Most USB keys nowadays have a small LED somewhere inside of them that
lights up when they are plugged in. On a windows box, the key is lit up
whenever it is mounted, and as soon as it is unmounted it turns off,
giving a handy physical indicator that the key is safe to remove. On
linux, the light is simply on whenever the key is plugged in.
Should linux toggle the light depending on mount state? Is it as trivial
as it seems or does this reflect some larger issue?
-Casey Dahlin
On 8/24/07, Casey Dahlin <[email protected]> wrote:
> Most USB keys nowadays have a small LED somewhere inside of them that
> lights up when they are plugged in. On a windows box, the key is lit up
> whenever it is mounted, and as soon as it is unmounted it turns off,
> giving a handy physical indicator that the key is safe to remove. On
> linux, the light is simply on whenever the key is plugged in.
>
> Should linux toggle the light depending on mount state? Is it as trivial
> as it seems or does this reflect some larger issue?
I think that depends on the key. My Corsair keys have the light
flicker whenever I/O is on-going.
josh
Casey Dahlin wrote:
> Most USB keys nowadays have a small LED somewhere inside of them that
> lights up when they are plugged in. On a windows box, the key is lit up
> whenever it is mounted, and as soon as it is unmounted it turns off,
> giving a handy physical indicator that the key is safe to remove. On
> linux, the light is simply on whenever the key is plugged in.
>
> Should linux toggle the light depending on mount state? Is it as trivial
> as it seems or does this reflect some larger issue?
I think that Windows turns off power to the port when you do the "safely
remove hardware" on it, or something like that. Mount/unmount doesn't
really indicate whether the device is in use in Linux, though, since it
can still be potentially accessed even when the device isn't mounted.
--
Robert Hancock Saskatoon, SK, Canada
To email, remove "nospam" from [email protected]
Home Page: http://www.roberthancock.com/
Robert Hancock wrote:
> Casey Dahlin wrote:
>> Most USB keys nowadays have a small LED somewhere inside of them that
>> lights up when they are plugged in. On a windows box, the key is lit
>> up whenever it is mounted, and as soon as it is unmounted it turns
>> off, giving a handy physical indicator that the key is safe to remove.
>> On linux, the light is simply on whenever the key is plugged in.
>>
>> Should linux toggle the light depending on mount state? Is it as
>> trivial as it seems or does this reflect some larger issue?
>
> I think that Windows turns off power to the port when you do the "safely
> remove hardware" on it, or something like that. Mount/unmount doesn't
> really indicate whether the device is in use in Linux, though, since it
> can still be potentially accessed even when the device isn't mounted.
If there is a way to toggle the power state from userspace, then a
desktop environment or userland tool can emulate the Windows behavior if
that is desired. A lot of devices can charge via USB now, and this is
actually more convenient on Linux than on Windows (in effect Windows
requires drivers in order to charge something). However, having direct
control over this is useful.
According to the following thread, it appears one can get the needed
functionality through libusb:
http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg19131.html
http://www.gniibe.org/ac-power-by-usb/ac-power-control.html
- Jim
25/08/07 12:49, James Bruce wrote/a ?crit:
> Robert Hancock wrote:
>> Casey Dahlin wrote:
>>> Most USB keys nowadays have a small LED somewhere inside of them that
>>> lights up when they are plugged in. On a windows box, the key is lit
>>> up whenever it is mounted, and as soon as it is unmounted it turns
>>> off, giving a handy physical indicator that the key is safe to
>>> remove. On linux, the light is simply on whenever the key is plugged in.
>>>
>>> Should linux toggle the light depending on mount state? Is it as
>>> trivial as it seems or does this reflect some larger issue?
>>
>> I think that Windows turns off power to the port when you do the
>> "safely remove hardware" on it, or something like that. Mount/unmount
>> doesn't really indicate whether the device is in use in Linux, though,
>> since it can still be potentially accessed even when the device isn't
>> mounted.
>
> If there is a way to toggle the power state from userspace, then a
> desktop environment or userland tool can emulate the Windows behavior if
> that is desired. A lot of devices can charge via USB now, and this is
> actually more convenient on Linux than on Windows (in effect Windows
> requires drivers in order to charge something). However, having direct
> control over this is useful.
Yes, maybe some userspace such as HAL could turn off the usb devices at
the same time it's unmounted. Actually that would be rather intuitive
way to tell the user the umount is finished. There doesn't seem to be
any loss of funcitonality, once it's turned off you can still re-access
the device, and it's automatically turned on again (at least on my PC).
