2022-07-20 08:49:24

by Tiezhu Yang

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: [PATCH v2] LoongArch: Remove LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 and some CSR definitions

According to the configuration information accessible by the CPUCFG
instruction [1] and the Overview of Control and Status Registers [2],
we can not see the descriptions about LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 (0x30),
LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID (0xc0), LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* (0xc0 ~ 0xff) and
LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* (0x100 ~ 0x109), they are not used in the
current kernel code.

LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 may be used only in the firmware layer, it should
not be used in the future for kernel developers, remove the related
LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 definitions.

LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* is shadow of LOONGARCH_CPUCFG*, no need to access
LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* and LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID through CSR instruction,
use CPUCFG instruction to access LOONGARCH_CPUCFG* is enough, so also
remove LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* and LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID definitions.

LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* may be not implemented in hardware, use CSR
instruction to access them is meaningless, so also remove the related
LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* definitions.

The intention of this patch is to keep consistent between the code and
the manual.

[1] https://loongson.github.io/LoongArch-Documentation/LoongArch-Vol1-EN.html#the-configuration-information-accessible-by-the-cpucfg-instruction
[2] https://loongson.github.io/LoongArch-Documentation/LoongArch-Vol1-EN.html#table-overview-of-control-and-status-registers

Signed-off-by: Tiezhu Yang <[email protected]>
---

v2:
-- Remove LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID and LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN*
-- Modify the patch subject and update the commit message

arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h | 229 ---------------------------------
1 file changed, 229 deletions(-)

diff --git a/arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h b/arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h
index 3ba4f7e..43755f9 100644
--- a/arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h
+++ b/arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h
@@ -218,12 +218,6 @@ static inline u32 read_cpucfg(u32 reg)
#define CPUCFG20_L3_SETS 16
#define CPUCFG20_L3_SIZE 24

-#define LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 0x30
-#define CPUCFG48_MCSR_LCK BIT(0)
-#define CPUCFG48_NAP_EN BIT(1)
-#define CPUCFG48_VFPU_CG BIT(2)
-#define CPUCFG48_RAM_CG BIT(3)
-
#ifndef __ASSEMBLY__

/* CSR */
@@ -728,229 +722,6 @@ static __always_inline void iocsr_write64(u64 val, u32 reg)

