DomainKey-Signature: a=rsa-sha1; q=dns; c=nofws;
  s=s1024; d=yahoo.com.au;
  h=Received:X-YMail-OSG:X-Yahoo-Newman-Property:From:To:Subject:Date:User-Agent:MIME-Version:Message-Id:Content-Type;
  b=dCMvl5tM/bbqnk4NaAHi1foAm1LIfRygm2ZVZhciaiQegxueSW45EmY+fPCfPbQn9xy/N0XCPpUPwqMVhk6fzY3ztYsit5DrN0WQw0Ppr6mmP3u8FJKoyvAP+YJqd4i57pV9DWPRXZLttbT+GOqoZ/E4Yj2RDiD1y9Kj9TA3TyQ=  ;
From: Nick Piggin <nickpiggin@yahoo.com.au>
To: "Molnar, Ingo" <mingo@elte.hu>, LKML <linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org>
Subject: Poor PostgreSQL scaling on Linux 2.6.25-rc5 (vs 2.6.22)
Date: Tue, 11 Mar 2008 17:49:28 +1100
User-Agent: KMail/1.9.5
MIME-Version: 1.0
Message-Id: <200803111749.29143.nickpiggin@yahoo.com.au>
Content-Type: Multipart/Mixed;
  boundary="Boundary-00=_5ti1HrafifJ9x1+"
Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org
Content-Length: 14867
Lines: 232

--Boundary-00=_5ti1HrafifJ9x1+
Content-Type: text/plain;
  charset="us-ascii"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline

Hi,

After investigating the claims of poor MySQL performance on Linux,
I had a look at postgresql with sysbench. This DBMS is even faster
than MySQL and could scale up to more connections with my (as close
as possible) out of the box compile and config. The nice thing
about PostgreSQL is that it has no noticable contention on user
space locks on this workload.

The problem with MySQL contention means that if the scheduler
unluckily chooses to deschedule a lock holder, then you can get
idle time building up on other cores and you can get context switch
cascades as things all pile up onto this heavily contended lock. As
such, it means MySQL is not an ideal candidate for looking at
performance behaviour. I discounted the relatively worse scaling of
MySQL with 2.6.25-rc (than 2.6.22) as such an effect.

PostgreSQL is different. It has zero idle time when running this
workload. It actually scaled "super linearly" on my system here,
from single threaded performance to 8 cores (giving an 8.2x
performance increase)!

So PostgreSQL performance profile is actually much more interesting.
To my dismay, I found that Linux 2.6.25-rc5 performs really badly
after saturating the runqueues and subsequently increasing threads.
2.6.22 drops a little bit, but basically settles near the peak
performance. With 2.6.25-rc5, throughput seems to be falling off
linearly with the number of threads.

Actually, this performance profile sort of matches the MySQL curve,
so while I thought the MySQL numbers may be invalid, actually it
appears to back up the pgsql numbers.

This was with postgresql 8.3; config and kernel config available on
request. Looks very much like a CPU scheduler issue. Please take a
look.

postgres.png contains 2.6.22 vs 2.6.25-rc5. compare.png contains
both of those plus MySQL on 2.6.22 vs 2.6.25-rc5.

Thanks,
Nick

--Boundary-00=_5ti1HrafifJ9x1+
Content-Type: image/png;
  name="postgres.png"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment;
	filename="postgres.png"
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--Boundary-00=_5ti1HrafifJ9x1+
Content-Type: image/png;
  name="compare.png"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Disposition: attachment;
	filename="compare.png"
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--Boundary-00=_5ti1HrafifJ9x1+--

--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/