For the record, here is how one can switch off a usb device (as root):
# cd /sys/bus/usb/devices/usb*/[0-9]-[0-9] (just go to the directory of
the device)
# echo -n 2 > *:1.0/power/state
# echo -n 2 > power/state
I use this to turn off my optical mouse when watching movies, but it
works fine as well to turn off usb storage devices.
It can also be turned on with
# echo -n 0 > power/state
See you,
Eric
On Fri, 24 Aug 2007, Josh Boyer wrote:
> On 8/24/07, Casey Dahlin <[email protected]> wrote:
> > Most USB keys nowadays have a small LED somewhere inside of them that
> > lights up when they are plugged in. On a windows box, the key is lit up
> > whenever it is mounted, and as soon as it is unmounted it turns off,
> > giving a handy physical indicator that the key is safe to remove. On
> > linux, the light is simply on whenever the key is plugged in.
> >
> > Should linux toggle the light depending on mount state? Is it as trivial
> > as it seems or does this reflect some larger issue?
>
> I think that depends on the key. My Corsair keys have the light
> flicker whenever I/O is on-going.
Yeah, it does, I am not a big expert in USB storage, and I haven't seen
many USB sticks, but I might imagine how windows turns the LED off on
unmount. Try "eject /dev/sdX", where sdX is your USB storage, after you
unmount it. Be careful, especially if you have SATA (or SCSI) discs in
your system or if you use libata for PATA discs not to eject the wrong
one... For example, if you think you have to eject /dev/sdc, check before
ejecting it with "mount" if there are any /dev/sdc* partitions mounted.
As for LED going on only when mounting, don't know. Maybe they also issue
eject after initial enumeration? In which case the LED would go shortly on
on plug in, then off, then on again on mount. You can try it under Linux
too, if you issue eject after plugging in but before mount. I think, you
won't be able to mount it directly after ejecting, you'd have to force
re-enumeration under Linux.
Thanks
Guennadi
---
Guennadi Liakhovetski
Guennadi Liakhovetski wrote:
> I might imagine how windows turns the LED off on
> unmount. Try "eject /dev/sdX", where sdX is your USB storage, after you
> unmount it. Be careful, especially if you have SATA (or SCSI) discs in
> your system or if you use libata for PATA discs not to eject the wrong
> one...
If there is only one USB disk connected:
# eject /dev/disk/by-path/*usb*:0
Provided you let udev create links for you. BTW, the /dev/disk/by-id/
symlinks are nice for static mount points in /etc/fstab.
After a disk was mounted, eject also accepts the mountpoint as parameter
and will unmount the disk before it tries to eject it.
--
Stefan Richter
-=====-=-=== =--- ==-=-
http://arcgraph.de/sr/
On Sat, 25 Aug 2007 21:26:09 +0200 (CEST), Guennadi Liakhovetski
<[email protected]> wrote:
> On Fri, 24 Aug 2007, Josh Boyer wrote:
>
>> On 8/24/07, Casey Dahlin <[email protected]> wrote:
>> > Most USB keys nowadays have a small LED somewhere inside of them that
>> > lights up when they are plugged in. On a windows box, the key is lit
> up
>> > whenever it is mounted, and as soon as it is unmounted it turns off,
>> > giving a handy physical indicator that the key is safe to remove. On
>> > linux, the light is simply on whenever the key is plugged in.
Windows powers off the USB device on unmount, whereas linus does not.
I think the problem may lie in HAL.
Xav
Sorry to have left this dormant for so long.
Running eject in either of the ways suggested still leaves the light on
my particular key turned on.
Stefan Richter wrote:
> Guennadi Liakhovetski wrote:
>
>> I might imagine how windows turns the LED off on
>> unmount. Try "eject /dev/sdX", where sdX is your USB storage, after you
>> unmount it. Be careful, especially if you have SATA (or SCSI) discs in
>> your system or if you use libata for PATA discs not to eject the wrong
>> one...
>>
>
> If there is only one USB disk connected:
> # eject /dev/disk/by-path/*usb*:0
>
> Provided you let udev create links for you. BTW, the /dev/disk/by-id/
> symlinks are nice for static mount points in /etc/fstab.
>
> After a disk was mounted, eject also accepts the mountpoint as parameter
> and will unmount the disk before it tries to eject it.
>