#define LOONGARCH_CSR_CTAG 0x98 /* TagLo + TagHi */

-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID 0xc0
-
-/* Shadow MCSR : 0xc0 ~ 0xff */
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR0 0xc0 /* CPUCFG0 and CPUCFG1 */
-#define MCSR0_INT_IMPL_SHIFT 58
-#define MCSR0_INT_IMPL 0
-#define MCSR0_IOCSR_BRD_SHIFT 57
-#define MCSR0_IOCSR_BRD (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_IOCSR_BRD_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR0_HUGEPG_SHIFT 56
-#define MCSR0_HUGEPG (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_HUGEPG_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR0_RPLMTLB_SHIFT 55
-#define MCSR0_RPLMTLB (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_RPLMTLB_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR0_EP_SHIFT 54
-#define MCSR0_EP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_EP_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR0_RI_SHIFT 53
-#define MCSR0_RI (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_RI_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR0_UAL_SHIFT 52
-#define MCSR0_UAL (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_UAL_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR0_VABIT_SHIFT 44
-#define MCSR0_VABIT_WIDTH 8
-#define MCSR0_VABIT (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR0_VABIT_SHIFT)
-#define VABIT_DEFAULT 0x2f
-#define MCSR0_PABIT_SHIFT 36
-#define MCSR0_PABIT_WIDTH 8
-#define MCSR0_PABIT (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR0_PABIT_SHIFT)
-#define PABIT_DEFAULT 0x2f
-#define MCSR0_IOCSR_SHIFT 35
-#define MCSR0_IOCSR (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_IOCSR_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR0_PAGING_SHIFT 34
-#define MCSR0_PAGING (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_PAGING_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR0_GR64_SHIFT 33
-#define MCSR0_GR64 (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_GR64_SHIFT)
-#define GR64_DEFAULT 1
-#define MCSR0_GR32_SHIFT 32
-#define MCSR0_GR32 (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_GR32_SHIFT)
-#define GR32_DEFAULT 0
-#define MCSR0_PRID_WIDTH 32
-#define MCSR0_PRID 0x14C010
-
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR1 0xc1 /* CPUCFG2 and CPUCFG3 */
-#define MCSR1_HPFOLD_SHIFT 43
-#define MCSR1_HPFOLD (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_HPFOLD_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_SPW_LVL_SHIFT 40
-#define MCSR1_SPW_LVL_WIDTH 3
-#define MCSR1_SPW_LVL (_ULCAST_(7) << MCSR1_SPW_LVL_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_ICACHET_SHIFT 39
-#define MCSR1_ICACHET (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_ICACHET_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_ITLBT_SHIFT 38
-#define MCSR1_ITLBT (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_ITLBT_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_LLDBAR_SHIFT 37
-#define MCSR1_LLDBAR (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LLDBAR_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_SCDLY_SHIFT 36
-#define MCSR1_SCDLY (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_SCDLY_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_LLEXC_SHIFT 35
-#define MCSR1_LLEXC (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LLEXC_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_UCACC_SHIFT 34
-#define MCSR1_UCACC (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_UCACC_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_SFB_SHIFT 33
-#define MCSR1_SFB (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_SFB_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_CCDMA_SHIFT 32
-#define MCSR1_CCDMA (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_CCDMA_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_LAMO_SHIFT 22
-#define MCSR1_LAMO (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LAMO_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_LSPW_SHIFT 21
-#define MCSR1_LSPW (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LSPW_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_MIPSBT_SHIFT 20
-#define MCSR1_MIPSBT (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_MIPSBT_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_ARMBT_SHIFT 19
-#define MCSR1_ARMBT (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_ARMBT_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_X86BT_SHIFT 18
-#define MCSR1_X86BT (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_X86BT_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_LLFTPVERS_SHIFT 15
-#define MCSR1_LLFTPVERS_WIDTH 3
-#define MCSR1_LLFTPVERS (_ULCAST_(7) << MCSR1_LLFTPVERS_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_LLFTP_SHIFT 14
-#define MCSR1_LLFTP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LLFTP_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_VZVERS_SHIFT 11
-#define MCSR1_VZVERS_WIDTH 3
-#define MCSR1_VZVERS (_ULCAST_(7) << MCSR1_VZVERS_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_VZ_SHIFT 10
-#define MCSR1_VZ (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_VZ_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_CRYPTO_SHIFT 9
-#define MCSR1_CRYPTO (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_CRYPTO_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_COMPLEX_SHIFT 8
-#define MCSR1_COMPLEX (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_COMPLEX_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_LASX_SHIFT 7
-#define MCSR1_LASX (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LASX_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_LSX_SHIFT 6
-#define MCSR1_LSX (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LSX_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_FPVERS_SHIFT 3
-#define MCSR1_FPVERS_WIDTH 3
-#define MCSR1_FPVERS (_ULCAST_(7) << MCSR1_FPVERS_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_FPDP_SHIFT 2
-#define MCSR1_FPDP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_FPDP_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_FPSP_SHIFT 1
-#define MCSR1_FPSP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_FPSP_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR1_FP_SHIFT 0
-#define MCSR1_FP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_FP_SHIFT)
-
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR2 0xc2 /* CPUCFG4 and CPUCFG5 */
-#define MCSR2_CCDIV_SHIFT 48
-#define MCSR2_CCDIV_WIDTH 16
-#define MCSR2_CCDIV (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR2_CCDIV_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR2_CCMUL_SHIFT 32
-#define MCSR2_CCMUL_WIDTH 16
-#define MCSR2_CCMUL (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR2_CCMUL_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR2_CCFREQ_WIDTH 32
-#define MCSR2_CCFREQ (_ULCAST_(0xffffffff))
-#define CCFREQ_DEFAULT 0x5f5e100 /* 100MHz */
-
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR3 0xc3 /* CPUCFG6 */
-#define MCSR3_UPM_SHIFT 14
