Return-path: Received: from nexus.dynaweb.hu ([195.70.37.87]:60323 "EHLO nexus.dynaweb.hu" rhost-flags-OK-OK-OK-OK) by vger.kernel.org with ESMTP id S1751522AbYKNKQD (ORCPT ); Fri, 14 Nov 2008 05:16:03 -0500 Date: Fri, 14 Nov 2008 11:15:59 +0100 From: RUMI Szabolcs To: "Nick Kossifidis" Cc: "Johannes Berg" , "Pavel Roskin" , linux-wireless@vger.kernel.org Subject: Re: ath5k master (AP) mode Message-Id: <20081114111559.56530874.rumi_ml@rtfm.hu> (sfid-20081114_111614_780887_4CB0CC41) In-Reply-To: <40f31dec0811131507x7449112cy5746d28c848a2146@mail.gmail.com> References: <20081112224810.8d4ca179.rumi_ml@rtfm.hu> <1226530010.15173.0.camel@dv> <20081113004632.d8d821c5.rumi_ml@rtfm.hu> <20081113181155.c556bde1.rumi_ml@rtfm.hu> <1226598550.5839.3.camel@johannes.berg> <20081113235928.3ed79ff6.rumi_ml@rtfm.hu> <40f31dec0811131507x7449112cy5746d28c848a2146@mail.gmail.com> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="Multipart=_Fri__14_Nov_2008_11_15_59_+0100_r=onjtiixQVVcqQ=" Sender: linux-wireless-owner@vger.kernel.org List-ID: This is a multi-part message in MIME format. --Multipart=_Fri__14_Nov_2008_11_15_59_+0100_r=onjtiixQVVcqQ= Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit On Fri, 14 Nov 2008 01:07:04 +0200 "Nick Kossifidis" wrote: > Have you enabled AP mode on the driver ? > > diff --git a/drivers/net/wireless/ath5k/base.c > b/drivers/net/wireless/ath5k/base.c > index e09ed2c..69aad6e 100644 > --- a/drivers/net/wireless/ath5k/base.c > +++ b/drivers/net/wireless/ath5k/base.c > @@ -488,6 +488,7 @@ ath5k_pci_probe(struct pci_dev *pdev, > > hw->wiphy->interface_modes = > BIT(NL80211_IFTYPE_STATION) | > + BIT(NL80211_IFTYPE_AP) | > BIT(NL80211_IFTYPE_ADHOC) | > BIT(NL80211_IFTYPE_MESH_POINT); > > Code for AP mode is there but it's not enabled yet until we do further > tests (it didn't work on some 5413 hw etc, now after PCU updates it > should work but we still need to test it) YES, that did the trick! :) With partial success. To