2011-04-30 21:09:34

by Cedric Sodhi

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: Status of vgaswitcheroo - Devastating!

Dear list,

for more and more people it becomes either very difficult or, like for me, practically impossible to boot on a Dual-Card setup.

If you look arround the Ubuntu forums and many many other communties you will find that most, if not all users with such setups experience great problems, many of them receive blank screens, kernel panics, black screens, etc.

I for my part have a HP Touchsmart tm2 laptop with the Intel/ATI kind of setup and thought the commit message in GIT says that this is the exact type that is meant to be supported, I find myself unable to boot into my system.

Some live distros work (I've made the best experience with Mint 10 x64), but even for them the results are kind of random. In some cases the system boots, in some the screen remains blank or black, sometimes closing the screen and opening it again helps, sometimes I can reboot with Ctrl-Alt-Del, sometimes through SysReq, it's rather random.

To my consternation, the one and only commit related to switcheroo is over a year old and I have found no indication whatsoever that this is being further addressed.

I would very much dislike having to use Windows in order to use this PC, just because I can't even get it to boot.

I partially blame HPs atrocious BIOS for this desaster, so I really don't know how far this can possibly be resolved, but I hope it can, because according to the commit message it was at least possible on a different computer with a similar setup.

Please help!
--
NEU: FreePhone - kostenlos mobil telefonieren und surfen!
Jetzt informieren: http://www.gmx.net/de/go/freephone


2011-05-01 11:13:24

by Cedric Sodhi

[permalink] [raw]
Subject: Re: Status of vgaswitcheroo - Devastating!

With ATI (<M>, +kms) and Intel i915 (<M>, +kms) I manage to boot into console, but ONLY if I blacklist the Intel
drivers. If I probe the intel driver *WITH* modeset at *ANY* time (on boot by not blacklisting them or later), my screen
turns black.

Besides, on dmesg I get confirmation, that

VGA switcheroo: detected switching method \_.SB_.PCI0.GFX0.ATPX handle

but I do not get a vgaswitcheroo interface in debugfs of the kernel.

I attached dmesg, so maybe someone spots something.


Attachments:
(No filename) (488.00 B)
dmesg.log (72.85 kB)
Download all attachments