-#define MCSR3_UPM (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR3_UPM_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR3_PMBITS_SHIFT 8
-#define MCSR3_PMBITS_WIDTH 6
-#define MCSR3_PMBITS (_ULCAST_(0x3f) << MCSR3_PMBITS_SHIFT)
-#define PMBITS_DEFAULT 0x40
-#define MCSR3_PMNUM_SHIFT 4
-#define MCSR3_PMNUM_WIDTH 4
-#define MCSR3_PMNUM (_ULCAST_(0xf) << MCSR3_PMNUM_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR3_PAMVER_SHIFT 1
-#define MCSR3_PAMVER_WIDTH 3
-#define MCSR3_PAMVER (_ULCAST_(0x7) << MCSR3_PAMVER_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR3_PMP_SHIFT 0
-#define MCSR3_PMP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR3_PMP_SHIFT)
-
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR8 0xc8 /* CPUCFG16 and CPUCFG17 */
-#define MCSR8_L1I_SIZE_SHIFT 56
-#define MCSR8_L1I_SIZE_WIDTH 7
-#define MCSR8_L1I_SIZE (_ULCAST_(0x7f) << MCSR8_L1I_SIZE_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L1I_IDX_SHIFT 48
-#define MCSR8_L1I_IDX_WIDTH 8
-#define MCSR8_L1I_IDX (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR8_L1I_IDX_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L1I_WAY_SHIFT 32
-#define MCSR8_L1I_WAY_WIDTH 16
-#define MCSR8_L1I_WAY (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR8_L1I_WAY_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L3DINCL_SHIFT 16
-#define MCSR8_L3DINCL (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3DINCL_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L3DPRIV_SHIFT 15
-#define MCSR8_L3DPRIV (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3DPRIV_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L3DPRE_SHIFT 14
-#define MCSR8_L3DPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3DPRE_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L3IUINCL_SHIFT 13
-#define MCSR8_L3IUINCL (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3IUINCL_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L3IUPRIV_SHIFT 12
-#define MCSR8_L3IUPRIV (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3IUPRIV_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L3IUUNIFY_SHIFT 11
-#define MCSR8_L3IUUNIFY (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3IUUNIFY_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L3IUPRE_SHIFT 10
-#define MCSR8_L3IUPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3IUPRE_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L2DINCL_SHIFT 9
-#define MCSR8_L2DINCL (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2DINCL_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L2DPRIV_SHIFT 8
-#define MCSR8_L2DPRIV (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2DPRIV_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L2DPRE_SHIFT 7
-#define MCSR8_L2DPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2DPRE_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L2IUINCL_SHIFT 6
-#define MCSR8_L2IUINCL (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2IUINCL_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L2IUPRIV_SHIFT 5
-#define MCSR8_L2IUPRIV (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2IUPRIV_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L2IUUNIFY_SHIFT 4
-#define MCSR8_L2IUUNIFY (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2IUUNIFY_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L2IUPRE_SHIFT 3
-#define MCSR8_L2IUPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2IUPRE_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L1DPRE_SHIFT 2
-#define MCSR8_L1DPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L1DPRE_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L1IUUNIFY_SHIFT 1
-#define MCSR8_L1IUUNIFY (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L1IUUNIFY_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR8_L1IUPRE_SHIFT 0
-#define MCSR8_L1IUPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L1IUPRE_SHIFT)
-
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR9 0xc9 /* CPUCFG18 and CPUCFG19 */
-#define MCSR9_L2U_SIZE_SHIFT 56
-#define MCSR9_L2U_SIZE_WIDTH 7
-#define MCSR9_L2U_SIZE (_ULCAST_(0x7f) << MCSR9_L2U_SIZE_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR9_L2U_IDX_SHIFT 48
-#define MCSR9_L2U_IDX_WIDTH 8
-#define MCSR9_L2U_IDX (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR9_IDX_LOG_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR9_L2U_WAY_SHIFT 32
-#define MCSR9_L2U_WAY_WIDTH 16
-#define MCSR9_L2U_WAY (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR9_L2U_WAY_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR9_L1D_SIZE_SHIFT 24
-#define MCSR9_L1D_SIZE_WIDTH 7
-#define MCSR9_L1D_SIZE (_ULCAST_(0x7f) << MCSR9_L1D_SIZE_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR9_L1D_IDX_SHIFT 16
-#define MCSR9_L1D_IDX_WIDTH 8
-#define MCSR9_L1D_IDX (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR9_L1D_IDX_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR9_L1D_WAY_SHIFT 0
-#define MCSR9_L1D_WAY_WIDTH 16
-#define MCSR9_L1D_WAY (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR9_L1D_WAY_SHIFT)
-
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR10 0xca /* CPUCFG20 */
-#define MCSR10_L3U_SIZE_SHIFT 24
-#define MCSR10_L3U_SIZE_WIDTH 7
-#define MCSR10_L3U_SIZE (_ULCAST_(0x7f) << MCSR10_L3U_SIZE_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR10_L3U_IDX_SHIFT 16
-#define MCSR10_L3U_IDX_WIDTH 8
-#define MCSR10_L3U_IDX (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR10_L3U_IDX_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR10_L3U_WAY_SHIFT 0
-#define MCSR10_L3U_WAY_WIDTH 16
-#define MCSR10_L3U_WAY (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR10_L3U_WAY_SHIFT)
-
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR24 0xf0 /* cpucfg48 */
-#define MCSR24_RAMCG_SHIFT 3
-#define MCSR24_RAMCG (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR24_RAMCG_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR24_VFPUCG_SHIFT 2
-#define MCSR24_VFPUCG (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR24_VFPUCG_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR24_NAPEN_SHIFT 1
-#define MCSR24_NAPEN (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR24_NAPEN_SHIFT)
-#define MCSR24_MCSRLOCK_SHIFT 0
-#define MCSR24_MCSRLOCK (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR24_MCSRLOCK_SHIFT)
-
-/* Uncached accelerate windows registers */
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN 0x100
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN0_LO 0x102
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN0_HI 0x103
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN1_LO 0x104
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN1_HI 0x105
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN2_LO 0x106
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN2_HI 0x107
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN3_LO 0x108
-#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN3_HI 0x109
-
/* Direct Map windows registers */
#define LOONGARCH_CSR_DMWIN0 0x180 /* 64 direct map win0: MEM & IF */
#define LOONGARCH_CSR_DMWIN1 0x181 /* 64 direct map win1: MEM & IF */
--
2.1.0