summarize: - Open System worked (only basic IPv4 tested, eg. ICMP ping) - MAC filtering from hostapd didn't work - WEP didn't work - WPA and WPA2 weren't tested I have attached a hostapd log (concatenated, commented, and gzipped) of my testing runs. In the end I need this to work properly as an AP with WPA2 so I'm willing to test further if somebody is willing to try to fix the whole thing... Thanks, Sab --Multipart=_Fri__14_Nov_2008_11_15_59_+0100_r=onjtiixQVVcqQ= Content-Type: application/x-gzip; name="ath5k_hostapd_081114.txt.gz" Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="ath5k_hostapd_081114.txt.gz" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 H4sICAtLHUkCA2F0aDVrX2hvc3RhcGRfMDgxMTE0LnR4dADtXelz2koS/66/ovflQ2BjsCTENbu8 egTjhIqvNWS9qVSWGqQRaC0krQ6TvNo/fnuE5NgmiY0NxIFWubi6p2f6mP7NoZGPHC/5DDyeVC/B Cp0rEcLMCYUrogjaZzD1LQGxiGLHG4Prj5XWcpeivG2fH1y0z7uKolaYWimr0I0nIvREDKbvxaHv uiJk0JY/+hF0/Ok08RyTx47vRXvQ88wytM+ruqZDQ9XLmsZHYzjpdaAQiitQtaIC2dVPRtGXKBbT e6QNzrsnB7L+QfeiZBiVsx5c5CqfdXrQtngQi/Ba7qHLxxGDURLBlKP8cA+mwnKSKVjiKhLuHrg8 Fp75BbRaA+s4/wdozevSx2Lqh1/QwmALbqt4QaGil0ZOvAee75WCUNgiNid85IoifIycP0WrZrz7 dC2gwwM+clwndgS24qNhfIIzf4Z+OuYeH4up8GJAt0WoIejXpd5JE7u5Sx0PkkiwuZ+Hgenc5UM/ J66Un3IoSs8Dm5voIh5a4ESo4QgNZMFvg7PSkeNdwuCodHFSq2pvflPw6p8eDuZOnvhRzAOrpJZr 5ariOiPPLWllTbmc15PHVimPKTv0p6CragM9W9YqUNCxoN4ohaZRmrlFZebEE7AxSPyZZA84mgp4 ELiOsJiilEol4PtzLaN9dOp+XsN+qsn+iEeibCqvXr2C0QP4/vgDSkajsVeDV/KtDvjDtdGGQeiP RCGKwwRNI3/AAIC/Bvi6p2QWncxKv8+cYPKl9LvjYaygFcVQ9qIIWtdGn1+ve4PCyREGtaYNe4eD D2fdYX/QHvROT4rwP+UV3MvdPpOM97MdvD3tPIjzuNt/Ozw77Z0Min+Tbj3vHrfP3/Wx66pMs5hq M7PGak3WNGRM+EmYhYsk15jgzLSZJliV52QT3YThiSEhOyAUnBn2Ja8oZQ/OP8ALTVFGoWONxTDg 5qWIo5am8CSeDLk7jloYDan7ZyJAEYltA3cjHyIRF5UpN7llhUNuulimtfSlKC8gi1UoWRbsYx/c z37I38uYoGylgy/OOAnnKtiOi/3o+9xmHLrDr54fh34StFTlNBCejN+Qz2CuKkR++mb72D1tx7PE Z1CV1/0+psUEbabtAX7pHciccwm2zW7/QUEFzCFRUTnkjuyZcWoYuG3OVPrlzVSgoAc8lcF7Tyac rFQSwHWTy8qhm0QT2Vjfta5dh24MMQEpB0L6B7/JpCrQIW7OEinh1HLCj7ct8InBCdaRYK+VpgNs