Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII
From: Ed Tomlinson <tomlins@cam.org>
Organization: me
To: Rik van Riel <riel@conectiva.com.br>, <linux-mm@kvack.org>
Subject: Re: [PATCH *] rmap based VM  #11a
Date: Tue, 8 Jan 2002 09:10:17 -0500
Cc: <linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org>
In-Reply-To: <Pine.LNX.4.33L.0201081045030.872-100000@imladris.surriel.com>
In-Reply-To: <Pine.LNX.4.33L.0201081045030.872-100000@imladris.surriel.com>
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7BIT
Message-Id: <20020108141020.C57801B1E0@oscar.casa.dyndns.org>
Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org

Hi,

Data point for you.  On a K6-III 400, 512M, 1G swap rmap11 with the
refill_inactive change runs  'make -j bzImage' with any oom problems.
X becomes unresponsive during the run as does a serial console - will
be interesting to see if Ingo`s scheduler helps.

Ed Tomlinson

On January 8, 2002 07:45 am, Rik van Riel wrote:
> The first maintenance release of the 11th version of the reverse
> mapping based VM is now available. It fixes agpgart_be and the
> OOM killer. Tests on diskless machines are especially appreciated.
>
> This is an attempt at making a more robust and flexible VM
> subsystem, while cleaning up a lot of code at the same time.
> The patch is available from:
>
>            http://surriel.com/patches/2.4/2.4.17-rmap-11a
> and        http://linuxvm.bkbits.net/
>
>
> My big TODO items for a next release are:
>   - fix page_launder() so it doesn't submit the whole
>     inactive_dirty list for writeout in one go
>
> rmap 11a:
>   - don't let refill_inactive() progress count for OOM    (me)
>   - after an OOM kill, wait 5 seconds for the next kill   (me)
>   - agpgart_be fix for hashed waitqueues                  (William Lee
> Irwin) rmap 11:
>   - fix stupid logic inversion bug in wakeup_kswapd()     (Andrew Morton)
>   - fix it again in the morning                           (me)
>   - add #ifdef BROKEN_PPC_PTE_ALLOC_ONE to rmap.h, it
>     seems PPC calls pte_alloc() before mem_map[] init     (me)
>   - disable the debugging code in rmap.c ... the code
>     is working and people are running benchmarks          (me)
>   - let the slab cache shrink functions return a value
>     to help prevent early OOM killing                     (Ed Tomlinson)
>   - also, don't call the OOM code if we have enough
>     free pages                                            (me)
>   - move the call to lru_cache_del into __free_pages_ok   (Ben LaHaise)
>   - replace the per-page waitqueue with a hashed
>     waitqueue, reduces size of struct page from 64
>     bytes to 52 bytes (48 bytes on non-highmem machines)  (William Lee
> Irwin) rmap 10:
>   - fix the livelock for real (yeah right), turned out
>     to be a stupid bug in page_launder_zone()             (me)
>   - to make sure the VM subsystem doesn't monopolise
>     the CPU, let kswapd and some apps sleep a bit under
>     heavy stress situations                               (me)
>   - let __GFP_HIGH allocations dig a little bit deeper
>     into the free page pool, the SCSI layer seems fragile (me)
> rmap 9:
>   - improve comments all over the place                   (Michael Cohen)
>   - don't panic if page_remove_rmap() cannot find the
>     rmap in question, it's possible that the memory was
>     PG_reserved and belonging to a driver, but the driver
>     exited and cleared the PG_reserved bit                (me)
>   - fix the VM livelock by replacing > by >= in a few
>     critical places in the pageout code                   (me)
>   - treat the reclaiming of an inactive_clean page like
>     allocating a new page, calling try_to_free_pages()
>     and/or fixup_freespace() if required                  (me)
>   - when low on memory, don't make things worse by
>     doing swapin_readahead                                (me)
> rmap 8:
>   - add ANY_ZONE to the balancing functions to improve
>     kswapd's balancing a bit                              (me)
>   - regularize some of the maximum loop bounds in
>     vmscan.c for cosmetic purposes                        (William Lee
> Irwin) - move page_address() to architecture-independent
>     code, now the removal of page->virtual is portable    (William Lee
> Irwin) - speed up free_area_init_core() by doing a single
>     pass over the pages and not using atomic ops          (William Lee
> Irwin) - documented the buddy allocator in page_alloc.c        (William Lee
> Irwin) rmap 7:
>   - clean up and document vmscan.c                        (me)
>   - reduce size of page struct, part one                  (William Lee
> Irwin) - add rmap.h for other archs (untested, not for ARM)    (me)
> rmap 6:
>   - make the active and inactive_dirty list per zone,
>     this is finally possible because we can free pages
>     based on their physical address                       (William Lee
> Irwin) - cleaned up William's code a bit                       (me)
>   - turn some defines into inlines and move those to
>     mm_inline.h (the includes are a mess ...)             (me)
>   - improve the VM balancing a bit                        (me)
>   - add back inactive_target to /proc/meminfo             (me)
> rmap 5:
>   - fixed recursive buglet, introduced by directly
>     editing the patch for making rmap 4 ;)))              (me)
> rmap 4:
>   - look at the referenced bits in page tables            (me)
> rmap 3:
>   - forgot one FASTCALL definition                        (me)
> rmap 2:
>   - teach try_to_unmap_one() about mremap()               (me)
>   - don't assign swap space to pages with buffers         (me)
>   - make the rmap.c functions FASTCALL / inline           (me)
> rmap 1:
>   - fix the swap leak in rmap 0                           (Dave McCracken)
> rmap 0:
>   - port of reverse mapping VM to 2.4.16                  (me)
>
> Rik
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/