2022-07-22 07:02:36

by Tiezhu Yang

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: Re: [PATCH v2] LoongArch: Remove LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 and some CSR definitions



On 07/20/2022 04:32 PM, Tiezhu Yang wrote:
> According to the configuration information accessible by the CPUCFG
> instruction [1] and the Overview of Control and Status Registers [2],
> we can not see the descriptions about LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 (0x30),
> LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID (0xc0), LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* (0xc0 ~ 0xff) and
> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* (0x100 ~ 0x109), they are not used in the
> current kernel code.
>
> LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 may be used only in the firmware layer, it should
> not be used in the future for kernel developers, remove the related
> LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 definitions.
>
> LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* is shadow of LOONGARCH_CPUCFG*, no need to access
> LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* and LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID through CSR instruction,
> use CPUCFG instruction to access LOONGARCH_CPUCFG* is enough, so also
> remove LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* and LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID definitions.
>
> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* may be not implemented in hardware, use CSR
> instruction to access them is meaningless, so also remove the related
> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* definitions.
>
> The intention of this patch is to keep consistent between the code and
> the manual.
>
> [1] https://loongson.github.io/LoongArch-Documentation/LoongArch-Vol1-EN.html#the-configuration-information-accessible-by-the-cpucfg-instruction
> [2] https://loongson.github.io/LoongArch-Documentation/LoongArch-Vol1-EN.html#table-overview-of-control-and-status-registers
>
> Signed-off-by: Tiezhu Yang <[email protected]>
> ---
>
> v2:
> -- Remove LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID and LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN*
> -- Modify the patch subject and update the commit message
>
> arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h | 229 ---------------------------------
> 1 file changed, 229 deletions(-)
>
> diff --git a/arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h b/arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h
> index 3ba4f7e..43755f9 100644
> --- a/arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h
> +++ b/arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h
> @@ -218,12 +218,6 @@ static inline u32 read_cpucfg(u32 reg)
> #define CPUCFG20_L3_SETS 16
> #define CPUCFG20_L3_SIZE 24
>
> -#define LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 0x30
> -#define CPUCFG48_MCSR_LCK BIT(0)
> -#define CPUCFG48_NAP_EN BIT(1)
> -#define CPUCFG48_VFPU_CG BIT(2)
> -#define CPUCFG48_RAM_CG BIT(3)
> -
> #ifndef __ASSEMBLY__
>
> /* CSR */
> @@ -728,229 +722,6 @@ static __always_inline void iocsr_write64(u64 val, u32 reg)
>
> #define LOONGARCH_CSR_CTAG 0x98 /* TagLo + TagHi */
>
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID 0xc0
> -
> -/* Shadow MCSR : 0xc0 ~ 0xff */
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR0 0xc0 /* CPUCFG0 and CPUCFG1 */
> -#define MCSR0_INT_IMPL_SHIFT 58
> -#define MCSR0_INT_IMPL 0
> -#define MCSR0_IOCSR_BRD_SHIFT 57
> -#define MCSR0_IOCSR_BRD (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_IOCSR_BRD_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR0_HUGEPG_SHIFT 56
> -#define MCSR0_HUGEPG (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_HUGEPG_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR0_RPLMTLB_SHIFT 55
> -#define MCSR0_RPLMTLB (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_RPLMTLB_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR0_EP_SHIFT 54
> -#define MCSR0_EP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_EP_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR0_RI_SHIFT 53
> -#define MCSR0_RI (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_RI_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR0_UAL_SHIFT 52
> -#define MCSR0_UAL (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_UAL_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR0_VABIT_SHIFT 44
> -#define MCSR0_VABIT_WIDTH 8
> -#define MCSR0_VABIT (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR0_VABIT_SHIFT)
> -#define VABIT_DEFAULT 0x2f
> -#define MCSR0_PABIT_SHIFT 36
> -#define MCSR0_PABIT_WIDTH 8
> -#define MCSR0_PABIT (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR0_PABIT_SHIFT)
> -#define PABIT_DEFAULT 0x2f
> -#define MCSR0_IOCSR_SHIFT 35
> -#define MCSR0_IOCSR (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_IOCSR_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR0_PAGING_SHIFT 34
> -#define MCSR0_PAGING (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_PAGING_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR0_GR64_SHIFT 33
> -#define MCSR0_GR64 (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_GR64_SHIFT)
> -#define GR64_DEFAULT 1
> -#define MCSR0_GR32_SHIFT 32
> -#define MCSR0_GR32 (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR0_GR32_SHIFT)
> -#define GR32_DEFAULT 0
> -#define MCSR0_PRID_WIDTH 32
> -#define MCSR0_PRID 0x14C010
> -
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR1 0xc1 /* CPUCFG2 and CPUCFG3 */
> -#define MCSR1_HPFOLD_SHIFT 43
> -#define MCSR1_HPFOLD (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_HPFOLD_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_SPW_LVL_SHIFT 40
> -#define MCSR1_SPW_LVL_WIDTH 3
