Tejun Heo wrote:
> Bill Davidsen wrote:
>
>> Gwendal Grignou wrote:
>>
>>> About ata1:0 problem, as reported in the bugzilla bug: I would try to
>>> disable NCQ to see if it helps. Your disks firmware might not fully
>>> support it.
>>>
>>> You can either add the parameter "libata.force=noncq" when loading
>>> your kernel, or set queue_depth to 1 for all the Seagate drives behind
>>> the Marvell MV88SX6081 controller.
>>>
>>> About ata5:0 , someone - in user space probably - is trying to do a
>>> SMART ENABLE operation, but the device ignores it. I don't know which
>>> device you are using, but I assume it does not support ATA SMART
>>> feature set. Timeout is an acceptable but not a nice way to answer, a
>>> cancel would have been better; check if there is a firmware upgrade
>>> for your device.
>>>
>>>
>> You certainly called the SMART issue, I was wondering why a new
>> distribution install on some older hardware was getting all the errors,
>> clearly the Fedora "smartd" doesn't check SMART capability before trying
>> to enable the feature. Oddly the drive on which I see this does reply to
>> SMART requests, so the firmware must be "semi-functional." Not a
>> problem, in my case the drive is just used for testing handling of hot
>> swap, and has no data of any value.
>>
>
> Can you post full kernel log including the boot messages and the error
> messages? Also, please attach the output of hdparm -I on the drive
> which fails the smart command.
>
Belatedly, the drive was retired after I got thinking about it, I'm just
calling it an old bad drive and leaving it at that. I'm not goinf to
re-install a dubious 20GB drive, it's out of the hot-swap carrier,
cleared with dban, and in the recycle bin. You seem to have far better
examples of the issue, so I don't feel I would hold up progress. :-)
> (cc'ing Bruce, hi!) Bruce, this is the second report I see about drive
> timing out SMART ENABLE OPERATIONS. Does anything ring a bell?
>
> Thanks.
>
>
--
Bill Davidsen <[email protected]>
"Woe unto the statesman who makes war without a reason that will still
be valid when the war is over..." Otto von Bismark