2010-11-12 15:11:28

by Felix Fietkau

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: Re: [PATCH v2 0/9] ath5k: Add AHB support

On 2010-11-12 3:48 PM, Wojciech Dubowik wrote:
> This series of patches implements AHB bus support for ath5k driver.
>
> General comments for AHB bus support in ath5k:
> * most of the original patches came from Felix Fetikau. I have used
> them as a reference and ported to current git tree
> * tried with access point functionality with WPA2 and without encryption
> * tested on AR5312 for AHB and AR5414 and AR5212 for PCI
> * compat wireless from openwrt was used for testing these patches
> * last two patches have to be applied together because otherwise
> hardware will crash on reset if only number 9 is committed.
> I have kept them separated for better visibility.
> There are two false positive checkpatch warnings from them.
>
> Wojciech Dubowik (9):
> ath5k: Use Generic DMA for later support of AHB bus.
> ath5k: Introduce ath5k_init_softc function as in ath9k
> ath5k: Move PCI bus functions to separate file.
> ath5k: Use generic eeprom read from common ath_bus_opts struct.
> ath5k: Check if pci pdev struct is initialized in common functions.
> ath5k: Add a function to read chipset's MAC revision
> ath5k: Add initial registers values for radio RF2317 chip.
> ath5k: Add AHB bus support.
> ath5k: Fix reset and interrupts for AHB type of devices.
One thing I forgot: it would be nice if you could add my Signed-off-by
for patches that I co-authored, maybe also a From: for patches that were
almost entirely written by me.

Thanks,

- Felix


2010-11-12 15:30:03

by Wojciech Dubowik

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: Re: [PATCH v2 0/9] ath5k: Add AHB support

>On 2010-11-12 3:48 PM, Wojciech Dubowik wrote:
>> This series of patches implements AHB bus support for ath5k driver.
>>
>> General comments for AHB bus support in ath5k:
>> * most of the original patches came from Felix Fetikau. I have used
>> them as a reference and ported to current git tree
>> * tried with access point functionality with WPA2 and without encryption
>> * tested on AR5312 for AHB and AR5414 and AR5212 for PCI
>> * compat wireless from openwrt was used for testing these patches
>> * last two patches have to be applied together because otherwise
>> hardware will crash on reset if only number 9 is committed.
>> I have kept them separated for better visibility.
>> There are two false positive checkpatch warnings from them.
>>
>> Wojciech Dubowik (9):
>> ath5k: Use Generic DMA for later support of AHB bus.
>> ath5k: Introduce ath5k_init_softc function as in ath9k
>> ath5k: Move PCI bus functions to separate file.
>> ath5k: Use generic eeprom read from common ath_bus_opts struct.
>> ath5k: Check if pci pdev struct is initialized in common functions.
>> ath5k: Add a function to read chipset's MAC revision
>> ath5k: Add initial registers values for radio RF2317 chip.
>> ath5k: Add AHB bus support.
>> ath5k: Fix reset and interrupts for AHB type of devices.
>One thing I forgot: it would be nice if you could add my Signed-off-by
>for patches that I co-authored, maybe also a From: for patches that were
>almost entirely written by me.
>
>Thanks,
>
>- Felix

Sure. I will generate new set.

br,
Wojtek