> -#define MCSR1_SPW_LVL (_ULCAST_(7) << MCSR1_SPW_LVL_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_ICACHET_SHIFT 39
> -#define MCSR1_ICACHET (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_ICACHET_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_ITLBT_SHIFT 38
> -#define MCSR1_ITLBT (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_ITLBT_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_LLDBAR_SHIFT 37
> -#define MCSR1_LLDBAR (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LLDBAR_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_SCDLY_SHIFT 36
> -#define MCSR1_SCDLY (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_SCDLY_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_LLEXC_SHIFT 35
> -#define MCSR1_LLEXC (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LLEXC_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_UCACC_SHIFT 34
> -#define MCSR1_UCACC (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_UCACC_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_SFB_SHIFT 33
> -#define MCSR1_SFB (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_SFB_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_CCDMA_SHIFT 32
> -#define MCSR1_CCDMA (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_CCDMA_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_LAMO_SHIFT 22
> -#define MCSR1_LAMO (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LAMO_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_LSPW_SHIFT 21
> -#define MCSR1_LSPW (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LSPW_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_MIPSBT_SHIFT 20
> -#define MCSR1_MIPSBT (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_MIPSBT_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_ARMBT_SHIFT 19
> -#define MCSR1_ARMBT (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_ARMBT_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_X86BT_SHIFT 18
> -#define MCSR1_X86BT (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_X86BT_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_LLFTPVERS_SHIFT 15
> -#define MCSR1_LLFTPVERS_WIDTH 3
> -#define MCSR1_LLFTPVERS (_ULCAST_(7) << MCSR1_LLFTPVERS_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_LLFTP_SHIFT 14
> -#define MCSR1_LLFTP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LLFTP_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_VZVERS_SHIFT 11
> -#define MCSR1_VZVERS_WIDTH 3
> -#define MCSR1_VZVERS (_ULCAST_(7) << MCSR1_VZVERS_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_VZ_SHIFT 10
> -#define MCSR1_VZ (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_VZ_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_CRYPTO_SHIFT 9
> -#define MCSR1_CRYPTO (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_CRYPTO_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_COMPLEX_SHIFT 8
> -#define MCSR1_COMPLEX (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_COMPLEX_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_LASX_SHIFT 7
> -#define MCSR1_LASX (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LASX_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_LSX_SHIFT 6
> -#define MCSR1_LSX (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_LSX_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_FPVERS_SHIFT 3
> -#define MCSR1_FPVERS_WIDTH 3
> -#define MCSR1_FPVERS (_ULCAST_(7) << MCSR1_FPVERS_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_FPDP_SHIFT 2
> -#define MCSR1_FPDP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_FPDP_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_FPSP_SHIFT 1
> -#define MCSR1_FPSP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_FPSP_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR1_FP_SHIFT 0
> -#define MCSR1_FP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR1_FP_SHIFT)
> -
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR2 0xc2 /* CPUCFG4 and CPUCFG5 */
> -#define MCSR2_CCDIV_SHIFT 48
> -#define MCSR2_CCDIV_WIDTH 16
> -#define MCSR2_CCDIV (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR2_CCDIV_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR2_CCMUL_SHIFT 32
> -#define MCSR2_CCMUL_WIDTH 16
> -#define MCSR2_CCMUL (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR2_CCMUL_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR2_CCFREQ_WIDTH 32
> -#define MCSR2_CCFREQ (_ULCAST_(0xffffffff))
> -#define CCFREQ_DEFAULT 0x5f5e100 /* 100MHz */
> -
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR3 0xc3 /* CPUCFG6 */
> -#define MCSR3_UPM_SHIFT 14
> -#define MCSR3_UPM (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR3_UPM_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR3_PMBITS_SHIFT 8
> -#define MCSR3_PMBITS_WIDTH 6
> -#define MCSR3_PMBITS (_ULCAST_(0x3f) << MCSR3_PMBITS_SHIFT)
> -#define PMBITS_DEFAULT 0x40
> -#define MCSR3_PMNUM_SHIFT 4
> -#define MCSR3_PMNUM_WIDTH 4
> -#define MCSR3_PMNUM (_ULCAST_(0xf) << MCSR3_PMNUM_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR3_PAMVER_SHIFT 1
> -#define MCSR3_PAMVER_WIDTH 3
> -#define MCSR3_PAMVER (_ULCAST_(0x7) << MCSR3_PAMVER_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR3_PMP_SHIFT 0
> -#define MCSR3_PMP (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR3_PMP_SHIFT)
> -
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR8 0xc8 /* CPUCFG16 and CPUCFG17 */
> -#define MCSR8_L1I_SIZE_SHIFT 56
> -#define MCSR8_L1I_SIZE_WIDTH 7
> -#define MCSR8_L1I_SIZE (_ULCAST_(0x7f) << MCSR8_L1I_SIZE_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L1I_IDX_SHIFT 48
> -#define MCSR8_L1I_IDX_WIDTH 8
> -#define MCSR8_L1I_IDX (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR8_L1I_IDX_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L1I_WAY_SHIFT 32
> -#define MCSR8_L1I_WAY_WIDTH 16
> -#define MCSR8_L1I_WAY (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR8_L1I_WAY_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L3DINCL_SHIFT 16