DzIJM8akqDzKb1no6OjBu7EDBRMTPjYO7eEnGCUUS8vFUr932nnTuzhvn7zpMrjoSnsGMryKLV2X 3yPs1abAbxpGhDk0EZta6mf7RhAmgSUDI5QvkQxBxJ7LmyCjnLcH3Y/qp5SlpalgS3xFKfqcomUU /SulNqfoGaVavUup5NK0hUJGRqp9pahzSjWjNBcotVycvkCq56TGAqmRN9xYIDUzUmWxFVpuCWNR opbbonpLZMdPsGd6fpz2+IBHEfZsiEzuybiQffvS82fYZ8MQA8LQm0azVteb1cf37GMEMAa9breb DcLGOC6ZYH3CZWDgECkU/03kEIiBbuh1OH77551WXnTPZMSEXwIpsbw1aaiyXBpC2tcMdIeL0hCl IUpDq05Dt4dHnUEfcBQfY8+/ERHZ0Og2a3/ih/jqon4DZ4opI81ci6XumCEUfCpT2uLI630kdb7u SJCmQEhHJZOZ7PmwOMzmHloocix42Ts7efmMlMnydz/N2r59Qy3L9zB7H785HkBh8C+cQbruCNND Edqdd8r1RFtcoYsZmFMLY6kxUg1whYeRruAUSNpBFUwXbGQyq8lqFWyNJ5uD0y9IfRzNs8wo9Lll 4qQcZF5ZRdk785g1lJXzos3WSJqSpmvU1DCY1mT1EatXt0lTiofnqel1jd+AGBtBT5mOpzFjacFQ RAGYoyeySuAiTuJcBSeF3a/L+bMS8jbp8ixgYuuia8v8vnmI/x5r3uwq4zgrxyEuZ43m452yoWru 8f2alUmydR+c4VsoKAqE6diOCY6HcqfZao8737h2xp4fCgsKGfPp+17aRPxrpCsCteJ1sw1makwb sWad8Yc2+zm1ZS3jBjL2ljv+O5zPXL8Vpt4GMyxmc2borNZYX+pdUTX3pN7NKDNfADWr0sUjdX02 o8Hjrk9NaK3oWQxP80XYhs3q9bWgUva73JtTbmzQIcwwwFa0Fl2Sb3q31PnHOORexE1ZpKWle3pJ NDR9SyDDTMgd5X62FbgoS25IcXkP4HxH6+YOYflOc1DlwP3ymEbpIBWWW/S9bgqLavHHRpISpH0m 3LNcMUwF4rAavh2iUgfbTzyL7En2fNb2pHWuta6q7ODmEK0F02rdBodDNrMr6QzWwhnQeiaxhDeE 388cvx91GxTNCh7gtbUZ+Ck9iNZuaOOPaqE4pDRNgxWy584v3mzmVgKLNXVmqkzUmF1f30bTYyZ0 K54Mrgzm1zw5/Xen74w97oKMOFM4VxjVJYhFOHU8Lo/cP/74zVPOyRmrOyf34tZBuQUhimOb6fm2 7IDNwenFCRT+k2SWzR48UFTohB2dsKMTdnTCbldP2NGZFNKUNCVNSVPSlDQlTXdyG584iZM4iZM4 f62DrruGfTSaolvetoJ1E1t9ACdiJqVdr6F907c3VjkZ3NnnO30HBT8QHsyfKF38saTjo+MuS19L 7feDt92TQa/THnTLjmdlAgsLhfbg9Kx7Mux/6A+6xw+Xf9A96g6677of+uUsIBdFF1e9a6kuvWv5 KMOLze0GU2D8woERRb45RCWV9JOTq5Iq/T1l5AbWaChPx7bUz4augeug/7z5rtsVd1uaqlwcd7EJ UIKJ+Gwl06AgFasXGbYUqirYOqi6/Kxq+Kr8k7uOle6owrwgyw/WVlWGvOm3+EsgIPscJaNS+l2F 6we2a5isPExW7d4Bfl7CODc0lyHJHQu0+1yQ2W2ejJevS54gTuvZA26m+41S90hEqSZGUzuoHGp6 Sc2uJbpGv3/a6d3XL1bdFZ7yALMN3W/5mPHhSpT5uQ+Q2KqnYWzW/xu6H2cjyqzq9uoHHZZf223y m1VmQ48xoFuVt+Q5Hdv1dBEyNrV6KwN7mzLijZmc5UTp5ELJP/xwlh8KHvnefB5fWWL+kgtPpzAP n0T0+g+bl+xBZdVTE1oFoVWQXVsFkXeqbt8qiPbcV0EoG9+/UITwL31siTt5Q/YjefvvN+tZxiS3 