2022-11-17 16:20:41

by Simon Vogl

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: Connecting to a BR/EDR+BLE device a via dbus?

Dear all,

we are communicating with a headset-ish device that offers classic
bluetooth services and BLE characteristics in parallel.

We have code to talk to the Bluetooth classic part via bluetoothd/dbus,
and we have code for talking to the BLE parts based on the C-library /
gatt-client code ; both run in parallel for some time but not
super-stable, so I'd like to move the code over to a dbus version.

As the device starts advertising BLE characteristics only after a
classic connection has been established, it appears as a Bluetooth
classic device on the system bus, and I did not find a way to start GATT
discovery via the 'official' dbus-API.

I don't fear to tweak bluetoothd nor ~ctl, but would like to know if
someone already some development going in that direction?

Simon

--

VoXel Interaction Design |http://www.voxel.at
DI Dr.techn. Simon Vogl |[email protected]
Tomaschekweg 46 | +43 650 2323 555
A-4040 Linz - Austria |
Office address: Industriezeile 35, 4020 Linz (2nd floor)



2022-11-17 21:59:37

by Luiz Augusto von Dentz

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: Re: Connecting to a BR/EDR+BLE device a via dbus?

Hi Simon,

On Thu, Nov 17, 2022 at 8:20 AM Simon Vogl <[email protected]> wrote:
>
> Dear all,
>
> we are communicating with a headset-ish device that offers classic
> bluetooth services and BLE characteristics in parallel.
>
> We have code to talk to the Bluetooth classic part via bluetoothd/dbus,
> and we have code for talking to the BLE parts based on the C-library /
> gatt-client code ; both run in parallel for some time but not
> super-stable, so I'd like to move the code over to a dbus version.
>
> As the device starts advertising BLE characteristics only after a
> classic connection has been established, it appears as a Bluetooth
> classic device on the system bus, and I did not find a way to start GATT
> discovery via the 'official' dbus-API.
>
> I don't fear to tweak bluetoothd nor ~ctl, but would like to know if
> someone already some development going in that direction?

Perhaps what is needed is to connect ATT over BREDR that way you don't
need 2 bearers to be connected, bt_att already supports connecting
over classic but we never took the step to connect ATT once we figured
it supported the ATT PSM given is not very common to have a classic
profile that uses GATT attributes.

> Simon
>
> --
>
> VoXel Interaction Design |http://www.voxel.at
> DI Dr.techn. Simon Vogl |[email protected]
> Tomaschekweg 46 | +43 650 2323 555
> A-4040 Linz - Austria |
> Office address: Industriezeile 35, 4020 Linz (2nd floor)
>


--
Luiz Augusto von Dentz