> -#define MCSR8_L3DINCL (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3DINCL_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L3DPRIV_SHIFT 15
> -#define MCSR8_L3DPRIV (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3DPRIV_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L3DPRE_SHIFT 14
> -#define MCSR8_L3DPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3DPRE_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L3IUINCL_SHIFT 13
> -#define MCSR8_L3IUINCL (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3IUINCL_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L3IUPRIV_SHIFT 12
> -#define MCSR8_L3IUPRIV (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3IUPRIV_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L3IUUNIFY_SHIFT 11
> -#define MCSR8_L3IUUNIFY (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3IUUNIFY_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L3IUPRE_SHIFT 10
> -#define MCSR8_L3IUPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L3IUPRE_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L2DINCL_SHIFT 9
> -#define MCSR8_L2DINCL (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2DINCL_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L2DPRIV_SHIFT 8
> -#define MCSR8_L2DPRIV (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2DPRIV_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L2DPRE_SHIFT 7
> -#define MCSR8_L2DPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2DPRE_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L2IUINCL_SHIFT 6
> -#define MCSR8_L2IUINCL (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2IUINCL_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L2IUPRIV_SHIFT 5
> -#define MCSR8_L2IUPRIV (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2IUPRIV_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L2IUUNIFY_SHIFT 4
> -#define MCSR8_L2IUUNIFY (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2IUUNIFY_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L2IUPRE_SHIFT 3
> -#define MCSR8_L2IUPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L2IUPRE_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L1DPRE_SHIFT 2
> -#define MCSR8_L1DPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L1DPRE_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L1IUUNIFY_SHIFT 1
> -#define MCSR8_L1IUUNIFY (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L1IUUNIFY_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR8_L1IUPRE_SHIFT 0
> -#define MCSR8_L1IUPRE (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR8_L1IUPRE_SHIFT)
> -
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR9 0xc9 /* CPUCFG18 and CPUCFG19 */
> -#define MCSR9_L2U_SIZE_SHIFT 56
> -#define MCSR9_L2U_SIZE_WIDTH 7
> -#define MCSR9_L2U_SIZE (_ULCAST_(0x7f) << MCSR9_L2U_SIZE_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR9_L2U_IDX_SHIFT 48
> -#define MCSR9_L2U_IDX_WIDTH 8
> -#define MCSR9_L2U_IDX (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR9_IDX_LOG_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR9_L2U_WAY_SHIFT 32
> -#define MCSR9_L2U_WAY_WIDTH 16
> -#define MCSR9_L2U_WAY (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR9_L2U_WAY_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR9_L1D_SIZE_SHIFT 24
> -#define MCSR9_L1D_SIZE_WIDTH 7
> -#define MCSR9_L1D_SIZE (_ULCAST_(0x7f) << MCSR9_L1D_SIZE_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR9_L1D_IDX_SHIFT 16
> -#define MCSR9_L1D_IDX_WIDTH 8
> -#define MCSR9_L1D_IDX (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR9_L1D_IDX_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR9_L1D_WAY_SHIFT 0
> -#define MCSR9_L1D_WAY_WIDTH 16
> -#define MCSR9_L1D_WAY (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR9_L1D_WAY_SHIFT)
> -
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR10 0xca /* CPUCFG20 */
> -#define MCSR10_L3U_SIZE_SHIFT 24
> -#define MCSR10_L3U_SIZE_WIDTH 7
> -#define MCSR10_L3U_SIZE (_ULCAST_(0x7f) << MCSR10_L3U_SIZE_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR10_L3U_IDX_SHIFT 16
> -#define MCSR10_L3U_IDX_WIDTH 8
> -#define MCSR10_L3U_IDX (_ULCAST_(0xff) << MCSR10_L3U_IDX_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR10_L3U_WAY_SHIFT 0
> -#define MCSR10_L3U_WAY_WIDTH 16
> -#define MCSR10_L3U_WAY (_ULCAST_(0xffff) << MCSR10_L3U_WAY_SHIFT)
> -
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR24 0xf0 /* cpucfg48 */
> -#define MCSR24_RAMCG_SHIFT 3
> -#define MCSR24_RAMCG (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR24_RAMCG_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR24_VFPUCG_SHIFT 2
> -#define MCSR24_VFPUCG (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR24_VFPUCG_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR24_NAPEN_SHIFT 1
> -#define MCSR24_NAPEN (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR24_NAPEN_SHIFT)
> -#define MCSR24_MCSRLOCK_SHIFT 0
> -#define MCSR24_MCSRLOCK (_ULCAST_(1) << MCSR24_MCSRLOCK_SHIFT)
> -
> -/* Uncached accelerate windows registers */
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN 0x100
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN0_LO 0x102
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN0_HI 0x103
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN1_LO 0x104
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN1_HI 0x105
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN2_LO 0x106
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN2_HI 0x107
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN3_LO 0x108
> -#define LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN3_HI 0x109
> -
> /* Direct Map windows registers */
> #define LOONGARCH_CSR_DMWIN0 0x180 /* 64 direct map win0: MEM & IF */
> #define LOONGARCH_CSR_DMWIN1 0x181 /* 64 direct map win1: MEM & IF */
>