bsi2wErS/4jkeDLNXDnxlyUUWiLB6uuIpW/0O9r2IVx7OK7JvJIjW/Z5ZdgGZhKGWOuQB62FkwDb vvz/1bCbgb4l0st5l8CPwI/Aj8CPwI/AbxvAr0LgR+BH4EfgR+BH4Ldr4GcQ+BH4EfgR+BH4Efjt GvhVCfwI/Aj8CPwI/Aj8dg38agR+BH4EfgR+BH4EfrsGfnUCPwI/Aj8CPwI/Ar9dA78GgR+BH4Ef gR+BH4HfroFfk8CPwI/Aj8CPwI/Ab9fAr03gR+BH4EfgR+BH4Ldr4PeawI/Aj8CPwI/Aj8Bv18Cv Q+C3DeB359HxDZvV66t/tihBLEEsQSxBLEHsMhB7QBBL80sCPwI/Aj8Cv10Dvy6BH4EfgR+BH4Ef gd+ugd8hgd8WLq6u65+MEsYSxhLGEsYSxi6BsZpKGEsTTAI/Aj8CPwK/XQM/jcBvC8Dv352+M/a4 CzInmMK5wiAoAfaoKcKT9P96sElbtR7nYupfpeEaz7vNImAfukk0kSzyX4XmbJgtQkdEysEtjAbs XzlLpCitpS8Fr8H5B3hRhUI8cSKInakAa2IGMPPDy2gPnODKmH8uKsqLUehYYzEMsE+LOEIALJj+ VP4XaXSHn8Tz1C/TeUpDPMTWJbYNd7heTLnJLSscctP9hhDFsU3fs50xpMaH92fAPQt6Z9iUOSEJ MW4fpe8LmPhosQDDx7JgX8TmfvZD/l6WVSidrJ65+W3HFewH3GYcuvMMb3NTDMehn8ihwCliuPRk yGcwtxlgr5Nvch3EsTH4xGdQldf9PqSJTOa013JVBKY8ugTbZrf/oKDCyInRF/3eaedN7+K8ffIG I/CiK20YYCutYkvX5ffIT0JT4DcNg8ccSlhCQLKVQy655MAuCSwZQ6F8idCdONKDSxF6woWpbyWu UM6xh3xUP6UsErdsl6Nn1c/6nKJlFP0rpTan6BmlWr1LqeTStIVCRkaqfaWoc0o1ozQXKLVcnL5A quekxgKpkTfcWCA1M1JlsRVabgljUaKW26J6S2THT7ATe34sDYwhgBB1hcY2uSfjgsH77P+0izDE gDD0ptGs1fVm9fFJ4BixgN3M9mOAzgTrEy4DA+AwTU6eiQMy3dDrcPz2zxshIVvZGfTlol0szPhG RFghtjy8w9qf+CG+uqjfQCYOP8gmJHdK3TEDwtZ05Iq0E9xmfB9Jna87Utb/Zw4O6yYzmTFgYbyU pga0qwUve2cnL5+RMjlyiDgJwLdvqGX5nih/b5h04YTCxcEMiCt0MQNzamEsNUaqkY6BNV05aOPk 4oDHfP+sXwp8dL8dcmyxHfrTtGE3RkrfnhR+G80etl77S5TF5PcLtZY0XUrTp8c/SSAJJIEk3IOP qmC6YCOTWU1WqyyZ0+rMNJg6YjXBuLpc2SfV+5gDLk/Zv6XRCJVdX1nKSCSBJJCEtWP9qu5dyrca H3ZelDh3gJN+/uk/f++Owl+clZINdXf6eYkbiDOsrzJuMxOBnrNGcw33Ka+2mu+E39OHPt9TiRbN t09TStSr5XyKBzdTy+Z7xBIpci3Ja13uX1+mXZsZqMmbaPIa1g42CvTky1U2eX1Kk/+2ssl0JIGO JDz8SMJaQ4QCg86q0FmVn3BWxTCqzfxhCL/AQc2FEa/JKtqzmvYuX0uDGRazOTN0Vms8sJYku3P7 SngWUqNAmI7tmOlhzHCa3a/tCnmsAZyx54cyEjLmLOg1WXWaK2pf7WowU2PaiDXrjDd/wbb83EUZ 8so2RcjWxPUKNv+ekquWqIbO2a3lnJ08eTZ42x687EP76GgPDk+P3vX/ouiq2sDhQlkz4O9hMnX+ CGN7Wp4kvyvK/wHX6YaRsRwBAA== --Multipart=_Fri__14_Nov_2008_11_15_59_+0100_r=onjtiixQVVcqQ=--