverbs: Make ib_uverbs_release_event_file() static
>       mlx4_core: Reserve the correct number of MTT segments
>       mlx4_core: Fix meaning of dev->caps.reserved_mtts
>       IB/mthca: Increase max number of QPs per multicast group to 56
> 
> Satyam Sharma (1):
>       IB/ehca: Misc cpuinit section annotations and #ifdef cleanups
> 
> Sean Hefty (7):
>       IPoIB: Specify Traffic Class with path record queries for QoS support
>       IB/sa: Add new QoS fields to path record
>       RDMA/cma: Add ability to specify type of service
>       RDMA/ucma: Allow user space to set service type
>       IB/srp: Add QoS support through service ID
>       IB/cm: Modify interface to send MRAs in response to duplicate messages
>       RDMA/cma: Queue IB CM MRAs to avoid unnecessary remote retries
> 
> Stefan Roscher (2):
>       IB/ehca: Small QP userspace support
>       IB/ehca: Support more than 4k QPs for userspace and kernelspace
> 
> Steve Wise (2):
>       RDMA/cxgb3: Make the iw_cxgb3 module parameters writable
>       RDMA/cma: Use neigh_event_send() to start neighbour discovery
> _______________________________________________
> general mailing list
> general@lists.openfabrics.org
> http://lists.openfabrics.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/general
> 
> To unsubscribe, please visit http://openib.org/mailman/listinfo/openib-general
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/