Hi all,

Are you OK with this change? Any comments will be much appreciated.

Thanks,
Tiezhu

2022-07-22 07:18:48

by 吕建民

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: Re: [PATCH v2] LoongArch: Remove LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 and some CSR definitions



On 2022/7/22 下午2:58, Tiezhu Yang wrote:
>
>
> On 07/20/2022 04:32 PM, Tiezhu Yang wrote:
>> According to the configuration information accessible by the CPUCFG
>> instruction [1] and the Overview of Control and Status Registers [2],
>> we can not see the descriptions about LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 (0x30),
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID (0xc0), LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* (0xc0 ~ 0xff) and
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* (0x100 ~ 0x109), they are not used in the
>> current kernel code.
>>
>> LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 may be used only in the firmware layer, it should
>> not be used in the future for kernel developers, remove the related
>> LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 definitions.
>>
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* is shadow of LOONGARCH_CPUCFG*, no need to access
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* and LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID through CSR instruction,
>> use CPUCFG instruction to access LOONGARCH_CPUCFG* is enough, so also
>> remove LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* and LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID definitions.
>>
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* may be not implemented in hardware, use CSR
>> instruction to access them is meaningless, so also remove the related
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* definitions.
>>
>> The intention of this patch is to keep consistent between the code and
>> the manual.
>>

Agree, they are should be cleaned up for consistency.

Acked-by: Jianmin Lv <[email protected]>

2022-07-22 08:11:14

by WANG Xuerui

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: Re: [PATCH v2] LoongArch: Remove LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 and some CSR definitions

On 2022/7/22 14:58, Tiezhu Yang wrote:
>
>
> On 07/20/2022 04:32 PM, Tiezhu Yang wrote:
>> According to the configuration information accessible by the CPUCFG
>> instruction [1] and the Overview of Control and Status Registers [2],
>> we can not see the descriptions about LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 (0x30),
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID (0xc0), LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* (0xc0 ~ 0xff) and
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* (0x100 ~ 0x109), they are not used in the
>> current kernel code.
>>
>> LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 may be used only in the firmware layer, it should
>> not be used in the future for kernel developers, remove the related
>> LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 definitions.
>>
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* is shadow of LOONGARCH_CPUCFG*, no need to access
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* and LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID through CSR instruction,
>> use CPUCFG instruction to access LOONGARCH_CPUCFG* is enough, so also
>> remove LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* and LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID definitions.
>>
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* may be not implemented in hardware, use CSR
>> instruction to access them is meaningless, so also remove the related
>> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* definitions.
>>
>> The intention of this patch is to keep consistent between the code and
>> the manual.
>>
>> [1]
>> https://loongson.github.io/LoongArch-Documentation/LoongArch-Vol1-EN.html#the-configuration-information-accessible-by-the-cpucfg-instruction
>> [2]
>> https://loongson.github.io/LoongArch-Documentation/LoongArch-Vol1-EN.html#table-overview-of-control-and-status-registers
>>
>> Signed-off-by: Tiezhu Yang <[email protected]>
>> ---
>>
>> v2:
>>   -- Remove LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID and LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN*
>>   -- Modify the patch subject and update the commit message
>>
>>  arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h | 229
>> ---------------------------------
>>  1 file changed, 229 deletions(-)
>> Hi all,
>
> Are you OK with this change? Any comments will be much appreciated.

