On Fri, 28 Jan 2022, Miklos Szeredi wrote:
> On Thu, 27 Jan 2022 at 03:47, NeilBrown <[email protected]> wrote:
> >
> > inode_congested() reports if the backing-device for the inode is
> > congested. Few bdi report congestion any more, only ceph, fuse, and
> > nfs. Having support just for those is unlikely to be useful.
> >
> > The places which test inode_congested() or it variants like
> > inode_write_congested(), avoid initiating IO if congestion is present.
> > We now have to rely on other places in the stack to back off, or abort
> > requests - we already do for everything except these 3 filesystems.
> >
> > So remove inode_congested() and related functions, and remove the call
> > sites, assuming that inode_congested() always returns 'false'.
>
> Looks to me this is going to "break" fuse; e.g. readahead path will go
> ahead and try to submit more requests, even if the queue is getting
> congested. In this case the readahead submission will eventually
> block, which is counterproductive.
>
> I think we should *first* make sure all call sites are substituted
> with appropriate mechanisms in the affected filesystems and as a last
> step remove the superfluous bdi congestion mechanism.
>
> You are saying that all fs except these three already have such
> mechanisms in place, right? Can you elaborate on that?
Not much. I haven't looked into how other filesystems cope, I just know
that they must because no other filesystem ever has a congested bdi
(with one or two minor exceptions, like filesystems over drbd).
Surely read-ahead should never block. If it hits congestion, the
read-ahead request should simply fail. block-based filesystems seem to
set REQ_RAHEAD which might get mapped to REQ_FAILFAST_MASK, though I
don't know how that is ultimately used.
Maybe fuse and others should continue to track 'congestion' and reject
read-ahead requests when congested.
Maybe also skip WB_SYNC_NONE writes..
Or maybe this doesn't really matter in practice... I wonder if we can
measure the usefulness of congestion.
Thanks,
NeilBrown