Sorry for not getting to this earlier; $DAY_JOB is taking its toll on my
Linux contributions these days.

IMO, it's probably better to keep the definitions for documentation
purposes.

As a Loongson employee, you may be aware of the fact that your company's
"official" documentation is often lacking, and this information you're
removing is not found elsewhere. So for preserving this knowledge,
either (1) ask your documentation people to properly record these
information in official docs then you can go ahead removing them here,
or (2) just keep the content here if (1) isn't doable for any reason.
You do want 3rd-parties to freely develop on your platforms, making full
use of the products' capabilities, don't you? ;-)

2022-07-22 08:28:48

by Huacai Chen

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: Re: [PATCH v2] LoongArch: Remove LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 and some CSR definitions

Hi, all,

On Fri, Jul 22, 2022 at 3:34 PM WANG Xuerui <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> On 2022/7/22 14:58, Tiezhu Yang wrote:
> >
> >
> > On 07/20/2022 04:32 PM, Tiezhu Yang wrote:
> >> According to the configuration information accessible by the CPUCFG
> >> instruction [1] and the Overview of Control and Status Registers [2],
> >> we can not see the descriptions about LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 (0x30),
> >> LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID (0xc0), LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* (0xc0 ~ 0xff) and
> >> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* (0x100 ~ 0x109), they are not used in the
> >> current kernel code.
> >>
> >> LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 may be used only in the firmware layer, it should
> >> not be used in the future for kernel developers, remove the related
> >> LOONGARCH_CPUCFG48 definitions.
> >>
> >> LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* is shadow of LOONGARCH_CPUCFG*, no need to access
> >> LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* and LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID through CSR instruction,
> >> use CPUCFG instruction to access LOONGARCH_CPUCFG* is enough, so also
> >> remove LOONGARCH_CSR_MCSR* and LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID definitions.
> >>
> >> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* may be not implemented in hardware, use CSR
> >> instruction to access them is meaningless, so also remove the related
> >> LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN* definitions.
> >>
> >> The intention of this patch is to keep consistent between the code and
> >> the manual.
> >>
> >> [1]
> >> https://loongson.github.io/LoongArch-Documentation/LoongArch-Vol1-EN.html#the-configuration-information-accessible-by-the-cpucfg-instruction
> >> [2]
> >> https://loongson.github.io/LoongArch-Documentation/LoongArch-Vol1-EN.html#table-overview-of-control-and-status-registers
> >>
> >> Signed-off-by: Tiezhu Yang <[email protected]>
> >> ---
> >>
> >> v2:
> >> -- Remove LOONGARCH_CSR_PRID and LOONGARCH_CSR_UCAWIN*
> >> -- Modify the patch subject and update the commit message
> >>
> >> arch/loongarch/include/asm/loongarch.h | 229
> >> ---------------------------------
> >> 1 file changed, 229 deletions(-)
> >> Hi all,
> >
> > Are you OK with this change? Any comments will be much appreciated.
>
> Sorry for not getting to this earlier; $DAY_JOB is taking its toll on my
> Linux contributions these days.
>
> IMO, it's probably better to keep the definitions for documentation
> purposes.
>
> As a Loongson employee, you may be aware of the fact that your company's
> "official" documentation is often lacking, and this information you're
> removing is not found elsewhere. So for preserving this knowledge,
> either (1) ask your documentation people to properly record these
> information in official docs then you can go ahead removing them here,
> or (2) just keep the content here if (1) isn't doable for any reason.
> You do want 3rd-parties to freely develop on your platforms, making full
> use of the products' capabilities, don't you? ;-)
I agree with Xuerui, and I have already had an offline discussion with
Tiezhu about why we want to keep it.
There are various drivers that provide large register definitions, the
most notable one is amdgpu (their registers are obviously not "all in
use"), you can see drivers/gpu/drm/amd/amdgpu/sid.h as an example.

Regards,
Huacai

>
>